Source: UNIV OF NORTH DAKOTA submitted to
NATIONAL ALTERNATIVE FUELS LABORATORY (NAFL) 2008
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0214094
Grant No.
2008-38819-19172
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
2008-03489
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Jul 1, 2008
Project End Date
Jun 30, 2010
Grant Year
2008
Program Code
[FE]- Alternative Fuels Characterization Laboratory, ND
Project Director
Aulich, T. R.
Recipient Organization
UNIV OF NORTH DAKOTA
(N/A)
GRAND FORKS,ND 58201
Performing Department
ENERGY & ENVIRONMENTAL RES CTR
Non Technical Summary
U.S. agriculture is dependent on nitrogen fertilizers, but the U.S. nitrogen fertilizer industry is at serious risk due to the high price of natural gas, the primary source of hydrogen for reaction with nitrogen to yield ammonia. The cost of natural gas, which accounts for at least 80% of the cost of ammonia (and by extension, the cost of all other nitrogen-based fertilizers) has resulted in a significant increase in fertilizer imports and a significant reduction in U.S. fertilizer production capacity. It is of urgent importance to develop domestic fertilizer production capabilities that can compete with current import-based scenarios that include the use of low-cost stranded natural gas, large-scale processing, and long-range transportation to U.S. farmers. This project will optimize recently developed electrolytic ammonia and urea production processes that replace high-cost natural gas-derived hydrogen with much lower-cost biomass gasification-derived syngas (bio-syngas). Because they are driven by electricity and operate at significantly lower temperatures and pressures than the natural gas-based processes, the electrolytic processes offer the potential to directly utilize wind-generated electricity for production of fertilizer at significantly reduced capital and operating costs versus the natural gas-based processes. Commercialization of the processes would 1) result in lower-cost fertilizer, 2) help the domestic fertilizer industry survive by eliminating the need to buy natural gas, 3) enable extracting value from wind energy without the need for major expansion of expensive, difficult-to-permit transmission capacity, and 4) promote rural economic development on the wind-rich Great Plains. This project will also optimize a process to convert ethanol to higher (longer carbon chain) alcohols including butanol, isobutanol, hexanol, and others. Isobutanol has value as a high-octane gasoline blendstock that could complement ethanol by effecting a reduction in the vapor pressure increase that accompanies low-level (5-20 volume%) ethanol addition to gasoline; butanol, hexanol, and other higher alcohol products have value as chemical intermediates. Motivation for this work is provided by the fact that the higher alcohols process can be efficiently conducted at moderate temperatures, atmospheric pressure, and without any exotic or toxic material inputs, which means it represents a potentially viable means of product diversification at existing corn- and new lignocellulosic-based ethanol plants. To optimize the higher alcohols process, new catalysts will be developed and evaluated, and the best-performing catalyst(s) will be used in tests to establish optimal process operational conditions including temperature, ethanol feed rate, unconverted or partially converted feedstock recycle rate, and catalyst regeneration procedure.
Animal Health Component
40%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
25%
Applied
40%
Developmental
35%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
1330410200020%
5110650200030%
5111599200020%
5111620200030%
Goals / Objectives
The project goals are to are to 1) optimize electrochemical processes for producing nitrogen-based fertilizers from biomass gasification-derived synthesis gas (bio-syngas) and electricity and 2) optimize a process for converting ethanol to butanol and other higher (longer carbon chain) alcohols via a low-temperature low-pressure condensation reaction. Commercialization of the bio-syngas fertilizer processes would enable lower-cost domestic fertilizer production versus the natural gas-based processes commercially utilized today. Because it is compatible with integration at current corn and new lignocellulose ethanol production facilities, commercialization of the higher alcohols process would enable development of new high-value product options for ethanol producers.
Project Methods
Optimization of electrochemical processes for fertilizer production will proceed via 1) development of high-efficiency and stable cathode catalysts, 2) evaluation and development of nonaqueous electrolyte systems, 3) optimization of electrode and electrolysis cell structures, 4) identification of optimal cathode and anode gaseous feedstock compositions, 5) optimization of reaction conditions including temperature, pressure, and input flow rates based on process efficiency and energy consumption, and 6) acquisition of process mass balance data required for design of an integrated biomass gasification-electrochemical fertilizer production system capable of producing 200-400 pounds of fertilizer per day. Optimization of the higher alcohols process will proceed via 1) preparation of ethanol condensation catalysts, 2) evaluation of catalysts based on desired product selectivity, ethanol conversion, and catalyst durability, and 3) using one or more selected catalyst(s), optimization of a complete process including unconverted feedstock recycle and catalyst regeneration.

Progress 07/01/08 to 06/30/10

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Activities comprised 1) conducting laboratory-scale experiments to optimize an electrochemical process for production of ammonia using inputs of electricity, nitrogen, and synthesis gas (carbon monoxide and hydrogen) generated via gasification of biomass or reforming of landfill or anaerobic digester gas, 2) disseminating experimental results and their implications in regard to the economic viability of small-scale commercial production of ammonia and ammonia-based fertilizers via reports and presentations given to the North Dakota and Minnesota Corn Growers' Associations, and 3) preparing and filing a "continuation-in-part" (CIP) patent application entitled "Electrochemical Process for the Preparation of Nitrogen Fertilizers." Identifying information for the CIP application includes the following: Filing date: October 15, 2010; Serial Number 12/905, 6000. PARTICIPANTS: Dr. Junhua Jiang, Principal Investigator, with assistance from Dr. Alexey Ignatchenko, developed 1) an electrolytic method for extracting ammonia synthesis-quality high-purity hydrogen from a synthesis gas and 2) a high-activity ammonia synthesis catalyst, with input from collaborators North Dakota Corn Utilization Council and Minnesota Corn Research and Promotion Council. Ted Aulich, Project Manager, assisted in project technical activities and assumed responsibility for project reporting and administrative requirements. TARGET AUDIENCES: Upper Midwest regional farmers and agricultural and forest product processors, ethanol producers, electric and agricultural product cooperatives, regional and state economic development agencies, and all other agricultural-related audiences. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: None.

