Source: ALABAMA A&M UNIVERSITY submitted to
SENSORY EVALUATION AND VALUE-ADDED APPLICATIONS OF EDIBLE DAYLILIES (HEMEROCALLIS, SPP)
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
TERMINATED
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1008994
Grant No.
(N/A)
Project No.
ALAX-012-1116
Proposal No.
(N/A)
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Program Code
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Feb 1, 2016
Project End Date
Dec 12, 2017
Grant Year
(N/A)
Project Director
Coggins, PA, C.
Recipient Organization
ALABAMA A&M UNIVERSITY
4900 MERIDIAN STREET
NORMAL,AL 35762
Performing Department
Food & Animal Sciences
Non Technical Summary
PROJECT SUMMARYInterest in the sensory aspects and acceptance of edible plants, in particular the daylily cultivar (Hemerocallis, spp) continues to grow due to consumer interest in the food, culinary, health, functional and medicinal properties of these plants.There are over 52,000 known daylily cultivars, all are edible.Daylilies are an underutilized food source. Consumers do not know how to use them for food.The sensorial and functional properties have not been thoroughly researched.The acceptance of edible daylily (Hemerocallis, spp), is dependent on consumer awareness.Additional value-added benefits such as the functional and medicinal properties of such plants will allow opportunity for increased consumer usage resulting in increased revenue for growers and businesses.During the period of this project, the objectives to be carried out will be to grow edible angiosperm (Angiospermae) daylily cultivars (Hemerocallis, spp.) in segregated plots, determine the optimum harvest time for preferred sensory attributes of the selected cultivars, develop a sensory descriptive language for each attribute category, define the functional and value-added applications of such cultivars by incorporation into novel foods as extracts, dried powders, and pastes, investigate medicinal and toxicological properties of edible plants, determine consumer acceptance of new products developed containing the edible plants, and investigate the bioactivities for safety and potential cytotoxicity.This research will provide investigation into: the usage of daylilies as a food source, development of a sensory lexicon, acceptance, and value-added applications as food ingredients.This research will provide educational opportunities for students and information for the agricultural and food community.
Animal Health Component
0%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
50%
Developmental
50%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
5027220309075%
5022239115025%
Goals / Objectives
RESEARCH OBJECTIVESTo grow select cultivars of edible daylilies (Hemerocallis, spp) for the exploration of sensory evaluation, value-added agricultural purposes, food engineering applications and toxicological studies on safety and cytotoxicity. Subtitle: Selection and Growing of Daylily (Hemerocallis, spp.) Cultivars Experimental plots will be established at the Alabama A&M University, Winfred Thomas Agricultural research Station (WTARS), with emphasis on genotypic diversity for continuous and abundant flowering. Selection of cultivars will be assessed on degree of the secondary metabolites anthocyanins that originate from the flavonoid biosynthesis pathway (Hall et al., 2015). The establishment of daylily plots at the WTARS will begin with a cursory analysis using a minimum of 50 cultivars with broad genetic variations. Post-harvest analysis of flowers will be carried out to determine desirable functional chemical profile. Desired types will be selected for further analysis and parentage for hybridization to create unique cultivars with enhanced desirable characteristics.To develop a sensory lexicon for daylily cultivars, whereby developing complete sets of descriptive attributes for the following categories: appearance, smell, flavor, basic tastes, feeling factors, texture (hand-held), texture (mouth) for select daylily cultivars.Subtitle: Sensory Ranking Procedure of Select Daylily (Hemerocallis, spp): The flowers of at least 15 daylily cultivars will be ranked according to overall preference. The top five ranked cultivars will be chosen for formal sensory studies and value-added applications to foods. The daylily flowers will be hand harvested based on the harvesting method of Pollard (2006).Subtitle: Quantitative Descriptive Analysis of Daylily (Hemerocallis spp.) Cultivars At least five panelists will be trained on QDA procedures and will be consistently calibrated and refined using reference standards. Panelists will be trained for no less than 36 hours. Daylily cultivars will be evaluated descriptively for appearance, aroma, flavor, basic tastes, texture (hand-held), texture (fork), texture (oral), feeling factors, and chew rate. Training will be performed using a 15-point intensity scale for references where, 0 = attribute not detected; and 15 = attribute extremely detected from an intensity level. Panelists will develop the terminology that will be used to generate the sensory