Source: UNIV OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS submitted to NRP
ESTABLISHING TREES USING ACTIVE AND PASSIVE IRRIGATION ON ARID SITES
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1009882
Grant No.
(N/A)
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
(N/A)
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Aug 22, 2016
Project End Date
Jul 31, 2021
Grant Year
(N/A)
Program Code
[(N/A)]- (N/A)
Recipient Organization
UNIV OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
(N/A)
ST. CROIX,VI 00850
Performing Department
Agricultural Experiment Station
Non Technical Summary
Irregular weather patterns with more extremes have been predicted due to Global Warming. During 2015, the Virgin Islands experienced a severe drought and the USDA Secretary Vilsack issued a Disaster Declaration due to Drought. The drought also had a devastating effect on young trees causing death and newly planted areas are more prone to fires. The US Virgin Islands (USVI) consists of four small islands in the Caribbean. When Europeans arrived in the Caribbean at the end of the 15th century, the various islands of the Greater and Lesser Antilles were largely covered in a mosaic of different types of tropical forests and woodlands: thorn scrub, very dry, dry, moist, wet, and rain forests. The forests of the USVI were cleared for sugar cane in the 17th and 18th centuries. Sugar cane is no longer commercially grown in the USVI and the forests have grown back, but the islands are quickly urbanizing. New urban and residential developments require landscape planting. Plant nurseries, particularly, those specializing in showy "tropical" plants such as species in the Heliconaceae, Musaceae, and Zingiberaceae families, need abundant water. However, supplies of fresh water are limited in the USVI. Rainfall is seasonal. There are no perennial streams or lakes to provide fresh water. Fresh water can be obtained by collecting rainwater in cisterns for later use, from wells that tap the subterranean aquifer, or buying it from the Virgin Islands Water and Power Authority, which is expensive, because it comes from a desalination plant. We are promoting the use of native tropical dry forest trees in landscape plantings as a way to conserve water and foster biodiversity. The focus of this proposal is to test the effectiveness of four supplementary watering regimes in the establishment and growth of nursery grown tree seedlings once planted outside. We will test how five native tree species planted outside react to four watering regimes within two supplementary systems. One system which we are calling 'active' conserves supplementary water by delivering water directly to the root areas, the other, 'passive' system collects and conserves rainwater by preventing run off. The two systems are inspired by a study of various forestry and agro-forestry texts. Tropical dry forests are adapted to seasonal rainfall regimes and low levels of precipitation. Periods of drought and water stress can last weeks and months. Soil type and topographic position also influence the amount of water available to plants. Young plants, even if they are tropical dry forest species, are still very susceptible to drought and water stress. Seedlings can be killed, and the growth of saplings retarded. By studying the active and passive supplementary watering systems, we hope to improve tree survival and growth. The University of the Virgin Islands, Agriculture Experiment Station (UVI-AES) has led native ornamental plant research in the territory on over 30 species of woody plants, including federally and territorially endangered species (Daley and Zimmerman, 2009; Morgan and Zimmerman, 2014).
Animal Health Component
90%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
10%
Applied
90%
Developmental
0%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
12506401060100%
Knowledge Area
125 - Agroforestry;

Subject Of Investigation
0640 - Tropical forests;

