Source: NEW MEXICO STATE UNIVERSITY submitted to
APPRECIATIVE INQUIRY & COMMUNITY CAPITAL SUMMIT: CREATING A SHARED VISION OF A RESILIENT FOOD SYSTEM
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1028236
Grant No.
2022-67024-36384
Cumulative Award Amt.
$50,000.00
Proposal No.
2021-11992
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Jan 1, 2022
Project End Date
Dec 31, 2023
Grant Year
2022
Program Code
[A1642]- AFRI Foundational - Social Implications of Emerging Technologies
Recipient Organization
NEW MEXICO STATE UNIVERSITY
1620 STANDLEY DR ACADEMIC RESH A RM 110
LAS CRUCES,NM 88003-1239
Performing Department
AXED
Non Technical Summary
More Resilient Food Supply Network:Achievingresilience--theoverarching, long-term goal of the Summit and our related other planning activities--will alsosupportmanyof the strategic objectives enumerated in the USDA Strategic Plan for 2018-2022, including:Objective 2.2:Creating New Markets and Supporting a Competitive Agricultural SystemObjective 2.3: Preventing and Mitigating the Spread of Agricultural Pests and DiseaseObjective 4.1: ExpandingRural Business OpportunityObjective 5.3: EnhancingProductive Agricultural LandscapesObjective 6.2: EnsuringLands and Watersheds Are Sustainable, Healthy, and ProductiveObjective 7.1: PreventingFoodborne Illness and Protect Public HealthObjective 7.2: ProvidingAccess to Safe and Nutritious Food for Low-Income People.It will also contribute to progress on three of the National Academy of Engineering's grand challenges:Providing Access to Clean WaterManaging the Nitrogen CycleRestoring and Improving Urban Infrastructure.Finally, a more resilient food supply network willadvance the United Nations' Sustainable Development Goal#12, "Ensure sustainable consumption and production patterns,"byreducing food waste?andfood losses along production and supply chains.NetworkFormation andIdentificationof Opportunities:One definition ofa"wicked problem" isthat it is a symptom ofanotherproblem (Rittel&Weber,2018).Theprocessofaddressing it engenders new opportunities and surfaces additional challenges. To foster continuing engagement, stakeholders will be asked to joinlarge proposals (e.g.,NSF ERC andAFRI CAP projects) andto formsmaller teams to develop projectsthataddress specific elements of the resilience challenge.Transformation of Agricultural Engineering:Cross-fertilization will?promote the incorporation of agricultural needs into?the dominant engineering disciplines (mechanical, civil, and electrical).To help realize this, we will work with colleagues?at two institutions affiliated with our NSF planning grant to?suggest enhancements to their?Packaging Engineering and Systems Engineering?programs.?These can serve as?models for similar expansions elsewhere.Beyond this, we will advocate for developing and expanding degree programs in Agricultural Engineering and Bioprocessing.?There are currently fewer than 40 such programs in the United States, many of which do not offer doctoral degrees.?To train students and postdocs in these programs, we will engage stakeholders toassist with thedevelopment ofexperiential and problem-based curricula that use case studies, industry-guided design projects, and internships.Workforce Development:We anticipate that stakeholders inculcated with resilience principles will incorporate them intoexisting certificate programs?(such as?ANSI's Certified Food Manager, or the Association for Supply Chain Management's Certified Supply Chain Professional). Participation by community colleges, local governments, and industry will foster partnerships to create stackable and latticed credentials for trainees indocumentation processes,market interfaces, logistics, and automated equipment operation (based on standards from the Manufacturing Skill Standards Council).
Animal Health Component
90%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
10%
Applied
90%
Developmental
0%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
50250103010100%
Knowledge Area
502 - New and Improved Food Products;

Subject Of Investigation
5010 - Food;

Field Of Science
3010 - Economics;
Goals / Objectives
The Summit hasthreeoperationalgoals/objectives:Integrate knowledge from six sectors to createaconvergentvisionofresilientfoodnetworks.Identify knowledge gaps and setpriorities for aportfolio of research, extension, and education projects.Form teams todesign these projects anddevelopproposalsto fundthem.Secure commitments to join a proposal for a majorinitiative (e.g.,NSF Engineering Research Center, AFRI CAPproject, orafoundation-supportedcenter of similar scope).
Project Methods
We will convene fromJanuary 10-13, 2022,at theNew Mexico Farm and Ranch Heritage Museum in Las Cruces, New Mexico. The museum has spaces suitable for plenary/large group sessions, breakout/small group session, and dining.Participants will progress through a daily sequence of Appreciative Inquiry themes, from Discovery to Dreaming to Design to Destiny.The Community Capitals Framework will be infused throughout all activities to maintain attention on integrating food systems into the four major aspects of Appreciative Inquiry.Interspersed between substantive work on food systems, we will tour exhibits illustrating the evolution ofsouthwestern agricultural technology to reinforce the possibility of positive change. There also will be brief artistic interludes to stimulate participants to imagine the potential for innovation.

