Source: OTISCO ENGINEERING LTD. submitted to NRP
COVID-19 RAPID RESPONSE: ADVANCEMENT OF A MINIMALLY INVASIVE, ECONOMICAL, EASY-TO-INSTALL GEOTHERMAL HEAT-TRANSFER CLOSED PIPING SYSTEM FOR FARMSTEAD APPLICATIONS
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1023790
Grant No.
2020-33610-32389
Cumulative Award Amt.
$100,000.00
Proposal No.
2020-06023
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Sep 1, 2020
Project End Date
Nov 30, 2021
Grant Year
2020
Program Code
[8.12]- Small and Mid-Size Farms
Recipient Organization
OTISCO ENGINEERING LTD.
446 MAPLEBROOKE DRIVE E
WESTERVILLE,OH 430828621
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
The project focus is on a way to heat and/or cool new or existing farm buildings using fluid-filled "circulation" pipes underground (geothermal loop field) to transfer heat from the building to the ground (in the summer) or vice versa in the winter. Otisco Engineeringhas developed a unique geothermal loop field design and installation method that will benefit farms. The system and installation method provides a geothermal loop field design that is equivalent or superior to other currently common approaches.The Otisco design also offers the following advantages.Much easier to retrofit on a previously developed farm;Causes little to no damage to existing landscaping or farm fields; andFor an existing 6,000 square foot building (a typical farm building size), the system can be installed and commissioned in two days.The project will include advancement of the design that can be more easily assembled to customize to a system under various scenarios and/or sizes or typesof buildings that need to be heated or cooled. The installation method goes hand and hand with Otisco's design, essentially a tube-in-a-tube arrangement installed undergorund with a directional drillign machine, much like those that are commonly used for installing fiberoptic or cable communication lines. The installed system will be verified by data aquisition during the winter and summer heating/cooling periods. The measurement of flow of fluid (which flows throughthe underground circulation loop pipes) and temperatures of individual loops will provide the actual amount of heat exchanged to or from from the earth to verify the performance of the system. The resulting advanced design will be easier and more economical to install and more readily scalable than convential systems that are in place forheating and cooling buildings.
Animal Health Component
60%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
10%
Applied
60%
Developmental
30%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
40253992020100%
Goals / Objectives
Major Goals (aka Technical Objectives)A. Develop through rapid prototypes a manifold that can be manufactured with injection molding equipment to allow for a simplified installation of a piping manifold to support Otisco Engineering's "tube-in-tube" geothermal heat-transfer closed piping system.B. Make the product easy enough to install such that most local plumbers, mechanical contractors or perhaps the farmers themselves can easily and efficiently connect the piping from the geothermal heat exchange wells; andC. Install a closed loop system, including the tube-in-tube piping and commercially advanced manifold, and interior heat-exchange equipment, and circulation pump, to demonstrate a reduction in the cost of the underground components of the system as compared to a vertical well system with u-tube piping arrangements.
Project Methods
Research and Development ApproachTo help meet Objective C, we plan to install the prototype system at a property in Otisco NY. We will design a geothermal system to heat an approximately 800 sf cottage the on the property.Each ton of heat capacity generally requires 300 feet of geothermal heat exchange piping in saturated high hydraulic conductivity soils, which is the case at the subject property. We preliminarily estimate the 800-sf structurewill require 1.5 tons of heating and cooling capacity. Based on a need for 1.5 tons of heating capacity and at 300 feet per ton, we estimate we need 450 feet of horizonal well. We will conduct more detailed calculations during the project to finalize our estimate of the pipe length and other aspects of the system.We will consider depth to groundwater and aim for the directional bores containing the geothermal piping to be below the typical seasonally low groundwater level along most of their length. We will do this because water surrounding the geothermal piping creates better heat transfer. Since these wells are arched, the beginning and end segments of the wells will be shallower and above the groundwater. A perennial stream at the edge of the property dictates the groundwater level; so we can conservatively assume the stream bottom elevation as the seasonally low groundwater level. Field work will be necessary to confirm the stream and groundwater levels. An onsite water supply well will be used to obtain the static depth to groundwater. The stream level and stream bottom will also be measured against a known elevation.The geothermal wells, specifically Otisco's tube-in-tube well design, will be installed using a directional boring machine. We will select a location that allows for easy setup of the machine and that allows for a location to install the manifold. Currently, we are thinking the manifold can be installed in a subgrade vault and the piping from the field connected to the manifold within that space. Additionally, the inlet and outlet pipes from the vault will enter the building and tie into a commercially available heat exchange unit inside.To meet Objectives Aand B, we will convert our current 2-dimensional manifold design to a 3-dimensional computer file that will allow it to be efficiently injection molded into a modular plastic injection-molded manifold. The three-dimensional drawing will be generated in SOLIDWORKS® or similar three-dimensional software. In converting the design from a two-dimensional to a 3-dimensional drawing, we will seek to make the manifold more compact, such that it will require less space and allow for it to be easily fastened and stabilized inside a utility room, vault or shed.We will conduct testing of the system using thermal sensors on the manifold to measure temperatures and flow on each dual tube well line as well as a combined line coming in and out of the manifold.We will assess the effectiveness of the system by running standard statistics (e.g., min, max, mean, standard deviation) of the temperatures and flow rates during various ambient temperature conditions. We have years of data, including energy usage and temperature tracking, from a past "tube-in-tube" installation that we can compare to the new system installed for this project. We will also draw upon the costs of vertical well closed-loop systems such as a study at the University of Tennessee Knoxville (Birchfield et al., 2014).Tasks to be performedBelow is a listing of tasks to be performed during the project.Perform a detailed study for the site features to guide locating of the design. This study will help in determiningNumber of wellsLength of each wellSubsurface profile of each wellLocation of each wellLocation of the manifoldSpecial provisions for mounting or housing the manifoldMeans of future monitoring of the installed systemPrepare drawings of the design includingPlan view showing the location of the system features, site features, such as a stream, topographic features, vegetation/trees, the building being heated/cooled, drive areas, septic system, on-site water well, and other utilities.Profile views of each well and any potential conflicts to be avoided (e.g., septic tank and leach field).Details of the manifold and piping, including various cut sections.A three-dimensional file of the manifold.Retain a contractor to injection mold the manifoldRetain a contractor to install the geothermal wells and weld the high-density polyethylene (HDPE) components, including the well end cap, the well piping to the manifold and theSchedule and implement the construction work including:Directionally drilled wellsThe vault for manifoldWelding of the HDPE wells to the HDPE manifold and end cap at the far end of the outer "tube"Install temperature and flow sensors on the system at the manifold for each of the following and log the data through "the cloud." This information will be used to calculate the actual heat transferred from the ground to each loop.Tabulate and graph the data to provide a statistical analysis and comparisons with a past installation that was similarly monitored.Prepare the necessary reports for the project including, at a minimum, an interim report approximately halfway through the project and a final report including:Summary of activitiesDrawingsProcedures for installing such a systemLessons learnedRecommendations for commercialization and possible Phase II researchComparisons of collected dataA summary of the market opportunity at the time of completion of the project.