lexiconal language for the daylily cultivars.Determination of value-added applications for Hemerocallis by incorporating the daylily components into foods as functional agents, colorants, texturizers, flavorings, or other comprised value-added additions. Subtitle: Sensory acceptance and product development of beverages containing Hemerocallis powder. Incorporation of Hemerocallis powder into beverages will be evaluated for sensory acceptance. Physical analyses will be performed on the beverages, i.e. rheological studies, color studies (Hunter color). Beverages will be evaluated for sensory acceptance of preferred cultivar.Subtitle: Instrumental Textural profile analysis of the Hemerocallis cultivars to evaluate and establish a correlation between subjective sensory observations to Instrumental Textural Profile Analysis (ITPA) during the storage period of Hemerocallis cultivars Instron Universal Testing Apparatus, (ATS Series model 1601, Warren, MI) will be used to obtain textural profile of the Hemerocallis cultivars samples.Subtitle: To maximize the fresh-life of Hemerocallis cultivars via environmental controlled storage studies to optimize the shelf life and the development of a sorption isotherm. Isotherm Development: A desorption sorption isotherm will be established for each cultivar. Gravimetric methods of establishing a desorption isotherm are based on exposing the samples in a controlled environment using salt solutionsShelf Life Studies: The samples (15 cultivars) will be placed in the Environmental chamber (EC) (ESPEC Model BTL 433-4 CU. ft, Hudsonville, Michigan). Hemerocallis cultivars will be stored in the EC at 15°C and 90 and 95% Relative Humidity (HR). The samples will be stored in EC for 3, 6, & 9 days. Each experimental unit will be replicated three timesTo determine the optimum month for consumption and storage quality of Hemerocallis cultivars. Subtitle: Determination of the optimum month for consumption of Hemerocallis grown in northern Alabama: Observance will be performed using an observance quality scale. The observance scale will have quality score selections from one to five, with one being "unmarketable" and five being "fresh market acceptable". The daylilies will be harvested at one-hour intervals and the observation scale of quality will be performed on each immediately prior to the formal sensory descriptive analysis will be performed. The flowers will be observed each day following harvest to determine length of acceptable marketability. 5: To determine the bioactivities (safety and potential cytotoxicity) of daylily cultivars Hemerocallis, spp Subtitle: Determination of the bioactivities (toxicity and cytotoxicity) of daylily cultivars (Hemerocallis spp) grown in northern Alabama: In this objective the biological activities (safety and toxicity) of 15 daylily cultivars will be determined. We will identify varietal differences on bioactivity in two cancer cell lines (Caco-2 and Hep 2G) and non-cancer cell line (Thle-3). We will investigate anticancer properties i.e., proliferation inhibition, apoptosis inducing and anti-inflammatory activities, modulations to antioxidants enzymes that play crucial roles in several chronic diseases such as cancer, diabetes and obesity.Cytotoxicity properties of Daylily cultivarsCytoxicity determination by LDH measurements: LDH release will be assayed using a colorimetric cytotoxicity detection kit (LDH) (Roche Diagnostics, Indianapolis, IN) according to the manufacturer's instructions. Absorbance will be recorded at 490nm and experiment will be performed in triplicates.Daylily extracts: The antiproliferative activity of lipids will be determined by the MTT (3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-2,5 diphenyltetrazolium bromide) assay Caco-2, Hep 2G and Thle-3 cells will be seeded at a density of 0.9 × 103 cells/well into a 96-well plate in final volume of 100ul of media. Anti- proliferative properties of the daylily extracts will be determined by reading the absorbance of the reduced intracellular formazan product at 550/630 nm on a synergy HT micro plate reader. Assay will be performed in triplicates.Effect of Daylily extracts on endogenous antioxidants Enzymatic and non-enzymatic assays (in vitro and in vivo experiment): CAT activity will be measured by the reaction of formaldehyde produced from methanol with Purpald to produce a chromophore according to the method of Johansson and Hakan Borg (1988).Anti-inflammatory properties of Daylily extracts.Caco-2, Hep 2G and Thle-3 cells culture supernatants from the basolateral side will be collected and pooled for analysis of inflammatory markers. Supernatants will be applied to membranes containing cytokine antibody array (Ray Biotech) for 1 h at room temperature, and detection will be performed with horseradish peroxidase-coupled secondary antibodies and chemiluminescence substrate (Ray Biotech). Array spot densities will be evaluated and compared using Quantity One software (Bio-Rad, Hercules, CA). Cell inflammatory markers TNF-α, IL-1β, IL-4, IL-6, IL-10, IL-11, IL-12 and IL-13 will be measured.
