Source: UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA submitted to NRP
SP: HLB-RESISTANT ROOTSTOCK CANDIDATES FOR THE CITRUS INDUSTRY: VALIDATING AND UNDERSTANDING DISEASE RESISTANCE
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
ACTIVE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1029411
Grant No.
2022-70029-38507
Cumulative Award Amt.
$1,163,487.00
Proposal No.
2022-06719
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Sep 15, 2022
Project End Date
Sep 14, 2025
Grant Year
2022
Program Code
[ECDRE]- Emergency Citrus Disease Research and Extension Program
Recipient Organization
UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA
G022 MCCARTY HALL
GAINESVILLE,FL 32611
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
Huanglongbing (HLB) is a devastating disease in Florida and threatens the US citrus industry. Citrus growers have been seeking a solution to HLB for over 15 years. The currently applied strategies for mitigating HLB are costly and unsustainable. The development and commercialization of HLB-resistant rootstocks proposed in this project titled "SP HLB-resistant rootstock candidates for the citrus industry: validating and understanding disease resistance" is a possible solution for sustainable citriculture in the US, bringing all commercial scions back into production in an HLB-endemic environment. This project will investigate rootstocks that do not test positive for CLas and appear resistant to citrus greening. Experiments will be conducted on inoculated plants in the greenhouse and inarching experiments will be conducted in an infected grove. The long term goals of this project are 1) to distribute HLB-resistant rootstocks to stakeholders; and 2) to understand the biological mechanisms behind HLB-tolerance and -resistance for breeding HLB resistant scions and gene editing purposes. The objectives of this project are 1) Verify HLB resistance of rootstock candidates and determine their impacts on scion performance; 2) Transfer rootstock resistant germplasm material; 3) Delivery of findings to stakeholders; and 4) Study underlying mechanisms of HLB resistance in rootstocks. This project will gather horticultural and multi-omic data to gain knowledge of the multidimensional underpinnings of HLB tolerance and resistance. This project's objectives align with 2.4 A cure for HLB-infected trees and strategies for maintaining their productivity and 2.8 Progress in the development of commercial citrus varieties (rootstocks and scions) with genetic resistance to HLB using traditional breeding techniques.
Animal Health Component
50%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
50%
Applied
50%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
2010999102034%
2010999104033%
2010999100033%
Goals / Objectives
The major goals of this project are 1) to commercialize and distribute HLB-resistant rootstocks to stakeholders in Florida, Texas, and California; and 2) to understand the biological mechanisms behind HLB-tolerance and -resistance for breeding HLB resistant scions and geneediting purposes.
Project Methods
Objective 1Methods: Experiments will be executed in two locations: 1) the greenhouse, and 2) the grove.Experimental design. Trees both in greenhouse and in the grove will be randomized with complete blocks and follow throughout the project period. Trees in the greenhouse and field will be grown using standard cultural practices. Trees in the greenhouse will be watered manually and trees in the field experiment will be watered by microjet sprinklers.Tree health assessment. We will collect visual ratings to describe tree decline by HLB disease using a method that ranges from 1 to 4 score. Scores are indicative of the proportion of the tree with HLB symptoms from severe to healthy.Plant sample collection. Tree foliage is divided into 4 sections and 4-5 leaves are collected per tree. Leaf samples are a mixed of symptomatic and asymptomatic samples. Fibrous root samples are collected by inserting a root auger. Chopped midrib of leaves and fibrous roots samples will be used.CLas detection via qPCR. To detect CLas in the selected citrus rootstock, DNA will be isolated from midrib of leaves of fibrous roots with a modified CTAB.Greenhouse ExperimentVerify HLB resistance of rootstock candidates and determine their impacts on scion performance in the greenhouseThe experimental design will be a randomized complete block design with eight replications that will include 15 HLB resistant advanced rootstock candidates and two conventional industry standard rootstocks. Once established, the candidate rootstock plants will be grafted with qPCR-verified CLas- (healthy uninfected control) and CLas+ (infected) sweet orange bud- sticks (a proven method that approaches 100% infection rate). HLB resistance of the selected rootstocks will be verified by qPCR testing of scion leaves and roots at the beginning and end of the experiment, as well as at three additional time points during the project period. The grafted plants will be grown for at least 12 months and then evaluated for CLas infection. Scion growth will be measured periodically over time, and at the end of the experiment during year 2, root growth will be evaluated using Winrhizo scan methodology. Verification of resistance will be determined if conventional rootstocks test positive and any of the HLB resistant candidates test negative after testing positive at the end of the experiment.Field ExperimentVerify HLB resistance of rootstock