Progress 09/01/21 to 11/30/21

Outputs
Target Audience:* Working with Water Furnace, manufacturer of geothermal heat pump (mechanical) equipment and accessories, to b ring our idea into their offering of accessories. * Working with Ohio State University College of Food Agricultural and Environmental Science to install our system at two of their buildings and to research the effectiveness of our system. This collaboration will give us lots of exposure in the ag community. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?We are working, under non-disclosure agreements, with Ohio State University (College of Food Agriculture and Environmental Science) and Water Furnace to help prove out and commercialize our idea. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?Project is complete and we will work toward our Phase II application, wiht the uyltimate goal being to furhter prove out the effectiveness of our concept and to commericalize it. We are teamed with Water Furnace and Ohio State University for Phase II.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? No new accomplishments since last report.

Publications

  • Type: Other Status: Awaiting Publication Year Published: 2021 Citation: Due to publish an article in mid-Sept. 2021 on the Ohio Ecological Food and Farm Assoc. website. https://www.oeffa.org/news/newsletter-archive/ Title: GEOTHERMAL HEATING AND COOLING ON THE FARM Author: Patrick Nortz, Otisco Engineering Ltd.


Progress 09/01/20 to 11/30/21

Outputs
Target Audience:Our target audience includes: * manufacturers of heat pumps for geothermal heating and cooling, * Small and medium sized farmers who may be interested in using geothermal heating and cooling on their farm, and * Installers of geothermal heating and cooling systems, typically HVAC contractors. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?The results of the project can be presented at a conference or published in a trade or academic journal. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Otisco Engineeing has shared some of our results with the partners we have developed for our Phase II application. These partners include the Ohio State University's Department of Food, Agricultural, and Biological Engineering and Water Furnace, a manufacturer of geothermal heating and cooling system heat pumps. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? A. Develop through rapid prototypes a manifold that can be manufactured with injection molding equipment to allow for a simplified installation of a piping manifold to support Otisco Engineering's "tube-in-tube" geothermal heat-transfer closed piping system. In lieu of injection molding, we discovered a method of fabricating the manifold without injection molding. We prototyped the manifold design using off-the-shelf components and developed a welding technique to fuse those components together into one manifold. We also decided to include valves for each "chamber" of the manifold to be able to regulate or shut off flow to each of three wells in the ground loop. The design will need to be further advanced in a later phase (with a Phase II grant) to enable injection molding or a similar automated manufacturing technique. The prototype, as currently designed, has condensed the space necessary for the manifold by approximately one half from an original fabrication in 2012 (see Photograph 4 of the 2012 installation and Photograph 5 of the 2020-21 prototype during fabrication). We have developed a 3-D computer model of the manifold in a computer aided design package, which will allow a view of the manifold from a point. This model will allow for us to work toward mass production of the manifold in a more efficient way, such as 3-D printing or injection molding. B. Make the product easy enough to install such that most local plumbers, mechanical contractors or perhaps the farmers themselves can easily and efficiently connect the piping from the geothermal heat exchange wells. The prototype manifold has been designed, fabricated, and successfully installed in the in the geothermal system at Copia Farm.This working prototype manifold installed, by a plumber or somebody with experience in working with plastic pipe. In Appendix E if the written report submitted to NiFA, we provide proprietary detailed fabrication and installation instructions for the Otisco Ground-loop SystemTM, including the manifold. C. Install a closed loop system, including the tube-in-tube piping and commercially advanced manifold, and interior heat-exchange equipment, and circulation pump, to demonstrate a reduction in the cost of the underground components of the system as compared to a vertical well system with u-tube piping arrangements. The reduced installation cost of the Otisco Ground-loop system over a vertical system is significant. We comparied costs between the Otisco Ground-loop SystemTM and a conventional system with vertical wells. This comparison assumes 900 feet of drilling and suggests that the Otisco system provides a savings of $10,200. This savings is significant in that it reduces the upfront costs and payback period of a geothermal system. For example, if you were to assume a monthly average energy cost reduction of $100 for a geothermal system as compared to propane heat and an electric-powered aire conditioner, the reduced payback period would be 8.5 years per the following. ($10,200/(12 months/year*$100/month)) = 8.5 years

