Source: UNIV OF WISCONSIN submitted to
IMPROVING PROTEIN SECRETION IN BACTERIA
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
TERMINATED
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1013558
Grant No.
(N/A)
Project No.
WIS02030
Proposal No.
(N/A)
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Program Code
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Oct 1, 2017
Project End Date
Sep 30, 2020
Grant Year
(N/A)
Project Director
Burton, BR.
Recipient Organization
UNIV OF WISCONSIN
21 N PARK ST STE 6401
MADISON,WI 53715-1218
Performing Department
Bacteriology
Non Technical Summary
Industrial scale production of enzymes is an integral component of many economically and agriculturally essential industries including the food, beverage, detergent, and paper industries. The State of Wisconsin leads the country in dairy and paper production, two industries at the forefront of industrial enzyme production and use. Such enzyme production relies heavily on the bacterium Bacillus subtilis and some of its closest bacterial relatives. These bacteria are popular due to their excellent fermentation properties, the potential for high protein yields, and their relative lack of toxic products. In most cases, however, the range of proteins secreted at high levels by these bacteria is limited and tools to advance the secretion capacity of these organisms remain underdeveloped.A few years ago, our laboratory demonstrated the existence and function of a previously undescribed, alternative protein secretion system in Bacillus subtilis. This system has the potential to avoid key bottlenecks confronted by the current preferred secretion strategies, and therefore could serve as a more robust protein secretion system than the ones currently employed for industrial enzyme production. The project proposed here will examine genetic factors that optimize yield of protein secretion and explore functional limits of the alternate secretion system. The results of this work will provide new insights into fundamental mechanisms of bacterial protein secretion that could aid in industrial production of products that promote food safety, sustainability, and animal agriculture.
Animal Health Component
0%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
90%
Applied
10%
Developmental
0%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
5117010110034%
5017010110033%
7117010110033%
Goals / Objectives
The major goals of this study are to investigate the genetic requirements for secretion of proteins via the alternative ESX secretion system in Bacillus subtilis and to evaluate the physical and molecular properties allowed for substrates. Secreted proteins are a major resource for industrial purposes, and the Bacilli are utilized abundantly for this purpose. Most protein secretion utilizes the housekeeping secretory (Sec) pathway. Cellular homeostasis, particularly under stress conditions, relies heavily on proteins that are natural substrates of the Sec pathway. Overproduction of heterologous proteins generates significant stresses on the cells and produces a direct competition with the endogenous housekeeping substrates of the Sec system. Moreover, the proteins secreted by the Sec system are exported as unfolded proteins, making them vulnerable to proteolytic cleavage in the extracellular environment. Work from our laboratory revealed that the alternative secretion system (ESX) can export stable, folded proteins and protein complexes and thus has the potential to circumvent several major challenges currently faced in industrial enzyme production. Our hypothesis is that additional genetic and molecular factors may be identified and defined to increase quantity and quality of protein secretion. We will pursue the following objectives related to this hypothesis:1. Dissect genetic requirements of the ESX secretion system in Bacillus subtilis1.1 Examine the genetic differences that contribute to differential secretion yield between B. subtilis strains.1.2 Identify genetic elements that contribute to ESX secretion in B. subtilis2. Determine the range of proteins that can be accommodated by the ESX system2.1 Examine the size of proteins substrates permissible for secretion by ESX.2.2 Assess the folding state of proteins secreted by ESX.2.3 Examine the need for unfolding and polypeptide threading during protein secretion.
Project Methods
