Source: CELLBAE INC. submitted to
VALIDATION OF RAPID TEST KITS FOR FOODBORNE PATHOGENS
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1029887
Grant No.
2023-33530-39325
Cumulative Award Amt.
$174,992.00
Proposal No.
2023-00495
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Jul 1, 2023
Project End Date
Feb 29, 2024
Grant Year
2023
Program Code
[8.5]- Food Science & Nutrition
Recipient Organization
CELLBAE INC.
2010 MILVIA ST
BERKELEY,CA 94704
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
Significance of the Problem Early, rapid and accurate detection of foodborne pathogens is important for outbreak prevention, maintaining food safety along the supply chain, and ensuring that food consignments are not subjected to unnecessary delays. Microbiological culture-based methods, such as those in FDA's Bacteriological Analytical Manual (BAM), are considered the gold standard for confirmatory pathogen detection. However, these methods are labor-intensive and can take more than 1-5 days to complete culture and analysis; hence, they are unsuitable for rapid mass screening. Also, technologies, such as polymerase chain reaction (PCR), enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA), mass spectrometry (MS), and nucleic acid sequencing, are accurate and relatively faster; thus, they have been widely adopted in laboratory settings. However, these methods rely on instrumentation and skilled manpower; hence, they are more suited for analytical/diagnostic laboratories, and are not widely utilized at the farms, where food are produced and processed.Lateral flow test kits are inexpensive, user-friendly, and provide results in about 15 minutes that can be read directly by the naked eye. These rapid test kits (RTKs) would be very attractive for on-site testing. However, conventional RTKs have inherent sensitivity limitations due to the reliance of gold nanoparticles (Au NPs) or latex beads as signal labels. Hence, there is a need to develop a much more sensitive RTK platform that can detect foodborne pathogens rapidly, accurately and on-site, so as to ensure food safety at each stage of food production, processing, and distribution. Cellbae Inc. has developed an RTK platform with enzymatic amplification to increase sensitivity. We aim to deliver a rapid and accurate RTK that will provide early, on-site and accurate pathogen detection for food safety applications. In particular, we are interested in developing and commercializing RTKs for E. coli (EC) O157:H7 and Salmonella Enteritidis (SE).MethodsWe will verify that our RTKs and preliminarily screened antibody pairs have good specificity for EC O157:H7 and SE, and also good sensitivity, such that we can reduce the initial enrichment time significantly, from overnight to ~ 4 hours. The verification will be done using heat-killed bacteria cultures as positive and negative controls. The limit of detection will be determined by serial dilutions, and the RTKs will be challenged with non-target cultures to determine specificity. In addition, we will determine the shelf-life of the RTK, and compare our performance/accuracy with commercially available test kits.Goals & BenefitsOnce we have verified that our EC O157:H7 and SE RTKs have satisfactory sensitivity and specificity, we hope to progress to a Phase II project, which will focus on research and development towards obtaining Performance Tested Methods (PTM) certification from AOAC (Association of Official Analytical Collaboration) International.After obtaining AOAC certification, we can proceed to market the products. With RTKs that have high sensitivity and specificity, famers will be able to detect outbreaks much earlier, and take preventive measures to prevent animal deaths and production loss. Food processing plants can also validate their processes to be pathogen-free, and be able to ship their products out confidently, without regulatory repercussions that may lead to financial losses. Regulatory authorities conducting food consignment checks can also be more confident of screening results from the RTK, and reduce the amount of tests required for confirmatory culture testing, resulting in time and cost savings.