candidates and determine their impacts on scion performance in the fieldThe experimental design will be a randomized complete block design with four replications that will include four HLB-resistant advanced rootstock candidates and one conventional industry standard rootstock (US-942).Trees with HLB symptoms will be inarched with HLB-resistant rootstocks and a control. Variables associated with growth of the scions will be evaluated. These variables will include shoot growth of flushes, number of shoots per flush, number of leaves, percentage of leaves with HLB symptoms, water potential, and SPAD reading. CLas titer of scion and inarched rootstocks will be quantified three times during the experiment.Means by which results will be analyzed, assessed, or interpreted: HLB-resistant rootstock candidates that show promise to mitigate HLB in susceptible commercial scions will be assessed by tree growth, tree health, and Clas titer measurements (in both scions and roots). Grafted trees showing pre-HLB health and growth will be interpreted as potentially tolerant, and among these, any showing suppressed Clas titers will be interpreted as potentially tolerant.Objective 2Methods: Rootstocks that have been validated as HLB-resistant will be shipped to California for distribution and conservation in the Citrus Clonal Protection Program and the National Clonal Germplasm Repository for Citrus and Dates.Means by which results will be analyzed, assessed or interpreted: The total number of rootstocks in this study that are found to be HLB resistant and sent to other germplasm collections.Objective 3Methods: This objective will include a two-phase extension program. Phase 1 will include pre- and post-workshop questionnaires to determine the program's effectiveness in disseminating knowledge. Phase 2 will use information gained from stakeholders from Phase 1 to understand grower and other stakeholder opinions on desirable rootstocks, evaluate project success, and determine change in attitude over time during the project period.Before and after Phase 1 activities and Phase 2 activities of the extension program, a group of interested stakeholders will meet with project personnel to discuss workshop composition, the survey, and pre- and post-event questionnaire questions to ensure that acceptable metrics are used in project evaluation of success.Means by which results will be analyzed, assessed or interpreted: Data from the surveys that will be given to stakeholders during extension activities will be evaluated with statistical software after being manually inputted into a spreadsheet.Objective 4Methods: This objective will include the acquisition of multi-omic data sets that will be analyzed separately and together to understand mechanisms of HLB resistance in citrus. The multi-omic data that will be used in this project are genomic, transcriptomic, and metabolomic in scale along with plant phenotypic data.Genomics All 16 rootstocks and two controls will be resequenced using Illumina Novaseq technology, which can generate several billion 2 x 250 bp paired end reads. Reads will be aligned to reference genomes that currently exist or are being produced by Gmitter's group or elsewhere.Transcriptomics Tissues from the roots of rootstocks and leaves of scions will be collected at three time points during the project period: 1) at experiment commencement; 2) when the first HLB symptoms are observed; and 3) a takedown of the experiment.RNA will be extracted and prepared using standard protocols from Gmitter's labBar-coded libraries will be constructed for each selected rootstock-tissue-time for multiplexed Illumina Novaseq 6000 sequencing, with PE 150 read lengths. (https://www.citrusgenomedb.org/) for public access.Metabolomics Tissues from the roots of rootstocks and leaves of scions will be collected at three time points during the project period: 1) at experiment commencement; 2) When the first HLB symptoms are observed; and 3) a takedown of the experiment. Metabolomic tissue sampling in the greenhouse experiment will include all 15 HLB-resistant rootstocks and the two HLB-susceptible controls. Wang's lab has extensive experience in the metabolomics approaches, and has developed a citrus specific metabolomics platform with an extensive citrus metabolite library. Samples will proceed through a multi-step process including analysis using three technique platforms: LC-MS/MS(+ESI), LC-MS/MS(-ESI) and GC-MS.Multi-dimensional analysis Co-PD Jia's lab has developed advanced multi-omic approaches for identifying genetic networks of multi-dimensional variables that determine complex traits of interest, such as disease resistance and susceptibility. These new multi-omic methods, as well as commonly applied prediction models including best linear unbiased prediction (BLUP), least absolute shrinkage and selection operator (LASSO), and stochastic search variable selection (SSVS), have been demonstrated in various organisms including rice and humans, and are currently being utilized in an ongoing citrus study.Means by which results will be analyzed, assessed or interpreted: Besides the advanced multi-omic methodologies, standard statistical methods, such as t-test, ANOVA, and multiple comparisons, will be applied to analyze and interpret data of disease incidence and/or severity, fruit quality parameters, fruit yield, and survey and sensory evaluation. Statistical software R, SAS, and SPSS will be used for the proposed data analysis and interpretation.