Publications

  • Type: Other Status: Submitted Year Published: 2021 Citation: Due to publish an article in spring 2022 on the Ohio Ecological Food and Farm Assoc. website. https://www.oeffa.org/news/newsletter-archive/ Title: GEOTHERMAL HEATING AND COOLING ON THE FARM Author: Patrick Nortz, Otisco Engineering Ltd.


Progress 09/01/20 to 08/31/21

Outputs
Target Audience:Our target audience includes: * manufacturers of heat pumps for geothermal heating and cooling * Small- and medium-sized farm owners who may be interested in using geothermal heating and cooling on their farm * Installers of geothermal heating and cooling systems, typically HVAC contractors or directional drilling companies. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?We produced an installation video that we published on the Otisco Engineering LinkedIn site to demonstrate how a ground loop can be installed with a directional boring machine. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?We have shared our ideas, under a confidentiality agreement, with The Ohio State University. We plan to team with OSU as part of pursuit of the Phase II grant. We are also in conversation with a possible industry partner and, once we have an agreement in place with them, will share our ideas to encourage commercialization of our advanced prototype. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?We hope to finalize our agreement with our prospective industry partner. We will summarize energy savings over the period that we researched the system we installed (approx Feb 2021-Sept 2021). We will develop graphical respresentation of the system operation model, which compares our installed geothermal system with hypothetical systems using other energy sources.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? A. Develop through rapid prototypes a manifold that can be manufactured with injection molding equipment to allow for a simplified installation of a piping manifold to support Otisco Engineering's "tube-in-tube" geothermal heat-transfer closed piping system. We developed a three dimensional drawing of the prototype that can be brought to a manufacturer with injection molding or 3-D printer technology to be able to price and/or produce the manifold. The prototype was created by welding commercially available plastic parts. The created manifold was installed in the overall system that is being beta tested at the Copia Farm. B. Make the product easy enough to install such that most local plumbers, mechanical contractors or perhaps the farmers themselves can easily and efficiently connect the piping from the geothermal heat exchange wells. We have advanced the manifold, the most complicated compent of the system, to be able to be fabricated by hand using off the shelf components. We incorporated an electrofusion coupling in our design to enable simplified in-field connection of the manifold to the ground loops. C. Install a closed loop system, including the tube-in-tube piping and commercially advanced manifold, and interior heat-exchange equipment, and circulation pump, to demonstrate a reduction in the cost of the underground components of the system as compared to a vertical well system with u-tube piping arrangements. The prototype system was installed at the Copia Farm in Johnstown, Ohio. The system was installed using a "horizontal" directional boring machine for the ground loops,. Use the direction bore method resulted in the following cost avoidance/savings as compared to a vertical well drilling method: * MINOR SITE RESTORATION. Avoided impact to the property that are common with vertical well installations, thereby avoiding site restoration costs * SHORT INSTALLATION TIME. Borings for the ground loops were completed in one day at a lower cost than vertical installations * CENTRALIZED CONNECTION. Other than the manifold pit, no other excavation such as trenching to connect pipes, was necessary. All the gorund loops originated at the manifold pit. This makes for a more efficient and cost-effective installation and again avoids some ot the site restoration that is necessary for vertical installations.

Publications

  • Type: Other Status: Submitted Year Published: 2021 Citation: Due to publish an article in mid-Sept. 2021 on the Ohio Ecological Food and Farm Assoc. website. https://www.oeffa.org/news/newsletter-archive/ Title: GEOTHERMAL HEATING AND COOLING ON THE FARM Author: Patrick Nortz, Otisco Engineering Ltd.
  • Type: Websites Status: Published Year Published: 2021 Citation: Blog on the Otisco Web Site describing the project: http://otiscoengineering.com/copia-farms/