Field Of Science
1060 - Biology (whole systems);
Goals / Objectives
Tropical dry forests are adapted to seasonal rainfall regimes and low levels of precipitation. Periods of drought and water stress can last weeks and months. Soil type and topographic position also influence the amount of water available to plants. Young plants, even if they are tropical dry forest species, are still very susceptible to drought and water stress. Seedlings can be killed, and the growth of saplings retarded. By studying the active and passive supplementary watering systems, we hope to improve tree survival and growth. The University of the Virgin Islands, Agriculture Experiment Station (UVI-AES) has led native ornamental plant research in the territory on over 30 species of woody plants, including federally and territorially endangered species (Daley and Zimmerman, 2009; Morgan and Zimmerman, 2014).Test 5 different techniques for establishing trees on water limited sites.Further the amount of knowledge known about propagation, ecology and growth of the chosen tree species.
Project Methods
Seeds from five tree species native to the USVI, will be collected and germinated under greenhouse house conditions. The tree species we are interested in working with are: of: Silk Cotton tree or Kapok (Ceiba pentandra), Bay-Rum (Pimenta racemosa), Royal Palm (Roystonea borinquena), White Cedar/Pink Poui (Tabebuia heterophylla) and Turpentine tree (Bursera simaruba). However, species selection is dependent on the availability of seed and may change. Seeds will be germinated from selected species and seedlings will be potted and grown in one gallon pots to the desired height, about 12 inches (30 cm). Then, the seedlings, approximately 12" (30 cm) tall, will be out planted in the agroforestry hillside field plot at the University of the Virgin Islands Agricultural Experiment Station. The hillside site has a flattish summit, upper slope, midslope and lower slope. Position on the slope is the block. As a covariant, the initial height of the tree seedling will be taken into account.Seven uniform trees of each species will be assigned to a treatment. The treatments are control, deep pipe, basin, basin with mulch, and dew collectors. The control treatment consists of just planting a tree in the conventional manner: i.e. dig a hole, remove the planting container from the tree seedling, place seedling in the hole and back fill the hole with the soil previously excavated. Immediately after planting, the trees will receive 3.8 L (a gallon) of water and within a week, another 3.8L of water as supplementary irrigation, to ensure that the trees recover from the shock of planting. In fact, all the trees in this experiment will receive these two initial supplementary waterings.The deep pipe treatment consists of planting a tree seedling and then burying vertically some twelve inches (30 cm) deep next to the tree pot soil ball, a PVC pipe with a 2" (6.25cm) diameter. We refer to this treatment as "active irrigation" because the trees will be watered every two weeks with 2.0 L of water. The length of the pvc pipe is 50 cm and open at the bottom and water will infiltrate into the soil. The volume of the pipe is near 1 liter. water will be applied twice for a total volume of 2.0 L. (Morgan M, Zimmerman TW 2014 Evaluation of drought tolerance in five native Caribbean tree species with landscape potential. Tree Planter's Notes 57:49-60) This pipe will serve as a means to concentrate supplementary water near the deeper roots of the tree seedlings. These trees will receive 2.0 L of water every two week. In a previous experiment, 2 L of water was applied every two weeks, because another researcher used that quantity (Bainbridge, 2002). However, this quantity of water is not enough for the species used on the island of St Croix. Also, it must be mentioned that Bainbridge performs his experiments in the Mojave Desert. Trees that grow there have to be extremely drought tolerant.The next three treatments are considered passive irrigation because after planting, and the initial supplementary watering, the only water they will receive is from rain and the condensation of dew. The first "passive" treatment consists of planting trees in small 4" (10 cm) deep basins, approximately 20-30" (50-70 cm) square. Rain water is supposed to pool in the basin and soak into the ground. The second passive treatment is similar to the first with the addition of wood chips mulch in the water catch basin. The mulch is to act as sponge.There is a new technology we would like to try out, it is called a GROASIS waterbox https://www.groasis.com/. In essence, it collects rainfall and the condensation of dew, and stores the water inside the box. By use of a cotton wick, and capillary action, the water steadily drips from the box to the base of the tree seedling. According the manufacturer and independent researchers about 50 ml of dew is collected every night per wick.(Liu, Zhen, and Rhen, 2014Of course, all plants will receive rainwater whenever it rains. The amount of rain water that falls in each precipitation event will be measured via a computerized gauge at the UVI- St Croix campus weather station. Evapo-transpiration will be estimated weekly by filling a pre-existing evapo-transpiration pan with 10" (25 cm) of water and then measuring the change in water levels to the nearest centimeter. Soil moisture in the rooting zone, will be measured via gypsum block soil moisture sensors will be measured daily with a datalogger.We will measure survival/mortality, tree height, stem diameter above 6" and the number of branches monthly during the course of three and a half years. The experimental design is that of analysed in a completely randomized block design in order to determine if there is a statistical difference amongst treatments and species. The location of the blocks is determined by the slope of the planting site. Data will be analysed using the menu driven version of SAS called JMP.