Animal Health Component
45%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
10%
Applied
45%
Developmental
45%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
7123260110040%
7123270110010%
7123320110050%
Goals / Objectives
The goal is to develop rapid test kits (RTKs) for E. coli (EC) O157:H7 and Salmonella Enteritidis (SE) via analytical verification and AOAC certification, for eventual commercialization of the RTKs. We have obtained antibody pairs for both targets from our preliminary screening studies. In this Phase I project, we conduct analytical verification of the RTKs built with these antibody pairs by:Determining the limit of detection (LOD) via spiking heat-killed bacteria culture into real food matrices.Determining specificity via challenging the RTKs with non-related to closely-related non-target bacteria (> 20 non-target organisms for each RTK).Conducting an accelerated stability test at 65°C to determine if the antibodies or enzyme conjugates are stable enough for 2 years storage at ambient temperature.Comparing with currently available commercial lateral flow kits, such as Neogen's Reveal 2.0 for EC O157:H7 and Romer Lab's RapidChek® SELECT™ Salmonella Enteritidis for SE.If any of these return unsatisfactory results, we may require further antibody screening, and/or optimization of enzyme-antibody conjugation method to improve sensitivity, specificity, and stability.
Project Methods
MethodologyFrom the antibody pairs that were preliminarily screened in our previous studies, we will first determine the limit of detection (LOD) of the rapid test kits (RTKs) for the standard bacteria reference material (e.g. from the American Type Culture Collection (ATCC)) when spiked in real food matrices and relevant bacteria culture broth.Relevant food samples for the E. coli (EC) O157:H7 RTK include raw beef cubes (boneless), raw beef trim, and raw ground beef. Reference EC O157:H7 (e.g. ATCC ref# 35150) can be cultured in trypticase soy broth (TSB) at 37? for 18 h. The most probable number (MPN) from the culture can be determined using FDA BAM Chapter 4A with the Least Cost Formulations (LCF) MPN calculator with 95% confidence interval. The cultured sample can be diluted with meat sample preparation to the desired concentration for LOD determination. 25 g of aseptically prepared raw beef cubes, trim or ground beef followed by 225 mL of modified EC broth (mEC) are added to a filtered stomacher bag. The bag is then stomached for ~ 45 sec. The resulting mixture can be used to dilute the reference EC O157:H7 culture to the desired concentrations (in CFU/mL) and tested on the RTK to determine its LOD. The raw beef samples should be tested to be free of EC O157:H7.Relevant food samples for the Salmonella Enteritidis (SE) RTK include raw chicken and shell eggs pool. Drag swabs from poultry house may also be tested for environmental testing application. Reference SE (e.g. ATCC Ref# BAA-3160) can be cultured in TSB at 37? for 24 h. Viable cells of the inoculum can be enumerated by suitable MPN or dilution plate counting on trypticase soy agar (TSA) supplemented with 0.6% yeast extract. 25 g of aseptically prepared raw chicken, followed by 225 mL of buffered peptone water (BPW), are added to a filtered stomacher bag, and then stomached for ~ 45 sec. Shell eggs are first disinfected using established FDA BAM methods of 70% ethanol-iodide-iodine solution, and the contents are pooled. 25 mL of pooled sample is added to 225 mL of TSB supplemented with ferrous sulfate and mixed well. The samples prepared can be used to dilute the reference SE culture to the desired concentrations (in CFU/mL) and tested on the RTK to determine its LOD.For the initial inclusivity and exclusivity tests, target and non-target reference bacteria isolates can be obtained from ATCC as well. Over 20 EC O157 and non-EC O157 isolates can be inoculated in 10 mL of TSB, and cultured at 37? for 18 h. After incubation, the samples are tested on the EC O157 RTK to determine its sensitivity and specificity. Similarly, over 20 SE and non-SE isolates can be inoculated in 10 mL of TSB, and cultured at 37? for 24 h. The cultured samples are tested on the SE RTK to evaluate its sensitivity and specificity.The LOD, inclusivity and exclusivity tests will also be performed in parallel with commercially available lateral flow rapid test kits as a comparison to our RTKs' performance. For the