Source: NEW MEXICO STATE UNIVERSITY submitted to NRP
BRIDGING TRADITIONAL AGRICULTURE AND CLIMATE-ADAPTIVE ORGANIC AGRICULTURE IN THE SOUTHWEST
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
ACTIVE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1029107
Grant No.
2022-51106-38061
Cumulative Award Amt.
$744,971.00
Proposal No.
2022-04692
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Sep 1, 2022
Project End Date
Aug 31, 2026
Grant Year
2022
Program Code
[112.E]- Organic Transitions
Recipient Organization
NEW MEXICO STATE UNIVERSITY
1620 STANDLEY DR ACADEMIC RESH A RM 110
LAS CRUCES,NM 88003-1239
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
Vastly expanded agricultural production and rapid urban development have been the hallmarks of the growing economy in the western United States. The American West has been experiencing a "megadrought" and recent modeling studiespredict that alongside climatic changes, socio-economic changes will exacerbate water shortages and impact crop yields. The Southwest is essentially ground zero for the future impact of climate change.Many small farmers in the southwestern United States do not have access to technologies or programs that address the growing scarcity of water for irrigation. Organic agriculture can increase system resiliency, but many small farmers in the Southwest are hesitant about pursuing organic certification.Our project will address this hesitancy by exploring the commonalities between organic principles and traditional agricultural methods. Our Research program will use participatory research to identify "non-thirsty" summer cover crop species and blends that provide ecosystem services and contribute to farm income with limited water resources. We will also determine the abilities of regionally adapted cover crops to produce seeds during the monsoon season with modest supplemental irrigation. Our Extension program will enable farmers and a regional organic seed supplier to decide if they want to produce seeds of cover crops well suited for organic transition in the Southwest. Our Extension program also will initiate organic transition on cooperators' farms, and at community and educational demonstration farms. Our Education program will exercise cultural sensitivity in predominantly minority ethnic communities (Hispanic and Native American) and address language barriers to increase knowledge of organic transition requirements, and promote knowledge of the benefits and limitations of cover crops in the Southwest.This project builds on a foundation of previous work that identified heirloom crops and winter cover crops that add economic value and ecosystem services. Thecross-commodity, and plant (cropping) systems goalsof this project arealigned withUSDA strategic goal no. 1.1 "Use Climate-Smart Management and Sound Science to Enhance the Health and Productivity of Agricultural Lands."
Animal Health Component
30%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
30%
Applied
30%
Developmental
40%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
2052410106080%
1020199114020%
Goals / Objectives
Major goals: 1) Identify primary constraints to small farmers in the southwestern United States which prevent their adoption of regenerative, organic farming practices and organic certification 2)Determine traditional farming practices that are compatible with organic principlesin order toincrease system resiliency and farmer interest in organic certification 3)Assist farmers with initiation oforganic transition on their farms by producing and distributing educational materials in various media and host workshops to increase farmer knowledge of organic transition and certification requirements 4) Promote knowledge of the benefits and limitations of cover crops in the Southwest 5) Identify summer-planted cover crop species and blends that provide ecosystem services and contribute to farm income under limited irrigation 6) Determine the abilities of regionally adapted cover crops to produce seeds with modest irrigation 7) Establish seed processing facilities and networks that willenable farmers to produce seeds of cover crops well suited for organic transition in the Southwest. 8) Develop market opportunities for regionally adapted cover crop seed, leading to income streams for producers.Education Objective 1. Address farmer hesitancy to pursue organic certification by improving knowledge and awareness of the compatibility of organic methods with traditional agricultural systems, and of the expanded market opportunities and agroecological benefits that result from organic certification.Education Objective 2. Improve knowledge and awareness of procedures and requirements for organic certification.Education Objective 3. Provide training to farmers who wish to become contract seed producers of selected cover crops in both Spanish and English languages.Research Objective 1. Through participatory research, compare the ability of "candidate" cover crop species and mixtures to provide ecosystem services during organic transition with limited irrigation.Research Objective 2. Compare the ability of "finalist" cover crop species to produce a high-quality seed crop with modest irrigation input.Extension Objective 1. Through participatory research, establish a network of farmers to produce seeds for drought tolerant, regionally adapted cover crops.