Progress 09/15/23 to 09/14/24

Outputs
Target Audience:The target audiences reached by my efforts during this reporting period include citrus growers, packers, processors, and research and extension faculty and staff at the University of Florida/IFAS. The reason for targeting these groups is because they are the intended stakeholders related to this project. This project intends to leverage the huanglongbing resistant varieties to determine if these rootstocks could help growers grow trees that end up being more profitable in their farming and cropping systems. This work, if successful, would aid other stakeholders downstream, such as the packers and processors, who rely on citrus fruit to run a profitable and sustainable business. If there are no fruit to pack for the fresh market or squeeze for the juice market, this could cause packing houses to close down and processing plants to close as well. The academic stakeholders were also reached during this reporting period, mainly during stakeholder workshops for growers and processors, and these academic stakeholders would likely benefit from this work as they learn about potentially disease resistant cultivars, their pedigrees and downstream there will be genes, gene transcripts and metabolites to target for research purposes included for breeding and gene editing purposes. The efforts utilized to reach these primary stakeholders include workshops, small and large grower meetings and scientific conferences. Changes/Problems:There have been twoproblems that are being addressed. 1. The inarching experiment trees were destroyed by the grove management crew with an unapproved herbcide mix and spray. This created a delay in the onset of this component of the project where we will need to plant the rootstocks after the threat of freeze is gone this planting seasonin 2025. We will follow the trees during the growing season and attempt to inarch them during planting with plant protection, which will likely be individual protective covers. We will likely ask for a no cost extension because of this problem. 2. The rootstock candidates that are believed to be HLB resistant have been growing off, but some have been growingslowly compared to the industry standard. We had to start the experiment due to the time constraints and we did not use the rootstocks thart were too small to conventionally graft. We instead ony selected the rootstocks that grew off well enough to graft. We plan to propagate additional individuals and restart the experiment with as many rootstocks as possible and ask for a no cost extension. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?This project has provided a space for the graduate student on the project, and others, to be trained for various skillsets related to the project activities. The student is learning how to manage a greenhouse and irrigate citrus trees and is learning how to manage transcriptomic and horticultural data. In addition, the graduate student on the project is learning how to write proposals and manuscripts. The grad student is also learning how to collect, process and analyze horticultural data. The postdoc on the project in Co-PI Wang's lab is being trained on sampling citrus roots and leaves and how to handle and process the samples. The second postdoc is being trained and enhancing their skills related to gene expressions and analysis. This postdoc is being trained in transcriptomics to determine if thereare markers assocaietd with HLB tolerance or resistance. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?Due to the extreme cold weather this season, the rootstocks of interest that will be used for inarching will be planted toward the end of winter or the beginning of spring. The second and third timepoints will be sampled this year and the stakekholder group will be updated on the progress of the project. The data from the preliminary experiment and the first, second and third timepoints will be processed and analyzed. I will work with the grove management crew to make sure that they do not destroy the plants planted for inarching. We have the conventional standards in the group and established and there will be inarching done in the early spring and the trees followed througout the year.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? For the first goal, " to commercialize and distribute HLB-resistant rootstocks to stakeholders in Florida, Texas, and California", there has been not accomplishments because the project has not yet identified any material with validated HLB resistance, as this is something that will happen later in the project. For the second goal, "to understand the biological mechanisms behind HLB-tolerance and -resistance for breeding HLB resistant scions and gene editing purposes", there has been some key accomplishments. These key accomplishments include propagating the huanglongbing resistant accessions and the industry standards by means of hardwood cuttings and growing most of them off to a point where we can graft the infected "budsticks" or hardwood propagules on the candidates. Another key accomplishment is that we have successfully sequenced the genomes of most of the rootstock candidates in this project. Additionally, we have tested the rootstock candidates for CLas, the bacteria that is believed to be the cause of huanglongbing. Some of the candidate rootstocks were difficult to propagate with this method and failed the first round of propagation, but the second round of propagation was successful. We have also propagated the trees that will be used for the inarching experiment and have identified the grove in which this experiment will be executed. For the rootstock candidates that were successfully propagated during the first round of propagation, we have pruned the individuals back so that they can be easily grafted with the infected propagules. One selection was inarched successfullly into a prelimiary tree. Two rootstocks that were propagated from the HLB-affecte grove were found to have HLB. We are continuing to monitor these plants to0 see if they overcome the disease. For this reporting period, the trees for inarching had been planted at a site with four-year-old Valencia trees. The rootstocks that were ready for grafting had infected and non-infected budwood budded onto several of the candidate rootstocks. Samples were taken from these propagated Valencia scions for metabolomic and transcriptomic analysis. The transcriptomic analysis is underway with sequencing and the metabolomic analysis is in storage until the other time points are harvested. The rootstocks planted in the field by the four-year-old Valencia were destroyed with high dosage herbicide sprays and plants are being propagated to replant in a more controlled trial. There are three time points proposed for the greenhouse experiment. The first time point has been sampled and there remain two more time points until the project is completed.