Progress 08/22/16 to 07/31/21

Outputs
Target Audience:Nursery folks, landscapers, botanical gardens, enviromental groups,home owners and VI Department of Agriculture Changes/Problems:Category 5 hurricanes Irma and Maria during September 2017, destroyed greenhouses, shade house and tree species started for this research project. New sources of seeds needed to be found to restart trees for outplanting.COVID-19 shut down and restrictions during 2020-1 limited activity and access to supplies. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?A forestry display was incorporated in the annual February Ag Fair 2017, 20, 22. Pruning/hurricane recovery workshops were conducted on St Croix and St Thomas during 2018-19. UVI students and post high school students assisted with seed collection, cleaning and planting. Students assisted with watering seed flats and germination over time. Two students assisted with planting trees to the replicated plot, apply water and collect data. Covid-19 restriction hampered these activities during 2020-1.. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Fiscal years 2016-7 wwere dedicated to the collection of seeds, and the production of planting stock for outplanting in the UVI - AES agroforestry plot at the start of the rainy season at the end of the 2017 year , which would be the beginning of FY 2018. We had the following tree species ready for outplanting in the greenhouse: Bourreria succulenta,Bucida buceras, Canella winteriana, Cedrela odorata, Ceiba pentandra, Cordia collococa, Cordia rickseckeri, Eugenia spp, Guaiacum officinale, Plumeria alba, and Tabebuia heterophylla. In additin we worked with the native plam species, Roystonea boriquiensis, also known as Puerto RIcan Royal Palm. We collected data seed germination and seed weights as part of the production process. Unfortunately, Hurricanes Maria and Irma struck the island of St. Croix in September. Hurricane Maria was a category 5 hurricane which destroyed the UVI-AES greenhouses and collapsed the shade house where much of the planting stock was hardening up for outplanting. Most, 89%, of the planting stock was destroyed. The agroforestry plot which was where the outplanting was to take place was covered in fallen branches and trees. However, by the end of calendar year 2017, the fallen timber was removed from the plot. Following two devastating category 5 hurricanes in September 2017, seeds were not available until late in the year. Even with a damaged greenhouse, three native tree species were germinated and grown to the liner stage. In 2018, 81 native trees were planted in an experiment called Passive versus Active Irrigation. Three species are being tested are: Lignumvitae (Guaiacum oficinale), Spanish Cedar (Cedrela odorata), and Gre-Gre (Bucida buceras). The 3 tree species have different growth rates. Lignumvitae grows the slowest, Spanish cedar the fastest, and Gre-Gre is intermediate between the two other species. There are three experimental treatments: trees planted in mulch filled shallow basins, trees planted in the conventional fashion, and trees planted with a PVC pipe with holes drilled into the side closest to the tree. The pipes are approximately 30 cm long with a diameter of 5 cm. Every two weeks a gallon (3.8 L) of water is poured into the pipes. This is considered the active irrigation treatment. The passive irrigation treatment is the use of mulch filled basins to accumulate and conserve rainwater. We are interested in comparing the effect of the treatments within the species, because the species growth rates are so dissimilar. Each species block consists of 27 trees assigned one of the 3 experimental treatments. So each species block has 9 trees assigned to the conventional planting or control treatment, 9 trees assigned to the passive irrigation treatment, and 9 trees assigned to the active irrigation treatment. Plants were monitored for height growth and survival since November of 2018. The project got a late start due to the destruction of the greenhouses and their contents by Hurricane Maria in 2017. Therefore, plant production needed to start over in order to have plants for this experiment. Initial results suggest that height growth is best increased by planting the trees in shallow much filled basins. During 2020, we were operating under Covid-19 restrictions since March, yet still collected data monthly. Our original hypothesis was that the trees would all do better regardless of species in the active irrigation or deep pipe treatment, where they were being watered every 2 weeks with 3.8 liters (a gallon of water). Followed by the trees planted in the basin treatment, which would accumulate and store rainwater in their basins. Finally, the trees in the control treatment, that is to say in a conventional manner, would do the worst. That did not what has been observed. The Spanish Cedars. (Cedrela odorata) performed the best, in the basin treatment, the Gre-Gres (Bucida buceras) trees performed best in the control, and the Lignumvitaes performed best in with the deep pipes. However, there is a noticeable gradient in soil properties (either chemical or physical and/or both) from west to east and where the trees grew the best was in the eastern third of the field. The Spanish Cedars subjected to the basin treatment are growing in this third, as are the Gre-Gres in the control treatment and the Lignumvitae in the Deep Pipe irrigation treatment. It also must be mentioned that most of the Lignumvitae look sickly. They do not like this soil or planting site. Physical and/or chemical properties like compaction or high pH of the calcareous soil could be the reason. The row these trees are planted in is next to a busy road with several hundred years of existence. Perhaps there was building or stone wall on site that hasn't existed for a long time. While digging the planting holes for this site a big block of coral used for construction of colonial era buildings was found lying on the surface of the soil. With both Spanish Cedar and Gre-Gre/Black Olive, I would have expected that to be the same case with Lignumvitae. But this species has not done well at all. Most of the 27 Lignumvitae are dead or dying. It does not like the calcareous soil at all, whether due to chemical, physical properties or both.