Methods for Objective 1: Dissect genetic requirements of the ESX secretion system in Bacillus subtilisOur approach will be to use a colorimetric (so-called "blue/white") assay for protein secretion to identify the genetic loci responsible for differential secretion phenotypes between domesticated and undomesticated strains of B. subtilis. Specifically, one transformation will identify loci in one bacterial strain that render the other strain no longer exclusively dependent upon the secretion operon for secretion. The reciprocal transformation will identify genetic loci of the second strain that render the first dependent on the secretion operon. Evaluation: Interconversion of the blue/white phenotypes will support our hypothesis that there are genetic regions outside the operon important for protein secretion. Finally, after confirming the phenotype of the transformants using our immunoblotting assay for secretion, the validated blue or white colonies will be sent for whole genome sequencing. We will then assemble the genome sequences and compare to two genomes to identify the genetic region(s) that could provide insights on additional genetic requirements of the secretion system.In a parallel approach, we will utilize unbiased genetic screening tools and combine these with our blue/white phosphatase assay to identify additional genetic loci that affect ESX secretion. We will utilize two transposon-mediated random mutagenesis tools to identify additional genetic interactions in the secretion system. First, since substrate secretion is not completely abolished in the an operon deletion strain, we will look for synthetic effects via modification of standard transposon mutagenesis. Briefly, a mariner-based transposon library will be generated in the operon deletion background. Evaluation: We will screen for the desired phenotype, in this case, conversion of blue colonies to white. White colonies will be restreaked to confirm the phenotype, and the location of the transposon insertion identified via standard transposon-sequeincing (TnSeq) methods. In a second unbiased approach, we will utilize a transposon with a strong outward-facing, optionally isopropyl-β-D-thiogalactopyranoside (IPTG)-inducible promoter to identify genes whose overexpression affects secretion. Evaluation: In this case, the screen will be carried out in two directions; light blue colonies formed in the wild type domesticated strain background will be screened for brighter blue, and the blue undomesticated strain will be screened for conversion to light blue or white. In both cases, due to the natural transformability of B. subtilis, the identified genomic locus can be easily confirmed as causative for the phenotypic change using standard molecular techniques and our secretion protocol.Methods for Objective 2: Determine the range of proteins that can be accommodated by the ESX systemOur approach to defining the range of permissible substrates, will focus on testing for substrate sizes, folding/oligomeric state, and ability to be threaded through the translocon. First, we will test the size parameter using various size polypeptide fusions to the canonical secretion substrate. These will ranges in size from 8.5 kDa to 474kDa. Evaluation: Secretion of each fusion will be followed by substrate-specific immunoblotting using our standard protocol.Second, we will assess whether folding or oligomeric state of a substrate affects B. subtilis substrate secretion by thsi system. For this we will use the a system that has been used for similar purposes in analyses of protein chaperones and the Tat and Type III secretion pathways. C-terminal and N-terminal fusions with the stabilizing protein will be tested in the presence or absence of the tight-binding cofactor. Such assays will be done in the B. subtilis afoA strain that was shown to be resistant to the cofactor. Further, we will test for export of folded, multi-protein complexes by co-expressing a different substrate fusion with its protein cofactor, and assaying for export of the cofactor polypeptide. Evaluation: Our standard immunoblotting-based secretion assay will be used to measure secretion of the various structurally stabilized substrates.Third, we will test whether the secretion translocon engages in substrate threading through a channel. In this approach we will test substrates that are covalently cyclized and therefore cannot be threaded. We will produce substrate fused with the peptide cyclyzation domains at each terminus. The two domains will spontaneously create a covalent link, thus efficiently cyclizing the secretion substrate. Evaluation: Our standard immunoblotting-based secretion assay will be used to measure secretion of the cyclized substrate.