accelerated stability test, we will validate if the antibodies, reagents, and formulations developed are stable for at least 2 years at ambient temperature. The testing will involve storing the a few sets of RTKs at an elevated temperature of 65? for 50 days. One set of RTK will be retrieved at each specific timepoint, and challenged with reference bacteria materials at a concentration of 3x LOD, to check whether the RTK is still able to detect the target.If any of the LOD, inclusivity/exclusivity, and accelerated stability tests return unsatisfactory results, we will further optimize the RTK via the following parameters:Antibody pairsNew antibody clones will be obtained and paired with each other in a matrix format to screen for satisfactory sensitivity/specificity with reference bacteria materials.Enzyme label/conjugateNew conjugation chemistries can be explored to conjugate the enzyme label to the detector antibody.Enzymes from different sources could be screened to determine which enzyme gives the highest signal intensity or has satisfactory stability.Stabilizing formulationComponents and their concentrations of the solution used to stabilize the antibodies and enzymes during the drying stage of RTK production will be optimized to ensure long-term stability.Concentrations of capture and detector antibodiesThe concentrations of antibodies and enzyme conjugate will be optimized to increase signal intensity or reduce background noise accordingly.MilestonesMonth 1:Purchase of reagents, antibodies, and bacteria reference materialsMonths 1 to 4:Analytical verification of RTKs (LOD, inclusivity/exclusivity)LOD in real food matrices and culture mediaInclusivity/exclusivity of target and non-target speciesMonths 1 to 5:Benchmarking RTKs with other major commercial lateral flow rapid test kitsMonths 5 to 6:Accelerated and real-time stability testing of RTKs equivalent to 2 years of storage at room temperatureMonths 2 to 5:Optimization of RTKs if necessary

Progress 07/01/23 to 02/29/24

Outputs
Target Audience:The target audience of our SalmonellaEnteritidis (SE) andE. coliO157:H7 (EC O157:H7)rapid test kits (RTKs) include food producers such as farmers and processing plants, food distributors, and regulatory authorities. Food producers, such as beef grinders (SE RTK) and/or poultry farm (EC O157:H7 RTK), would benefit from the rapid and on-site RTKs, which enable early diagnosis, medical intervention, and preventive measures. Although culturing method is the confirmatory method used by the Food Safety and Inspection Service(FSIS) Lab, the food industry has a need for early, rapid, on-site and accurate results. RTKs can provide rapid and convenient testing for surfaces, equipment and raw materials at different stages of production and processing (start, middle, and end). Samples can be sent for confirmatory tests if any RTK screening results indicate presumptive positive cases. Regulatory authorities provide food supply and safety regulatory oversight via testing/monitoring of food consignments to ensure food safety. If rapid and accurate test kits are available, it would help the authorities to avoid unnecessary consignment delays due to the conventional long culturing methods and any false-positive results. Our target audience will further benefit from our RTKs viademonstration of our RTKs, conducting on-site trials, and in-depth discussionsto determine if and how our RTKs can fit into their production/manufacturing and regulatory/inspection workflow. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?Professional development (individual study) Through performing the research goals of this grant, the PI gained more skills and knowledge with regards to culturing different bacteria strains, safety handling, and their storage. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Conventional foodborne pathogen detection techniques, such as culturingmethods or other lababoratory techniques such as polymerase chain reaction (PCR), which take couple of days or require trained personnel and expensive instrumentation. Using our enzymatic-amplified rapid test kits (RTKs) immobilized with selected antibody pairs, foodborne pathogen detection can be greatly accelerated in a sensitive and specific manner. With our RTKs, the enrichment duration could be shortened to a few hours (vs. overnight culturing), and then followed by a 15-minute runtime on the RTK. This will greatly benefit food producers and farmers, enabling rapid on-site detection at various stages and early diagnosis, medical intervention, and preventive measures to prevent losses. Regulatory authorities can also clear food consignment quickly, and prevent delaying food items from getting onto market shelves. Achieving major goals of the project Heat-killedE. coliO157:H7 (EC) andSalmonellaEnteritidis were spiked into food matrices, i.e. beef, chicken, and pork meat, at different concentrations, and then tested on the RTKs to determine the limit of detection (LOD) of the respective bacteria targets, without culturing. The SE RTK was able to detect as low as103CFU/mL of SE in chicken and pork matrices (not tested in beef), while theEC RTK was also able to detect as low as 103CFU/mL of EC O157:H7 in chicken, pork, and beef matrices. As a comparison with existing commercial RTK, the same experiment was conducted on Neogen's "Reveal® for E. coli O157:H7" and Romer Lab's "RapidChek® SELECT™ Salmonella Enteritidis"RTK. Both the Neogen's EC RTK wasonly able to detect as low as104CFU/mL of spiked EC O157:H7, while Romer Lab's SE RTK was only able to detect as low as 106CFU/mL of spiked SE. This demonstrates that our EC and SE RTKs are 10 and 100 times more sensitive as compared to existing EC O157:H7 and SE commercial kits, respectively. This will enable our kit to work with less bacteria culture/enrichment time, leading to reduced turnaround time in detection workflows of food producers/manufacturers, farmers, and regulatory authorities. To determine the sensitivity and specificity of ourEC O157:H7 and SE RTKs, theEC O157:H7 RTK was challenged with the targetEC O157:H7 strain (20 samples) and 117 strains (148 samples) of non-target organisms; whereas the SE RTK was challenged with targetSalmonellaGroup D1 (18 strains, includingSalmonellaEnteritidis) from 29 samples, and53 strains(63 samples) of non-target organisms. Our RTKs achieved excellent sensitivity and specificity as summarized in the table below. SE EC O157:H7 Sensitivity 96.6% 28/29 100% 20/20 Specificity 100% 63/63 99.3% 147/148 RTKs should be stable at room temperature (RT, 30°C) for at least 2 years to enable easy storage for on-site applications. To determine the stability of our RTK, we conducted an accelerated stability test, in which we stored a sufficient amount of RTKs at 60°C for 31 days to simulate 2 years storage at RT. Acrosssix time points, the RTKs were retrieved from storage and challenged withheat-killed target bacteria to determine if the RTKs' detection capability is affected. The RTKs were challenged with low levels of target bacteria, i.e. at their limit of detection of 103CFU/mL, and 5 replicates were performed. At Day 31 of storage at 60°C, both RTKs were still able to detect their target organisms at their LOD level (results summarized below), indicating that our RTKs are stable for at least 2 years at RT. Days at 60°C Detected at 103 CFU/mL 0 Yes 5/5 4 Yes 5/5 7 Yes 5/5 15 Yes 5/5 21 Yes 5/5 31 Yes 5/5 Finally we determined if we are able to shorten the bacteria culturing time required for target detection (vs. overnight culturing of 16 to 20 hours). A low (10 CFU/mL) and medium (100 CFU/mL) load of bacteria (both EC O157:H7 and SE, 5 strains each) were cultured for 6 and 8 hours, and then tested on our RTKs for detection. Most (8/10) of the medium load targets can be detected after a 6-hour culture, while most (8/10) low load and all (10/10) medium load targets could be detected after an 8-hour culture. The reduced culturing time as compared to overnight culturing, willgreatly benefit food producers and farmers, enabling rapid on-site detection at various stages and early diagnosis, medical intervention, and preventive measures to prevent losses. Regulatory authorities can also clear food consignment quickly, and prevent delaying food items from getting onto market shelves. 6 hours 6 hours 8 hours 8 hours Organism ID No. 10 CFU/mL 100 CFU/mL 10 CFU/mL 100 CFU/mL 1 E. coli O157:H7 ATCC 35150 No Yes Yes Yes 2 E. coli O157:H7 EC1/14 No Yes Yes Yes 3 E. coli O157:H7 EC2/14 No Yes Yes Yes 4 E. coli O157:H7 EC3/14 No Yes Yes Yes 5 E. coli O157:H7 EC1/15 No Yes Yes Yes 6 S. Enteritidis ATCC 13076 No No No Yes 7 S. Enteritidis ATCC 4931 No Yes Yes Yes 8 S. Enteritidis ATCC 31194 No No No Yes 9 S. Enteritidis S53/20 No Yes Yes Yes 10 S. Enteritidis S44/20 No Yes Yes Yes

Publications