Progress 01/01/22 to 12/31/23

Outputs
Target Audience:Contemporary food supply chains--optimized for high volume, low cost, and global reach--are not infallible [1]. Food deserts persist while substantial amounts of food go to waste [2-4]. Small enterprises lack market intelligence and market power to find and exploit opportunities. Technical and regulatory requirements restrict entry and participation [5]. Natural disasters and the current pandemic disrupt production and delivery [6]. Consumers are still sickened by contaminated [7] or improperly processed foods [8]. The targeted societal impact of the FRESCH ERC is to improve the nation's health [9] and prosperity by both avoiding or mitigating disruptions [10] and by exploiting opportunities to expand food variety and profitability [11]. An important aspect of the FRESCH ERC's work is to shift our thinking from linear "food supply chains" to flexible and resilient "food networks." Resilience within food networks means that whatever disruptions do occur have smaller negative impacts or greater positive ones. Investment in adaptive capacity within the food industry provide balance against the continuous drive for leaner (but more brittle) food systems, especially when "lean" is at odds with other sustainable development goals, such as increasing the incomes of food producers (within the United Nations' Goal 1 to end poverty) and ensuring decent work for all (Goal 8) [12, 13]. Resilience complements efficiency with effectiveness and equity. Our work supplements the existing values and organization around efficiency with values and organization of equity. Changes/Problems:The majority of limitations found within the study comes from the willingness of participants to answer questions in the Q-sort process. Researchers were limited to what information the participants were willing to share. Participants were encouraged in the initial instructions of the study to share their thought process and decisions. It was recorded by the researcher that female participants were more willing to converse and elaborate answers than male participants. Researchers were limited to the understanding of participants interpretations of Q-sort statements. Participants were invited to elaborate their decision making during the first portion of the sorting exercise, given the participants willingness determined if they were interested in elaborating their decisions. An additional limitation may be that data collection and analysis were dependent on the willingness of individuals to participate in the study. Participants were contacted via email, some were inactive accounts, while others neither proclaimed their interest and disinterest in the study. Participants were required to provide a "Yes" response, and then schedule a meeting within the researchers to meet via Zoom call to complete the interview. This came as a difficulty for some due to busy schedules, growing/harvesting season, etc. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?The opportunities for training and professional development should be focused around the priorities identified through this analysis. The primary focus of financial accessibility, local engagement, communication information, informed consumers, labor and consciouness of impacts at local, regional, and national levels. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?There are plans to share the results of this project within the community of extension and through the Journal of Extension. In both cases the outcomes and priorities will be the focus of the communication. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? The overall research question for this study was to define what areas of focus are preferred among individuals within the food supply system when determining the priorities of creating resiliency and mitigating disruptions. The conclusion to the research question was interpreted through the Q-sort data analysis, participant demographics, research field notes, and reflective journal. Participant's experiences and backgrounds in the food supply system guided their interpretation of statements and priorities they indicated through their individual Q-sorts. The backgrounds of participants represent various sectors of the food supply system as stakeholders, researchers, educational representatives, and government representatives. Sharing the experiences and background of participants aids in the interpretation of factors as each perspective comes from those actively involved in different sectors and segments of the food supply system. The viewpoints identified by participant prioritization were described by researchers as financial accessibility, local engagement, communication information, inform consumers, labor, and consciousness of impact. The similarity within these factors is found between consensus in government/policies in the food system, and participation in the food system. These factors represent the areas of focus that participants within the operating food system believe to be of highest importance when it comes to creating resiliency and mitigating disruptions.

Publications

  • Type: Other Status: Other Year Published: 2023 Citation: Adams, K., Robinson, C., and Norris-Parish, S. Understanding participant's inputs: appreciative inquiry and community capitals summit, New Mexico State University, 2023


Progress 01/01/22 to 12/31/22

Outputs
Target Audience:The target audience included participants within the food supply chain including producers, processors, manufacturers, transportation, warehousing,retailers and food service. In total we had 55 registered for the three day meeting with 35 participating for the length of the event. Changes/Problems:Due to the schedule change from January to June due to COVID issues, we have also extended the timeline for the project to allow for enough time to adaquetly design and develop a useful website and complete the follow-up process with participants. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?The Summit facilitators utilizied the Appreciative Inquiryplatform, along with Community Capitals discussion to train and identify strengths and gaps within the food system.These two platforms provided structure and direction for the participants to understand the issues and how to move them forward. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?This next reporting period we will have the results of the website development, interaction and follow-up with participants, as well as updates on projects from the sub-groups.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? The Summit had established three operational goals/objectives. The group of participants was successful at identifying knowledge gaps or missunderstandings. They identified and discussed priorities for industry agencies, organizations and educational group. Within the group, subgroups were organized to address a specific, managable project to move forward. These individuals all requested additional time and follow-up opportuntities with the full group.These networks that were established will provide access throughout the food system. Each of the sub-groups continue to meet after the Summit and have started to explore funding opportunities.

Publications