Project Methods
Efforts:Education Objective 1 methods:At pre-season collaborator meetings, ask farmers to describe their traditional farming methods and crops they grow. Present overview or organic practices and opportunities for production of less water-thirsty cash and cover crops. Discuss how organic principles are aligned with the cultural values of different farmers.Discuss farmer perspectives, review their current farm plans, and discuss what the potential outcomes of the cover-crop selections might be, and in what ways they are likely to contribute to ecosystem services on their farms.Provide educational materials that will include technical note sheets, protocols for limited irrigation, plot management, and access to videos posted on the web.Organize farmer-to-farmer meetings at on-farm visits, with invitations extended to all interested parties.Education Objective 2 methods:We will present the certification plan for the NMSU Student Research and Education Gardens and discuss how each plan is unique for the particular farm operation. Farmers will be able to ask questions and interact with Rodale Institute staff and a consultant (farm advisor) who has twenty years of experience as an organic vegetable grower. An overview sheet will be provided so that growers can easily access relevant information.Education Objective 3 methods:In year three, a presentation will be made by a regional organic seed company owner who will discuss contract seed production for seed companies.A follow-up webinar will be hosted to allow interested parties to learn of these kinds of opportunities from national seed companies offering diverse organic seeds.Working with the Student Chapter of the National Agri-Marketing Association--develop a marketing strategy for the benefit of our producer/collaborators.Research Objective 1 methods:Convene pre-season collaborator meetings to review the goals and objectives of the project.Discuss farmer perspectives, review their current farm plans, and allow them to make their cover-crop selections.Provide technical assistance where needed to ensure proper planting of field plots and application of limited irrigation treatments.Provide needed guidance, assistance, and materials to program assistants and students to secure a. weed suppression data, b. soil quality and moisture measurements, c. canopy cover and biomass data from research plots and on-farm trials. a. 1. Determine, with grower input, which weeds are the most problematic, and scout fields and determine weed abundance prior to planting.b. i. Soil moisture probes will be installed so that irrigation applications can be provided in a consistent manner. ii. Student and program assistants will obtain soil samples for analysis. c. 1. The date when canopies close in each treatment will be recorded. ii. Plant tissue samples will be obtained by student and program assistants to determine nutritional and anti-nutritional parameters.Research Objective 2 methods:In years three and four, plant "finalist" annual cover crop species and provide sufficient irrigation to allow seed maturation. Harvest plots to determine yields and seed quality. a. Seed quality traits to be determined are: 100-seed weight, seed viability with tetrazolium staining, standard germination tests,accelerated aging tests, leachate assays for mechanical integrityExtension Objective 1 methods:The "finalist" cover crops that will be examined for their seed production potential will have been identified during the first two years of the project.Seed yield and quality of the tested cover crops will be determined following moderate irrigation treatments.Seed producers will be able to thresh and clean seed at any one of the three "hubs."A seed company representative will provide training on proper processing of seed.A video will be produced and posted on the web so that other interested parties can obtain access.Evaluation:Implement "pre-then-post" tests to measure changes in farmer knowledge regarding organic transition and certification requirements, organic farm management practices, cover crop ecosystem services,andseed production practices following educational workshops and meetings.Solicit "self-evaluations" and employ questionnaires in meetings with farmer-cooperators to determine a. their degree of adoption of organic, regenerative managementpractices b. whether or not they have obtainedaccess to new marketsA research protocol using secondary data, focus groups and targeted consumer surveys will be employed to determine the current and future demand in regional and established markets for the project's "finalist" cover crop species. Evaluation of potential strategies or modelsfor supplying the seed will be conducted by collaborators and external reviewers who will be solicited to act in an advisory capacity.Indicators of success will include:The identification of well-adapted, weed-suppressive "non-thirsty" summer cover crops and methods for assuring their ability to provide ecosystem services.The identification of summer cover crops that will be candidates for seed production.The adoption of more regenerative, organicpractices on farms.The adoption of better irrigation and soil moisture management practices on farms.Organic certification of some or all of the cooperating farmers operations.increased access to market opportunities for farmers'cash crops or new seed crops.Research findings that improve our state of knowledge regarding the adaptation of summer cover crops in semi-arid regions.Research findings that improve our state of knowledge regarding weed suppression during the organic transition period.