Progress 10/01/17 to 09/30/20

Outputs
Target Audience: During the award period, we primarily presented this work to researchers and undergraduates interested in microbial genetics, molecular biology, and biochemistry. Each year, the graduate student presented a talk at a weekly seminar attended by several research groups on campus. He also presented a poster at a national conference, the Molecular Genetics of Bacteria and Phages. The PI gave a talks to graduate program students and to freshman interested in the microbiology major on campus and highlighted this work. The graduate student mentored two undergraduates, a microbiology major and a biochemistry major, for their respective independent research project credits. The undergraduates presented posters are university-wide poster sessions attended by hundreds of undergraduates. Due to COVID, the two international meetings were cancelled (BACELL in Kobe, Japan, in April 2020 and Molecular Genetics of Bacteria and Phages in Madison, WI in August 2020) at which we had anticipated presenting work associated with this award. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?During the course of this award, the project has provided opportunities for training graduate, two undergraduates, and a high school student. The primary contributor to this project began as a graduate student in the UW-Madison Bacteriology Master's degree program. Midway through this project, the graduate student successfully defended a Master's thesis focused mostly on results from Objective 1 of this project. He matriculated into the Microbiology Doctoral Training Program here at UW-Madison and continued this work while preparing for this PhD candidacy exam. Through regular meetings with the PI and interactions with senior graduate students and laboratory scientists, the graduate student made significant advances in his ability to conduct independent research. In addition to daily function in the laboratory, this project has provided the student with professional development such as, coordinating resource distribution with multiple laboratories, writing skills from preparing graduate funding and program applications, and presentation skills from research presentations, committee meetings, and an oral preparation at cross-departmental seminar. In the fall of 2018, the graduate student began mentoring two UW-Madison undergraduates. With guidance from the PI, and attendance at campus mentor training workshops. The graduate student developed skills in teaching and overseeing his mentees in sub-aims of his projects. He gained experience editing and providing constructive feedback when his mentees developed posters for undergraduate symposium presentations. The graduate student also mentored a high school student at UW-Madison through the summer PEOPLE Program. He taught the student fundamentals of laboratory techniques and basics of the laboratory research process. The high school student had the opportunity to present a ~5min description of the summer work associated with this project to her summer cohort. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Each year, the graduate student presented a talk at a weekly seminar attended by several research groups on campus. He also presented a poster at a national conference, the Molceular Genetics of Bacteria and Phages. The PI gave a talks to gradaute program students and to freshman interested in the microbiology major on campus and highlighted this work. The graduate student mentored two undergraduates, a microbiology major and a biochemistry major, for their respective independent research project credits. The undergraduates presented posters are university-wide poster sessions attended by hundreds of undergraduates. Due to COVID, the two international meetings were cancelled (BACELL in Kobe, Japan, in April 2020 and Molecular Genetics of Bacteria and Phages in Madison, WI in August 2020) at which we had anticiapted presenting work associated with this award. Although additional experiments are still needed, we anticipate that results from this work will be included in forthcoming manuscripts from the lab. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Associated with Objective 1, in which the goal was to identify genetic determinants for the ESX secretion system: (1) We conducted two genetic screens. In the first screen, we examined ~4000 strains of B. subtilis, each of which is missing a different gene from the genome. This provided a list of 345 so-called candidate genes that might be involved in ESX secretion. In the second screen, we examined over 250,000 colonies of B. subtilis, each of which has a unique genetic disruption called a transposon insertion somewhere within the genome. This yielded a list of 102 candidates. (2) Using secondary confirmation, bioinformatic analysis, and literature searches, we grouped the candidates from the two screens and identified a core set of gene candidates for follow-up experiments. In particular, we focused on one candidate gene that was identified in both of the screens. This gene is linked to the ability of B. subtilis cells to switch between a motile and a non-motile state. (3) We conducted a series of biofilm and motility assays to test for effects of this mutant in the context of the secretion system background. The results of these experiments did not suggest a link between this gene and the secretion phenotype found in the original screen. Simultaneously, we were remaking clean genetic background strains for the top candidates. In this process, we found that the blue/white phenotypes from the screen were not stable, including our top candidate. (4) That led us to test whether the quantity of ESX substrate made by the cell was influencing the secretion result. The major result from this work is that genetic elements that control the quantities of ESX substrate contribute to this otherwise un-regulated export of substrate into the media. Associated with Objective 2, in which the goal was to determine the range of proteins that can be accommodated by the ESX system: (1) We designed and produced a panel of secretion fusions with a range of sizes and biochemical properties. The fusion partners we used were chosen based on their use and utility in industrial applications. (2) We tested for protein secretion of the fusions by immunoblotting for the presence of the protein in the extracellular medium. All of the fusions were made and present in the cells. Only two of the fusions were detected as secreted. The other two were not. Secretion status did not correlate strictly with size or surface charge properties, so additional study will be required to determine characteristics of secretion-prone vs secretion-inhibited substrates. (3) We produced a secretion fusion that can be locked into its three-dimensional structure when in the presence of a complementary peptide. (4) We tested for protein secretion of this "locked" protein. This fusion was made and present in the cells, but not detected in the secreted sample. We found that presence of the fusion appeared to inhibit secretion of other protein substrates for the secretion apparatus. (5) We retested the original fusions that we had made. For a couple of the fusions, we found a similar result of apparent inhibition to secretion of other substrates by the fusions. The major results from these observations are a. some fusions are viable for secretion, and b. some fusions may be able to functions as "stoppers" for the secretion apparatus.