Impacts
Outcomes include the development and demonstration of 1) an electrolytic method for extracting high-purity hydrogen from a synthesis gas and 2) a high-activity ammonia synthesis catalyst. The electrolytic hydrogen extraction technology enables one-step, low-cost generation of hydrogen at a purity level of at least 99.95%, which is sufficient to enable use of the hydrogen for ammonia synthesis and avoid catalyst poisoning. Because the extraction/purification occurs in one step, it offers the potential of reduced ammonia production capital and operating costs versus traditional hydrogen purification processes that include multiple carbon dioxide removal, carbon monoxide conversion to methane, and methane removal steps. Because of its high activity, the project-developed ammonia synthesis catalyst enables high single-pass ammonia generation at ambient pressure versus the high (1100 to 2500 pounds per square inch) pressures traditionally used for commercial ammonia production. Because it negates the need for high-cost compressors and high-pressure-compatible reactor vessels, valves, and piping, the catalyst offers the potential for significantly reduced ammonia production capital and operating costs.

Publications

  • Jiang, J.; Aulich, T.; Collings, M.; Sohn, C. High-Pressure Electrochemical Hydrogen Purification Process Using a High-Temperature Polybenzimidazole (PBI) Membrane. ECS Transactions 2010, 28 (26), 91-100.


Progress 07/01/08 to 06/30/09

Outputs
OUTPUTS: National Alternative Fuels Laboratory (NAFL) activities during the reporting period include 1) conducting laboratory-scale experiments to optimize an electrochemical process for production of renewable ammonia using inputs of electricity (ideally generated from wind energy), nitrogen, and renewable synthesis gas (carbon monoxide and hydrogen generated via gasification of lignocellulosic biomass) and 2) conducting laboratory-scale experiments to optimize the second step of a two-step renewable isobutanol production process comprising conversion of renewable synthesis gas to a mixture of normal alcohols containing primarily methanol with lesser amounts of ethanol, propanol, and butanol, followed by conversion of the normal alcohol mixture to a mixture of primarily isobutanol with lesser amounts of branched pentanols and hexanols. The ammonia process optimization experiments were conducted using simulated synthesis gas mixtures, a project-designed and -fabricated electrochemical cell, and project-developed electrocatalysts and membrane electrode assemblies. The isobutanol process optimization experiments were conducted using normal C1 to C4 alcohol mixtures, a project-designed and -fabricated reactor system, and project-developed alcohol condensation catalysts. Information regarding a patent application filed during the project reporting period is as follows: Title: Electrochemical Process for the Preparation of Nitrogen Fertilizers Authors: Junhua Jiang, Edwin Olson, and Ted Aulich Filing date: 8/21/2008 Application No.: 12/206,621 PARTICIPANTS: Dr. Junhua Jiang, Principal Investigator, developed electrochemical methods for producing ammonia and other nitrogen-based fertilizers, with input from collaborators North Dakota Corn Utilization Council and Minnesota Corn Research and Promotion Council. Dr. Ramesh Sharma optimized thermocatalytic methods for converting mixed normal alcohols to isobutanol and other isoalcohols, in collaboration with Syntec Biofuel, Inc., of Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada. Ted Aulich, Project Manager, assisted in project technical activities and assumed responsibility for project reporting and administrative requirements. TARGET AUDIENCES: Upper Midwest regional farmers and agricultural and forest product processors, ethanol producers, electric and agricultural product cooperatives, regional and state economic development agencies, and all other agricultural-related audiences. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
Ammonia process optimization activities resulted in development of a cathode catalyst with an activity of 60 millimoles of ammonia produced per hour per gram of catalyst. Based on a recently conducted literature search and conversations with commercial ammonia production catalyst producers, this activity level appears to be a new record in catalyst performance. After the catalyst underwent endurance testing for over 1 month, no reduction in catalyst activity was observed. Because it operates at significantly lower temperature and pressure than the traditional natural gas-based ammonia production process, the NAFL-developed electrochemical ammonia process offers the possibility of lower-cost, distributed-scale domestic ammonia production. In pursuing development of the process, NAFL is collaborating with the North Dakota Corn Utilization Council and the Minnesota Corn Research and Promotion Council. Renewable isobutanol process optimization activities resulted in development of a catalyst that enabled conversion of a methanol-rich normal alcohol mixture to a branched alcohol mixture comprising 65% isobutanol and lesser quantities of isopentanols, isohexanols, and isooctanols. According to Argonne National Laboratory, use of cellulosic ethanol to displace gasoline reduces greenhouse gases by 85%. By extension, the use of cellulosic isobutanol and higher isoalcohols to replace gasoline should reduce greenhouse gases by a similar amount. Because isobutanol and higher isoalcohols are relatively nonpolar, they offer the possibility of sufficient gasoline compatibility to enable their transport (as blends with gasoline) in pipelines, which would further reduce greenhouse gas emissions and significantly improve product distribution economics.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period