Publications


    Progress 10/01/20 to 07/31/21

    Outputs
    Target Audience:Nurseries in the US Virgin Islands, Botanical gardens, VI Department of Agriculture, Nature Conservancy, local home owners, St Croix Enviromental Association, National Park Service and UVI Cooperative Extension Service. Changes/Problems:Covid-19 restriction imposed by University of the Virgin Islands impaired progress. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?Covid-19 restriction hampered these activities. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?Complete the project and prepare a final report.Write a new Plan of Research.

    Impacts
    What was accomplished under these goals? Even though Covid-19 restrictions were in place, data was collected throughout the year.

    Publications


      Progress 10/01/19 to 09/30/20

      Outputs
      Target Audience:The Virgin Island's nursery community, backyard gardeners, Cooperative Extension Service, VI Dept. of Agriculture, St George villageBotanical Gardens, local home owners and environmental groups. Changes/Problems:The covid-19 pandemic hit the US Virgin Islands with stay-at-home orders in March and August. This significantly influenced research during these times. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?A student assisted the researcher with watering regimes and collecting monthly data. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?A student was able to attend the Southern Association of Agricultural Scientists in late January, 2020 and present a poster on research results. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?Complete the monthly monitoring of the growth and development of the tree species in the trial of multiple irrigation regimes for establishment of trees in the semi-arid US Virgin Islands.

      Impacts
      What was accomplished under these goals? We have been operating under Covid-19 restrictions since March, yet still collected data monthly.Our original hypothesis was that the trees would all do better regardless of species in the active irrigation or deep pipe treatment, where they were being watered every 2 weeks with 3.8 liters (a gallon of water). Followed by the trees planted in the basin treatment, which would accumulate and store rainwater in their basins. Finally, the trees in the control treatment, that is to say in a conventional manner, would do the worst. That did not what has been observed. The Spanish Cedars. (Cedrela odorata) performed the best, in the basin treatment, the Gre-Gres (Bucida buceras) trees performed best in the control, and the Lignumvitaes performed best in with the deep pipes. However, there is a noticeable gradient in soil properties (either chemical or physical and/or both) from west to east and where the trees grew the best was in the eastern third of the field. The Spanish Cedars subjected to the basin treatment are growing in this third, as are the Gre-Gres in the control treatment and the Lignumvitae in the Deep Pipe irrigation treatment. It also must be mentioned that most of the Lignumvitae look sickly. They do not like this soil or planting site. Physical and/or chemical properties like compaction or high pH of the calcareous soil could be the reason. The row these trees are planted in is next to a busy road with several hundred years of existence. Perhaps there was building or stone wall on site that hasn't existed for a long time. While digging the planting holes for this site a big block of coral used for construction of colonial era buildings was found lying on the surface of the soil. With both Spanish Cedar and Gre-Gre/Black Olive, I would have expected that to be the same case with Lignumvitae. But this species has not done well at all.Most of the 27 Lignumvitae are dead or dying. Itdoes not like the calcareous soil at all, whether due to chemical, physical properties or both.