Publications

  • Type: Theses/Dissertations Status: Other Year Published: 2020 Citation: Genetic and Molecular Characterization of the Type VII Secretion System in Bacillus subtilis


Progress 10/01/18 to 09/30/19

Outputs
Target Audience: We primarily targeted other researchers and undergraduates interested in microbial genetics, molecular biology, and biochemistry. Mr. Finn presented a talk at a weekly seminar attended by several research groups on campus. The PI gave a talk to freshman interested in the microbiology major on campus and highlighted this work. Mr. Finn mentored two undergraduates, a microbiology major and a biochemistry major, in their Biology 152 mentored research project on campus. Both of the students had the opportunity to present posters on their work at university-sponsored poster sessions at the end of their respective mentored research semesters. In August 2019, Mr. Finn presented the work completed to-date for his defense of his Masters thesis. This presentation was attended by faculty from the UW-Madison Bacteriology Masters program. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?During this reporting period, the project has provided opportunities for training graduate, undergraduate students. The primary contributor to this project is a graduate student in the UW-Madison Bacteriology Masters degree program, Mr. James Finn. Through regular meetings with the PI and interactions with senior graduate students and laboratory scientists, Mr. Finn has made significant advances in his ability to conduct independent research. In addition to daily function in the laboratory, this project provided Mr. Finn with professional development such as, coordinating resource distribution with multiple laboratories, writing skills from preparing graduate funding and program applications, and presentation skills from research presentations, committee meetings, and an oral preparation at cross-departmental seminar. In the fall of 2018, Mr. Finn began mentoring two UW-Madison undergraduates. With guidance from the PI, and attendance at campus mentor training workshops, Mr. Finn developed skills in teaching and overseeing his mentees in sub-aims of his projects. He gained experience editing and providing constructive feedback when his mentees developed posters for undergraduate symposium presentations. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Mr. Finn presented a talk at a weekly seminar attended by several research groups on campus. The PI gave a talk to freshman interested in the microbiology major on campus and highlighted this work. Mr. Finn mentored two undergraduates, a microbiology major and a biochemistry major, in their Biology 152 mentored research project on campus. Both of the students had the opportunity to present posters on their work at university-sponsored poster sessions at the end of their respective mentored research semesters. In August 2019, Mr. Finn presented the work completed to-date for his defense of his Masters thesis. This presentation was attended by faculty from the UW-Madison Bacteriology Masters program. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?During the next reporting period, we will continue the functional validation of the hits from the genetic screens. We will also test the newly made protein fusions for secretion by the ESX system.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? During this reporting period, the two most significant accomplishments were the completion of the two genetic screens designed to identify previously unknown genes associated with the ESX protein secretion system in Bacillus subtilis. The output of these two labor-intensive screens allows us to now explore which conditions and genetic modifications can increase protein secretion yields by this system. In the first screen, we examined ~4000 strains of B. subtilis, each of which is missing a different gene from the genome. This provided a list of 345 so-called candidate genes that might be involved in ESX secretion. In the second screen, we examined over 250,000 colonies of B. subtilis, each of which has a unique disruption called a transposon insertion somewhere within the genome. This yielded a list of 102 candidates. Using secondary confirmation, bioinformatic analysis, and literature searches, we were able group the candidates from the two screens and identify a core set of gene candidates that are now undergoing follow-up experimentation for their possible contributions to ESX secretion. In particular, we have focused on one candidate gene that was identified in both of the screens. This gene is linked to the ability of B. subtilis cells to switch between a motile and a non-motile state. Armed with this knowledge, we can test, for example, whether forcing all of the cells to be either motile or non-motile will alter the protein secretion yields of a bacterial culture. The major accomplishment for Aim 2 was the successful construction of four new protein fusions for further testing.