Progress 09/01/23 to 08/31/24

Outputs
Target Audience:Experiential learning (field plot research) internshipand special topics courses - undergraduate minority students (3 Hispanic). Conduct ongoing research through on-farm visits (approximately one dozen) and one-on-one consulting to assist New Mexico, small farmers, including those representing minority groups (Hispanic, Native-American, i.e. Isleta Pueblo, Navajo Nation). Support growers with farm management decisions and cover crop trials, Support from university scientists, andprofessional farm consultants associated with Southwest Grain Cooperative and Rodale Institute. An educational presentation on cover crop research by a graduate student to the public at Fabian Science Center field day Las Cruces, NM 10/10/23). Educational and organizational grower-cooperator meeting (Albuquerque New Mexico, 10/20/23) includes an educational presentation on cover crop research by graduate students to researchers and farmers/cooperators. Experiential learning opportunities for growers through farmer-to-farmer visits (Isleta Pueblo, Belen, NM, 10/21/23). Dr. Pratt (PD) and a graduate student attended the WSARE "Building Relationships" summit meeting in December 12-13, 2023, in Phoenix, Arizona. Graduate student made an oral presentation on first-year results from cover crop field research. Educational presentation to hay growers by a graduate student entitled "Using Cover Crops in Transitioning from Traditional Agriculture to Climate-Adaptive Organic Farming in the Southwestern US." New Mexico Crop Production Association 2024 Conference held in Ruidoso, NM on January 29-30, 2024. An educational presentation on cover crop research to the public by NMSU scientist (K. Djaman) and Rodale Consultant (S. Hilborn-Naluai) to public at Farmington Ag Science Center Field Day(June 27, 2024). Changes/Problems:Some farmer collaborators failed to plant cover crop trials due to personal reasons or circumstances beyond their control. It may be necessary to recruit additonal collaborators. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?In-person meeting (Fall 2023) with farmers and researchers in attendance. Our graduate student, Mr. Aminou Saibou, made a powerpoint presentation on his research findings, and farmers discussed their experiences with the candidate cover crops during the 2023 season. Discussions about cover crops and soil health ensued during the in-person meeting. We also had farm visits following the meeting at three farms (two at Isleta Pueblo and one near Los Lunas, NM - the Moya Farm.) We have continued individualized instruction and mentoring throughout the year. These have entailed in depth conversations about problem solving, daily management, longer term crop rotation and soil husbandry planning. Student interns have gained valuable practical experience in planning and management of field crops. One intern completed the LEADING Hispanics to Federal Agency Employment program (2023/2024). The graduate student has gained valuable experience in the conduct of cover crop fieldresearch. The graduate student has realized professional development by making educational presentations to other researchers, farmer/cooperators and the public at the Western SARE meeting in Phoenix (2023), at the New Mexico Crop Production Association 2024 Conference, and at the College of Agriculture Consumer Science Open House. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?The public was reached at a field day in Las Cruces (Fabian Garcia Science Center October 11, 2023) and the public (including the Navajo Nation) was reached at a field day at the Farmington Ag Science Center on 27th June, 2024. Presentation "Developing Region-Specific Guidelines for Cover Crops in New Mexico." What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?Continue ongoing outreach and consulting to assist New Mexico small farmers. Support growers with farm management decisions and cover crop trials, Support from university scientists, and professional farm consultants associated with Southwest Grain Cooperative and Rodale Institute. Ongoing conversations with farmers will reveal if there are specific traditional farming practices that are compatible with organic principles. We are in the process of developing "in-house" educational articles for future distribution. Further elaborate soil moisture usage/retention by different cover crops and different planting densities. Examine the potential of open-pollinated varieties of sorghum and millet to replace sorghum-sudangrass hybrids as candidate summer cover crop species for seed production. Conduct more systematic research on the optimal configuration of promising cover crop blends e.g. time of planting respective components of blends, relative contribution of components (grass v. legume) to final biomass. Facilitate consideration of farmers forming a Cooperative through assistance from the Rocky Mountain Farmers Union. Zoom meeting planned in December 2024 with Dan Hobbs, RMFU Cooperative Specialist. We will also be presenting at the Organic Seed Alliance Conference in Corvallis, Oregon, in February 2025. The title of our panel presentation is: "Grown by Southwest Farmers for Southwest Farmers: Trials and Pipeline for Regionally Adapted, Certified Organic Cover Crop Seed".