      Publications

      • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2020 Citation: Sanchez, EP, M Morgan, TW Zimmerman. 2020. Asexual propagation of Bucida buceras: Air layering versus ground layering. https://journals.ashs.org/hortsci/view/journals/hortsci/55/9S/article-pS1.xml


      Progress 10/01/18 to 09/30/19

      Outputs
      Target Audience:Nurseries, Botanical Gardens, VI Dept. Natural Resources, VI Dept. of Agriculture, US Fish & Wildlife, local residents and landscapers Changes/Problems:Hurricane Maria in September 2017 destroyed the UVI greenhouses and most native trees.needed for seed collection. Greenhouses have not yet been repaired. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?UVI students and post high school students assisted with seed collection, cleaning and planting. Students assisted with watering seed flats and germination over time.Two students assisted with planting trees to the replicated plot, apply water and collect data. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?work with the students to water trees weekly, collect data monthly and maintain the plot by cutting grass around the trees. . Phenology and seeds of new native species will be sought out weekly. ,

      Impacts
      What was accomplished under these goals? We planted 81 native tree species in an experiment called Passive versus Active Irrigation. Three species are being tested are: Lignumvitae (Guaiacum oficinale), Spanish Cedar (Cedrela odorata), and Gre-Gre (Bucida buceras). The 3 tree species have different growth rates. Lignumvitae grows the slowest, Spanish cedar the fastest, and Gre-Gre is intermediate between the two other species. There are three experimental treatments: trees planted in mulch filled shallow basins, trees planted in the conventional fashion, and trees planted with a PVC pipe with holes drilled into the side closest to the tree. The pipes are approximately 30 cm long with a diameter of 5 cm. Every two weeks a gallon (3.8 L) of water is poured into the pipes. This is considered the active irrigation treatment. The passive irrigation treatment is the use of mulch filled basins to accumulate and conserve rainwater.We are interested in comparingthe effect of the treatments within the species, because the species growth rates are so dissimilar. Each species block consists of 27 trees assigned one of the 3 experimental treatments. So each species block has 9 trees assigned to the conventional planting or control treatment, 9 trees assigned to the passive irrigation treatment, and 9 trees assigned to the active irrigation treatment.We have been monitoring height growth and survival since November of 2018. The project got a late start due to the destruction of the greenhouses and their contents by Hurricane Maria in 2017. Therefore, plant production needed to start over in order to have plants for this experiment. Initial results suggest that height growth is best increased by planting the trees in shallow much filled basins.

      Publications


        Progress 10/01/17 to 09/30/18

        Outputs
        Target Audience:Homeowners, nursery and garden centers, botanical gardens, national park service, VI DPNR, USFWS Changes/Problems:The devasation by two category 5 hurricanes and destruction of the greenhouses and shadehouse, negatively impacted the accomplishments for the year. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?A forestry display was was incorporated in the annual Ag Fair. Pruning/hurricane recovery workshops were conducted on St Croix and St Thomas. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Information was distributed at the Ag Fair and workshop. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?Establish the tree irrigation studies with three native species.

        Impacts
        What was accomplished under these goals? Following two devastating catigory 5 hurricanes, seeds were not available until late in the year. Even with a damaged greenhouse, three native tree species were germinated and grown to the liner stage.