Publications


    Progress 10/01/17 to 09/30/18

    Outputs
    Target Audience:We primarily targeted other researchers in this field including microbial geneticists, molecular biologists, and biochemists. Mr. Finn presented a poster at the national conference, Molecular Genetics of Bacteria and Phages in 08/2018, which had over 400 attendees. The PI presented a seminar that included some of this work in the Distinguished Lectures in Microbiology seminar series at UW-Madison in 09/2018. The PI also gave talks to incoming UW-Madison freshman exploring the microbiology major, as well as to the UW-Madison Microbiology Club. A high school student from the PEOPLE program who trained on this project over the summerhad the opportunity to present a poster related to this work. Changes/Problems:During the first reporting period, we discovered that the twoB. subtilisstrains, previously demonstratedto differ in ESX secretion when using an immunoblotting method to analyze differences,exhibit indistinguishableESXsubstrate secretion when assessed using our blue/white method. Wetherefore modified the genetic screen to focus on genetic hits that reveal general secretion inhibitors or enhancers, as opposed to the strain-specific genetic hits we originally expected to identify(objective 1.1). This was a fortuitous adjustment, as finding suchuniversal genetic hits will be more valuable and transferrable across secretion-relevant strains. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?The project has provided opportunities for training graduate,undergraduate, and high schoolstudents. The primary contributor to this project is a graduate student in the UW-Madison Bacteriology Masters degree program, Mr. James Finn. Through reguar meetings with the PI and interactions with senior graduate students and laboratory scientists,Mr. Finn has made significant advances in his ability to conduct independent research. In addition to daily function in the laboratory, this projecthas provided Mr. Finn withprofessional development such as, coordinating resource distribution with multiple laboratories, writing skills from preparing graduate funding and program applications, and presentation skills from research presentations,committee meetings,and a poster preparation at a national conference. Over the summer of 2018, Mr. Finn mentored a high school student at UW-Madison through the PEOPLE Program. Mr. Finn taught the student fundamentals of laboratory techniques and basics of the laboratory researchprocess. In the fall of 2018, Mr. Finn began mentoring two UW-Madison Microbiology major undergraduates, and began learning how to design and coordinate appropriate projects for students at this stage. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Mr. Finn presented a poster at the national conference, Molecular Genetics of Bacteria and Phages in 08/2018 which had over 400 attendees. The PI presented a seminar that included some of this work in the Distinguished Lectures in Microbiology seminar series at UW-Madison in 09/2018. The PI also gave talks to incoming UW-Madison freshman exploring the microbiology major, as well as to the UW-Madison Microbiology Club. A high school student from the PEOPLE program who trained on this project over the summerhad the opportunity to present a poster related to this work. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?During the next reporting period, we will(1) verify the genetic hitsidentified by the KO library screen by first,constructing newB. subtilisstrains containing direct KO's, second,testing the new strains for ESX substrate secretion using our blue/white assay, and, third, directly followingESX substrate secretion with polyclonal antibodies to the ESX substrate, and(2) conduct the transposonscreen andvalidate genetic hits as described for the KO library hits.Additionally, we will complete the construction ofB. subtilisstrains containing ESX substrate protein fusions and test the strains for secretion of the fusions.

    Impacts
    What was accomplished under these goals? During the first reporting period, we focused our efforts on Objective 1:Dissect genetic requirements of the ESX secretion system inBacillus subtilis. We accomplished the following crucial steps towards thisobjective: (1) we obtained and re-arrayed into a functional format for screeninga knock-out (KO) librarycontaining all ~4000 nonessentialBacillus subtilisgenes, (2) we screened the arrayed KO library for changes in ESX substrate export, and after secondary screeningof thehits, identified over three hundred hits to send for sequencing identification and further validation, (3) we built bacterial strains that will allow for screening of a transposon library with ~130,000 independent mutants in the second funding year. Towards Objective 2: Determine the range of proteins that can be accommodated by the ESX system,we have designed and begun molecular geneticconstruction ofB. subtilisstrains containing ESX substrate protein fusions. These protein constructs are fusions of the ESX proteins with additional proteinsof various sizes and folding state stability. Most fusions that we will testare for enzymes that are established, important industrial products.

    Publications