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Major Goal 1) Identify constraints to adoption of organic farming practices - Through interviews, site visits, and group meetings, we ascertained the following: Primary constraints on small farmers preventing adoption of regenerative organic practices include: the cost of certification fees and time spent on paperwork finding and/or creating new market opportunities additional knowledge about cover crops in the southwestern environment is needed concern about the cost of cover crop seed (primarily because of added shipping costs to our region) lack of planting, harvesting, and processing equipment when presented with a new crop opportunity Risks associated with transitioning to a new cropping system often inhibit farmers from doing so. Building and maintaining soil health takes time, and learning new skills and knowledge can be a challenging process. We learned that familiarity with organic management techniques per se is not a primary constraint in deciding to undertake organic certification. Many farmers have already been using some organic management practices. In addition to the above-mentioned obstacles, barrierstoadoption of organic certification tend to be farm-specific or case specific. Major Goal 2) - Determine compatibility of traditional and organic system, increase system resiliency and farmer interest in organic certification We have emphasized participatory research during the first two years of our project by conducting research in both (university) cover crop field experiments and in on-farm trials. We have made progress in introducing cover crops to farmers and connecting a clear relationship between their utility in both traditional and organic systems. Native/Indigenous farmers have told us that they are averse to using agricultural chemicals, even though they have been encouraged to do so by conventional extension educators over the years. Understanding that the soil is a living ecosystem helps farmers remember traditional values of sound land stewardship for the benefit of future generations. THe opportunity to seesoil moisture data has also given farmers more confidence that a limited irrigation strategy can still result inecosystem services from a variety of summer cover crops. Increased grower knowledge and awareness of procedures and requirements for organic certification was also achieved. Major Goal 3) Assist farmers with initiation of organic transition on their farms by producing and distributing educational materials in various media and host workshops to increase farmer knowledge of organic transition and certification requirements We continued making use of educational materials from California Certified Organic Farmers (CCOF), which will be our certifying agency, and the Rodale Institute. Ongoing support from our collaborators (Dr. Tim Vos, and Ms. Samantha Hilborn-Naluai) has shown the importance of cover crops as both a management tool and "soil builder" in the development of Organic System Plans. Farmer participation in field trials of cover crops gave them first-hand experience and observations to share with the entire group. The fall meeting in Albuquerque also focused on SeedLinked as a tool for farmers to use to report and share data. The co-founder of SeedLinked, Dr. Nicolas Enjalbert, joined us through video-link during the fall meeting. Growers improved their ability to conduct on-farm variety trials and how to use SeedLInked. Their understanding of trial rating systems and shared results improved. Growers have increasingly realized that organic certification is not merely a bureaucratic necessity. One farmer collaborator has completed the organic certification process. Another has submitted their application, undergone inspection, and should receive final certification next month. Major Goal 4) Promote knowledge and benefits of cover crops - Cover crops in the Southwest have not been as widely used as they should be. We shared knowledge about the benefits of cover cropping as a foundational practice for building soil health and fertility.Farmers realized the benefits of cover crops, but growing them under current mega-drought conditions is challenging. Growers learned that water conservation can be achieved by selecting drought and heat tolerant cover crops, and withholding irrigation longer than originally thought possible.Through research and educational efforts we are demonstrating the importance of cover cropping for soil water-holding capacity, which then would lead to a more resilient cropping system in the context of future climate change uncertainties. Farmers gained direct experience with the planting of summer cover crops that wasintegral to their knowledge base of cover cropping. Benefits and limitations realized included: • Successful cover crop planting with both grain drills and by broadcasting • Certain cover crops weremore or less competitive with weeds • Some cover crops weremore resilient under stress and producedseed heads/pods even