Source: HOOD CANAL MARICULTURE INC submitted to
PARADIGM SHIFT TECHNOLOGY FOR SCALABLE, HIGH-DENSITY, HIGH-YIELD COMMERCIAL MULTI-SPECIES MARICULTURE
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
ACTIVE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1029027
Grant No.
2022-39411-38251
Cumulative Award Amt.
$650,000.00
Proposal No.
2022-04389
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Sep 15, 2022
Project End Date
Sep 14, 2025
Grant Year
2022
Program Code
[8.7]- Aquaculture
Recipient Organization
HOOD CANAL MARICULTURE INC
7793 HANSEN RD NE
BAINBRIDGE ISLAND,WA 981101614
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
PROJECT SUMMARY/ABSTRACT: Farm efficiency and commercial competitiveness for kelp farming and multi-species mariculture (kelp plus shell-fish) will be meaningfully enhanced through successful final development and commercialization of novel technology that Blue Dot Sea Farms (BDSF) has significantly demonstrated/advanced under Phase 1 SBIR. In addition to improvements in production efficiencies and creation of a significant marketing advantage, the technology base leads to the ability to franchise to other farmers and create a drive towards more sustainable and commercially viable broad-based mariculture in the United States. BDSF is proposing a novel, semi-rigid, growing support framework, based on using recycled carbon fiber (rCF) cable, that will replace and ultimately eliminate conventional plastic line in the farm marine environment. The macro-algae growing support system will have the capability to easily accommodate structures for shellfish and other aquaculture species, with demonstrated potential for significant improvements in farm systems efficiency. The approach enables:A semi-rigid structure that eliminates flexible "plastic" (e.g. polypropylene, nylon, etc.) rope, and is designed so marine mammal entanglement is physically impossible.Significantly closer line spacing to gain 4-6X yield improvements, as the semi-rigid rCF cables hold their position during storms/severe currents, eliminating entanglement between lines and thus abrasion of developing kelps which is common with poly-rope.Improvements in longevity by an order of magnitude over poly rope, resulting in lower capital replacement, operating and maintenance costs.Faster and easier seeding with inoculated twines that is very simple to automate.Marine biofouling cleaning to occur with either a light abrasive pad cleansing (demonstrated) or with high-pressure steam (postulated), greatly improving labor productivity, and removing contamination by harmful micro-plastics.Combined performance improvements that result in multi-cropping (we demonstrated in-situ harvest, cleaning, reseeding, and re-placing lines in one day), without having to remove the system, disconnect anchors, etc. which was not feasible with poly-rope.Anticipated results will provide a basis for commercial launch, including:Completing optimization of line spacing for the rCF lines;Completion of systems development for in-situ line cleaning;Research and demonstration into automation and cost analysis for a semi-rigid system, including multi-line harvest, clean, and re-seeding;Research into farm systems manufacturing and capability to achieve rapid deployment of scaled systems in a turn-key solutions business model; and,Research on multiple species farming and annual kelp multi-cropping farming and estimation of the limits on applicable species and recommendations for preferred species.The commercial potential if fully realized could impact all aquaculture farms as we drive to reduce and eventually eliminate plastics introduced via marine farming systems. The improved yields and annual multi-cropping show an excellent business case. In 5 years, we anticipate having 25 large-scale farms deploying this system in the US, as well as developing an international export sales potential.