Publications


    Progress 09/15/22 to 09/14/23

    Outputs
    Target Audience:The target audiences reached by my efforts during this reporting period include citrus growers, packers, processors, and research and extension faculty and staff at the University of Florida/IFAS.The reason for targeting these groups is because they are the intended stakeholders related to this project. This project intends to leverage the huanglongbing resistant varieties to determine if these rootstocks could help growers grow trees that end up being more profitable in their farming and cropping systems. This work, if successful, would aid other stakeholders downstream, such as the packers and processors, who rely on citrus fruit to run a profitable and sustainable business. If there are no fruit to pack for the fresh market or squeeze for the juicemarket, this could cause packing houses to close down and processing plants to close as well. The academic stakeholders were also reached during this reporting period, mainly during stakeholder workshops for growers and processors, and these academic stakeholders would likely benefit from this work as they learn about potentially disease resistant cultivars, their pedigrees and downstream there will be genes, gene transcripts and metabolites to target for research purposes included for breeding and gene editing purposes.The efforts utilized to reach these primary stakeholders include workshops, small and large grower meetings and scientific conferences. Changes/Problems:So far, there are no major changes. It is likely that there will be a no-cost extension request to make sure we haveample time for data analysis and transfer of materials. This request will likley occur in March or April of 2024 if needed. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?This project has provided a space for the graduate student on the project, and others, to be trained for various skillsets related to the project activities. The student is learning how to manage a greenhouse and irrigate citrus trees and is learninghow to manage transcriptomic and horticultural data. In addition, the graduate student on the project is learning how to write proposals and manuscripts. The grad student is also learning how to collect, process and analyze horticultural data. The postdoc on the project in Co-PI Wang's lab is beingtrained on sampling citrus roots and leaves. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?The results thus far have been disseminated to communities of interest via small and large group meetings. For the grower, packer, and processors stakeholder group, the results that we have so far (propagating and testing material for huanglongbing) has been disseminated at grower meetings. These grower meetings include annual grower meetings that host over 100 growers per year and smaller grower meetings, which host less than 100 growers per year. For the academic communities of interest, I have disseminated that results that we have thus far to a group of scientists at the USDA building that houses the Jefferson Auditorium in Washington D.C. All results have been disseminated via powerpoint presentation. In many cases, the dissemination of results thus far have included a few slides towards the end of presentations to demonstrate the status of this project. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?The trees will be subjected to the preliminary experiment to test gene transcripts during peak physiological activity and during the pre-dawn or evening hours to determine diurnal effects of gene expression of these seemingly huanglongbing resistant rootstock candidates. After that, the trees will be grafted with huanglongbing-affected Valencia and the leavesand roots of these accessions will be subjected to metabolomic and transcriptomic profiling over two to three timepoints. Additionally, horticultural data will be gathered during the next project reporting period. These samples will be sent to the lab for processing and the resulting genomic, transcriptomic, and metabolomic data will be utilized in multi-omic bioinformatics modeling to determine differences in gene expression and metabolomic profiles as they relate to disease status and horticultural traits. We will meet with the stakeholder advisory board to report on progress. The first phase of the extension program will also occur during this reporting period. And finally, the inarching experiment will be planted during the next reporting period of this project.

    Impacts
    What was accomplished under these goals? For the first major goal, "to commercialize and distribute HLB-resistant rootstocks to stakeholders in Florida, Texas, and California", there has been not accomplishments because the project has not yet identified any material with validated HLB resistance, as this is something that will happen later in the project. For the second goal, "to understand the biological mechanisms behind HLB-tolerance and -resistance for breeding HLB resistant scions and gene editing purposes", there has been some key accomplishments. These key accomplishments include propagating the huanglongbing resistant accessions and the industry standards by means of hardwood cuttings and growing most of them off to a point where we can graft the infected "budsticks" or hardwood propagules on the candidates. Another key accomplishment is that we have successfully sequenced the genomes of most of the rootstock candidates in this project. Additionally, we have tested the rootstock candidates for CLas, the bacteria that is believed to be the cause of huanglongbing. Some of the candidate rootstocks were difficult to propagate with this method and failed the first round of propagation, but the second round of propagation was successful. We have also propagated the trees that will be used for the inarching experiment and have identified the grove in which this experiment will be executed. For the rootstock candidates that were successfully propagated during the first round of propagation, we have pruned the individuals back so that they can be easily grafted with the infected propagules.

    Publications

    • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Other Year Published: 2023 Citation: Chater, J.M. (2023) "SP HLB-resistant rootstock candidates for the citrus industry: validating and understanding disease resistance" Washington D.C. November 3rd, 2023.