during shorter seasons • Farmers learned timing of planting and irrigation is important to success of cover crops Major goal 5) Identify summer-planted cover crop species and blends that provide ecosystem services and contribute to farm income under limited irrigation We now have results from trials of the candidate grass and legume species across two seasons at two locations. Data from one 2024location is still being analyzed but some trends are coming into focus: 1) all candidate cover crops do well at one or more of the multiple eco-system services desired, but none of them appear to be "super plants" capable of high performance for theecosystem services measured -- biomass production, weed suppression, forage quality and water conservation. Sorghum-sudan grass hybrids make the most biomass and appear to have the best weed-supressive ability. 2) The legume species do not produce as much biomass as the best performing grasses, but they have very good forage quality. Some specific observations are also becoming more apparent: 1) there appears to be some preferential adaptation across elevations...e.g. foxtailmillet appears to be more adapted to higher elevation sites.2) Sunn hemp biomass production appears to be highly variable across environments. 3) Tepary bean hashigh forage quality. Performance of the grass/legume blends requires further study. Major goal 6) Determine the abilities of regionally adapted cover crops to produce seeds with modest irrigation We started performing observations this year. At some sites, it appears that birds may be a problem for sorghum and millet seed crops. A trial harvest of foxtailmillet showed that some weed species with similar seed size will have to be more efficiently removed from the harvested seed. No results to report at this time. Major goals 7 and 8 have been initiated. Nothing to report at this time.

Publications

  • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Accepted Year Published: 2024 Citation: Saibou, A., Schutte, B., Djaman, K., Pratt, R. & Idowu, J. (2024). Using Cover Crops in Transitioning from Traditional Agriculture to Climate-Adaptive Organic Farming in the Southwestern US. New Mexico Crop Production Association 2024 Conference held in Ruidoso, NM on January 29-30, 2024. https://newmexicocropproductionassociation.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/2024-conference-agenda.pdf https://research.nmsu.edu/Other/RCW/OralPresentations.html


Progress 09/01/22 to 08/31/23

Outputs
Target Audience:Experiential learning (field plot research)internships-undergraduate minority students(1 Hispanic, 2 Native American) Ongoing outreach through sIte visitsand one-onone consulting to assistNew Mexico and Colorado small farmers, including those representing minority groups (Hispanic, Native-American, i.e. Isleta Pueblo, Navajo Nation). Supportgrowers with farm management decisions and cover crop trials, Support from university scientists, andprofessional farm consultants associated with Southwest Grain Cooperative and Rodale Institute. Educatational and organizational grower-cooperator meetings (Spring - Farmington NM, Fall - Albuquerque New Mexico). Educational presentation on cover crop research by graduate student to grower/cooperators (Albuquerque, NM 10/20/23). Educationalpresentationon cover crop research by graduate student to public at Fabian Science Center field day (Oct. 10, 2023) Educationalpresentationon cover crop research to public by NMSU scientist (K. Djman) and Farm Adviser(T. Vos) to public at Farmington Ag Science Center(Aug 17, 2023) Experiential learning opportunities for growers through farmer to farmer visits (Isleta Pueblo, Belen, NM, 10/21/23). Education outreach for regional growers, millers, bakers, and consumers - Grain School in the Field (8/4/23, Cortez Colorado) Southwest Grain Cooprative discussing cover crops using grains and legumes (T. Vos, Farm Adviser) Education outreach for regional growers, millers, bakers, and consumers -Grain School in the Field (8/5/23, Cortez Colorado) Biodiversity in the Field with New Mexico State University (R. Pratt, NMSU Professor), Rocky Mountain Farmers Union, and Apple Biodiversity Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?In-person meeting (spring 2023) to introduce farmers and researchers to each other, provide information on grant, discuss cover crop and soil health In-person meeting (fall 2023) to review the season. This included farmer collaborator farm visits that included individualized instruction and mentoring, having in depth conversations together about problem solving, daily management, longer term crop rotation and soil husbandry planning. Student interns have gained valuable practical experience in planning and management of field crops. The graduate student has gained valuable experience in the conduct of cover crop field trial research . The graduate student has realized professional development by making educational presentations to grower/cooperators and the public. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?The public was reached at a field day in las Cruces (Fabian Garcia Science Center) and the public (indlucding the Navajo Nation) was reached at a field day at theFarmington Ag Science Center. The public (primarily growers, millers and bakers) was reached through presentations (2) at the Colorado Grain School in the Field event. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?Continue ongoing outreach and consulting to assistNew Mexico and Colorado small farmers. Supportgrowers with farm management decisions and cover crop trials, Support from university scientists, andprofessional farm consultants associated with Southwest Grain Cooperative and Rodale Institute. Provide criteria and examples for trait evaluation using hedonic one to five (stars) rating scale when using SeedLInked variety trial evaluations. Ongoing conversations with farmers will reveal if there are specific traditional farming practices that are compatible with organic principles. We are in the process of developing"in-house"educational articles for futue distribution. Continue research plot and on-farm trials of cover crops.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Major Goal 1) Identify constraints to adoption of organic farming practices - Through interviews, site visits, and group meetings, we ascertained the following: Primary constraints on small farmers preventing adoption of regenerative organic practices include: the cost of certification fees and time spent on paperwork, finding and/or creating new market opportunities, lack of knowledge about organic farming systems lack of planting, harvesting, and processing equipment when presented with a new crop opportunity In many cases, producers are located far from urban centers, which makes the logistics of marketing a challenge. Risks associated with transitioning to a new cropping system often inhibit farmers from doing so. Building and maintaining soil health takes time, and learning new skills and knowledge can be a challenging process. Major Goal 2) - Determine compatibility of traditional and organic system, increase system resiliency and farmer interest in organic certification Traditional farming practices include livestock as an integral part of the system, which represents a strong link tothe regenerative paradigm. We are working on cover crop trials in research plots and on-farm trials. We have made progress increating a bridge and demonstrating a clear relationship between traditional and organic systems. Also, many Native/Indigenous farmers will tell you that they are averse to using agricultural chemicals, even though they have been encouraged to do so by conventional extension educators over the years. Understanding that the soil is a living ecosystem helps farmers remember traditional values of stewardship and taking care of the land for future generations. Increaed grower knowledge and awareness of procedures and requirements for organic certification was achieved. Major Goal 3) Promote knowledge of the benefits and limitations of cover crops in the Southwest Zoom meeting focused on the organic transition process and requirements. Discussed the development of Organic System Plans as both a thought experiment and valuable management tool. Growers realized that organic certification isnot merely a bureaucreatic necessity. Zoom meeting focused on SeedLinked as a tool for farmers to use to gather data. Growers improved their ability to conduct on-farm viriety trials and how to use SeedLInked. Their understanding of trial results advanced. This year we have been making use of educational materials from CCOF, which will be our certifying agency, and Rodale Institute. Major Goal 4) Promote knowledge and benefits of cover crops - Cover crops in the Southwest have not been as widely used as they should be. Wesharedknowledge about the benefits of cover cropping as a foundational practice for building soil health and fertility. Growers learned that water conservation can be achieved by selectingdrought and heat tolerant crops, which is the focus of the cover crop trials we've undertaken. Growers realized the benefits of cover crops are clear, but growing them under current mega-drought conditions is very challenging. Through research and educational effortswe are demonstratingthe importance of cover cropping for soil water-holding capacity, which then would lead to a more resilient cropping system in the context of future climate change uncertainties. Farmers gained directexperience with the planting of summer cover cropsis integral to the knowledge base of cover cropping. Benefits and limitations irealized ncluded: Successful trialing of cover crop planting with drill Certain cover crops being less competitive with weeds Certain cover crops being more resilient under stress and producing seed heads/pods Farms learned timing of planting is very important to success of cover crops Major goals 5 through 8 are in progress. Nothing to report at this time.

Publications