Animal Health Component
75%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
75%
Developmental
25%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
40253301070100%
Goals / Objectives
The major goals of the project will be to move the technology forward from the TRL 5demonstrated in Phase 1 SBIR to TRL 8. The project will research the critical aspects of the semi-rigid rCF (recycled carbon fiber) cable system, including: improving manufacturing of the cable and fittings to determine and ensure longevity, including long-term fatigue testing under relevant loading scenarios;designing and developing systems for automating the seeding, harvesting, and cleaning of lines;researching and developingthe capability to include shellfish species in the kelp farm set-up (to include cage and support system designs, and evaluating shading, depth control, and integrated farm operations with kelp crops that have much shorter growth cycles); refining the line spacing for farms in three different regions of the country (Alaska, Maine, and Washington); developing vessel designs for bespoke kelp farm operations; and, developing the data required to refine the commercialization plan and to enter market opportunities. The technical work plan also includes the evaluation of loads on the lines at various stages of kelp growth and correlate this directly to current flows experienced in the trial setting, so we can have high-fidelity and real-world data for line dimension sizing and fitting loads, rather than rely solely on data from synthetic kelp in tow tanks.
Project Methods
The project will be a coordinated effort around both design analysis and experimental validation with in-field trials. Utilizing the existing farm in Hood Canal, WA, approximately 1/4 of the farm area will be set-up with a growth lattice for macroalgae and support systems for bi-valve cages. Two additional developmental/demonstration sites will be designated in Alaska and Maine of a size TBD. Design analysis of the stiffness of these recycled carbon fiber cables with attached load of their macroalgae will be run to evaluate options for cable spacing. The closest practical cable spacing (limited by operations parameters) will be assembled and deployed with seeded lines and cages. The lines will be placed in the water column such that currents and nutrients will be comparable to those over the traditional plastic rope sides of the farm. Growth monitoring will occur on a bi-weekly basis with documentation of the relative performance of the systems. Data collected will be shared with program partners and used to develop the scientific input required for cost/benefit/societal analysis, including for food production; determining specific areas of improvement and research anddevelopment needed in Phase II; environmental impacts both positive and negative; and to develop indicators and guidance for species optimization. Farm systems will be instrumented for determining the local strains on rCF cables and current monitoring via doppler instruments will be collected and correlated to strains and kelp loading (mass and dimension.) The reduced data and results of the approaches will be written up for publication reviews and will be disseminated to other farm operators and cross-sections of the communities impacted. Farm design parameters will be developed and analysed to begin preparing design suite options if the system is used in different locations and with different flow and anchoring provisions. Design and analyses will be compared to existing literature and participant farm experiences to determine the opportunities for intellectual property protection. Data will inform a thorough commercialization plan and a techno-economic analysis to provide confidence in scalability of the approach. Experts in species selection and growth habit on the team will develop input for species selection and optimization as well as look into specific farm management practices that can be significantly improved through the use of this semi-rigid farm system, including items such as cage rotation, wet-dry cycling, and water column usage optimization. Their input will inform experiments to evaluate the hypotheses, and either new designs will be deployed (should time allow) or computer simulations used to demonstrate anticipated performance and experimental design for future work.Design of automated systems will be prepared from data of Phase 1, and reduction to practice for each of the unit subsystems will be completed and demonstrated on at least one of the farm sites. Systems for the evaluation of combined shellfish and kelp species will be designed and deployed utilizing current and new data, and these systems will also be deployed for evaluation in at least one of the trial sites. Design for optimum food and profit will be created based on these inputs, and research and demonstration of how this can be accomplished within the confines of typical farm equipment and labor will be analysed.