        Publications

        • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Published Year Published: 2018 Citation: Morgan, M. and T.W. Zimmerman. 2018. VI Research Day. Page 3.


        Progress 10/01/16 to 09/30/17

        Outputs
        Target Audience:Tree prodcuers in the US Virgin Islands and the greater Caribbean area Changes/Problems:As previously mentioned Hurricane Maria was a category 5 hurricane which destroyed the UVI-AES greenhouses and collapsed the shade house where much of the planting stock was hardening up for outplanting. Much of the planting stock was destroyed. The agroforestry plot which was where the outplanting was to take place was covered in fallen branches and trees. However by the end of calendar year 2017, the fallen timber was removed from the plot. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?So far Fiscal year 2018 has been dedicated to producing replacing the destroyed planting stock. However it must be mentioned that enough planting stock survived to perform some limited outplanting this year.

        Impacts
        What was accomplished under these goals? Fiscal year 2017 was dedicated to the collection of seeds, and the production of planting stock for outplanting in the UVI - AES agroforestry plot at the start of the rainy season at the end of the 2017 year , which would be the beginning of FY 2018. We had the following tree species ready for outplanting in the greenhouse: Bourreria succulenta,Bucida buceras, Canella winteriana, Cedrela odorata,Ceiba pentandra, Cordia collococa, Cordia rickseckeri, Eugenia spp, Guaiacum officinale,Plumeria alba, and Tabebuia heterophylla. In additin we worked with the native plam species, Roystonea boriquiensis, also known as Puerto RIcan Royal Palm. We collected data seed germination and seed weights as part of the production process. Unfortunately, Hurricanes Maria and Irma struck the island of St. Croix this past September . Hurricane Maria was a category 5 hurricane which destroyed the UVI-AES greenhouses and collapsed the shade house where much of the planting stock was hardening up for outplanting. Much of the planting stock was destroyed. The agroforestry plot which was where the outplanting was to take place was covered in fallen branches and trees. However by the end of calendar year 2017, the fallen timber was removed from the plot.

        Publications


          Progress 08/22/16 to 09/30/16

          Outputs
          Target Audience:Tree prodcuers in the US Virgin Islands and the greater Caribbean araea Changes/Problems:As previously mentioned Hurricane Maria was a category 5 hurricane which destroyed the UVI-AES greenhouses and collapsed the shade house where much of the planting stock was hardening up for outplanting. Much of the planting stock was destroyed. The agroforestry plot which was where the outplanting was to take place was covered in fallen branches and trees. However by the end of calendar year 2017, the fallen timber was removed from the plot. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?So far Fiscal year 2018 has been dedicated to producing replacing the destroyed planting stock. However it must be mentioned that enough planting stock survived to perform some limited outplanting this year.

          Impacts
          What was accomplished under these goals? Fiscal year 2017 was dedicated to the collection of seeds, and the production of planting stock for outplanting in the UVI -AES agroforestry plot at the start of the rainy season at the end of the 2017 year , which would be the beginning of FY 2018. We had the following tree species ready for outplanting in the greenhouse: Bourreria succulenta,Bucida buceras, Canella winteriana, Cedrela odorata,Ceiba pentandra, Cordia collococa, Cordia rickseckeri, Eugenia spp,Guaiacum officinale,Plumeria alba, and Tabebuia heterophylla. In additin we worked with the native plam species, Roystonea boriquiensis, also known as Puerto RIcan Royal Palm. We collected data seed germination and seed weights as part of the production process. Unfortunately, Hurricanes Maria and Irma struck the island of St. Croix this past September . Hurricane Maria was a category 5 hurricane which destroyed the UVI-AES greenhouses and collapsed the shade house where much of the planting stock was hardening up for outplanting. Much of the planting stock was destroyed. The agroforestry plot which was where the outplanting was to take place was covered in fallen branches and trees. However by the end of calendar year 2017, the fallen timber was removed from the plot.

          Publications