Progress 09/15/22 to 09/14/23

Outputs
Target Audience:We have held detailed discussions and information exchanges with a range of target audiences, including growers, funders, purchasers, product developers, and eco-system service interested parties. These are ongoing andincluded: Atlantic Sea Farms Cascadia Seaweed (BC, Canada) Cawthorn Institute (NZ) Maine Aquaculture Sea-Grove Kelp Vashon Kelp Forest Pacific Sea Farms The Nature Conservancy Builders Fund DowAKSA Maritime Blue Makah Tribe Jamestown S'Klallam Tribe Alaska Fisheries Development Council Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?Project worked with macroalgae farmers in several regions to enable their understanding of the results and benefits, significant ongoing interactions with several of these farmers will lead to test deployments in the near future to complement our interanl evaluations of efficacy of the overall system. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?We have and will continue to directly interact with others in the community, including tours of the Hood Head farm and visits to Blue Dot Sea Farms and Composite Recycling Technology Center. One presentation was given on Phase 1 results and once the refined systems are in place and data gaind from the 2023 season we will further disseminate results through presentations at technical conferences. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?We will perform the following in the next reporting period: Refine manufacturing so we are ready to supply farms at scale. Deploy 3rd generation system at Hood Head and expand the rCF system so we collect additional productivity data. Collect growing and farm operation (labor) productivity data. Deploy small open ocean test farm in NZ for a potentially large customer. Complete the combined shellfish/macroalgae system design. Finalize the commercialization plan (well under way at this point.) Collect and evaluate real-world line strain data as a function of current and kelp loading and use to predict long-termperformance in various regions of the country. Grow-out the 3rd Generation 2023-2024 season and evaluate any potential issues in line spacing, new spreader bar designs, and new harvest/cleaning/seeding at scale. Test efficacy of the natural fiber twine for innoculation, wrapping, and hold-fast development, also test for in-situ decomposition over the growing season to determine how these materials can match up with production cycles. Evaluate other macroalgae species for multi-cropping. Develop designs for bespoke farm vessel encompassing all the improvements demonstrated to date and also over the 2023-2024 season. Look for opportunities to patent or otherwise protect IP generated in the project and also disseminate results of the SBIR efforts to the broader community.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? In this Period of Performance, the following was worked on and achieved these major accomplishments: Second farm deployment of generation 2 of the rCF cable system and support interface components, improved the attachment fittings to overcome galvanic corrosion issues and eliminated all galvanized steel fitting, replacing with 316 stainless steel with isolators between fittings and carbon fiber spreader bars and lines. Designed new approach to fabricating the rCF lines for faster production and lower labor cost to further lower the overall system cost. Improved the line surface finish as a side benefit of the new approach. Remanufactured a third generation of line attachments to make deployment more rapid and improve the productivity of farm team. Redesigned and manufactured new buoy and spreader bar systemsto allow even easier harvesting, cleaning and reseeding. Deployed above as noted at the Hood Head Kelp Farm and demonstrated that yield improvements from Phase 1 SBIR were also consistently achieved during Phase 2 SBIR trials, a 6.8X factor of improvement over the parallel section of the farm that used poly-rope. Developed and implemented a new spooling system to more robustly handle long lengths of rCF line necessary to efficiently scale operations. Demonstrated a new and improved method of line cleaning that was significantly faster and easier than previous Phase 1 methods (refer to Phase 1 report - first trials were an order of magnitude less time and effort to clean than poly rope, hence this is a significant even further increase in farm labor productivity.) Procured and deployed a doppler flow sensor to collect data on the localized currents within the rCF line section of te farm. Designed and fabricated a customline strain monitoring system with data logger so we can track actual rCF line loads as a function of the current and size/density of the macroalgae throughout the growing season (data will be collected on the third trial deployment in late 2023.) This will be the first such real-world data from in-water growing systems to our knowledge and can be related back to tow-tank data and simulated kelp loading. Performed mechanical property testing (strength, modulus, failure mode)on rCF line to connectors in our Universal Testing Machine, as well as strength testing for the spreader bars. Procured samples of natural fibers for use as a sacrificial twine for seeding lines, innoculation and testing will be done in the next PoP. Interfaced with kelp farmers in Maine and Alaska to evaluate their methods of growing and deployment (anchors, buoys, etc.) to determine the feasibility of integrating into their systems. Interfaced with open-ocean macroalgae farmers in New Zealand to evaluate doing a trial system in parallel with their poly-rope systems. Began design process on third generation system to be deployed in Fall 2023, with a goal of eventually removing all metal components as these are the items providing long-term failure points with the more rigid rCF lines, as well as being more expensive than our alternatives.

Publications