Project Methods
Selection and Growing of Daylily (Hemerocallis, spp.) Cultivars Selections will be made among the more than 35,000 available cultivars for types that will flourish in Alabama. Experimental plots will be established at the Alabama A&M University, Winfred Thomas Agricultural research Station (WTARS) with emphasis on genotypic diversity for continuous and abundant flowering. Selection of cultivars will be assessed on degree of the secondary metabolites anthocyanins that originate from the flavonoid biosynthesis pathway (Hall et al., 2015). The establishment of daylily plots at the WTARS will begin with a cursory analysis using a minimum of 50 cultivars with broad genetic variations. Initial plots will be planted in a complete block design in two locations at the WTARS to represent full sun and partial shade. Post-harvest analysis of flowers will be carried out to determine desirable functional chemical profile. Desired types will be selected for further analysis and parentage for hybridization to create unique cultivars with enhanced desirable characteristics.Sensory Ranking Procedure of Select Daylily (Hemerocallis, spp): The flowers of at least 15 daylily cultivars will be ranked according to overall preference. The top five ranked cultivars will be chosen for formal sensory studies and value-added applications to foods. The daylily flowers will be hand harvested based on the harvesting method of Pollard (2006). Quantitative Descriptive Analysis of Daylily (Hemerocallis spp.) Cultivars Formal sensory analysis using the quantitative descriptive analysis (QDA) methodology will be performed. At least five panelists will be trained on QDA procedures and will be consistently calibrated and refined using reference standards. Daylily cultivars will be evaluated descriptively for appearance, aroma, flavor, basic tastes, texture (hand-held), texture (fork), texture (oral), feeling factors, and chew rate. Training will be performed using a 15-point scale for references where, 0 = attribute not detected; and 15 = attribute extremely detected from an intensity level. The objective of this portion of the study is to develop the sensory lexicon for the cultivars tested. At least fifteen daylily cultivars will be analyzed using quantitative descriptive analysis (QDA). Daylily flowers will be harvested on the days of QDA panels and held for a minimum time, less than two hours. Teflon® sniff bottles will be utilized for the olfactory portion of the QDA panels. Panelists will develop the terminology that will be used to generate the sensory lexiconal language for the daylily cultivars. Sensory acceptance and product development of beverages containing Hemerocallis powder. Incorporation of Hemerocallis powder into beverages will be evaluated for sensory acceptance. Hemerocallis sepals and tepals will be oven dried then pulverized using a Waring spice grinder to a minimum of 60 mesh sizing. Physical analyses will be performed on the beverages, i.e. rheological studies, color studies (Hunter color). Beverages will be evaluated for sensory acceptance of preferred cultivar.Instrumental Textural profile analysis of the Hemerocallis cultivars to evaluate and establish a correlation between subjective sensory observations to Instrumental Textural Profile Analysis (ITPA) during the storage period of Hemerocallis cultivars Instron Universal Testing Apparatus, (ATS Series model 1601, Warren, MI) will be used to obtain textural profile of the Hemerocallis cultivars samples. A 5 KN load cell and a Warner-Bratzler and a cylindrical punch attachments will be used. Instrumental textural profile parameters obtained by cyclic compression of the samples to 75% of their original thickness. Toughness, which is the ability of the product to withstand repeated stress before fracture, will be measured as the area under the first curve of ITPA.To maximize the fresh-life of Hemerocallis cultivars via environmental controlled storage studies to optimize the shelf life and the development of a sorption isotherm. Isotherm Development: A desorption sorption isotherm will be established for each cultivar. Gravimetric methods of establishing a desorption isotherm are based on exposing the samples in a controlled environment using salt solutions to establish equilibrium moisture content (EMC). Hence, EMC vs Aw will be established and the GAP mathematical model will be used to fit the model.Shelf Life Studies: The samples (15 cultivars) will be placed in the Environmental chamber (EC) (ESPEC Model BTL 433-4 CU. ft, Hudsonville, Michigan). Hemerocallis cultivars will be stored in the EC at 15°C and 90 and 95% Relative Humidity (HR). The samples will be stored in EC for 3, 6, & 9 days. Each experimental unit will be replicated three timesDetermination of the optimum month for consumption of Hemerocallis grown in northern Alabama:Observance will be performed using an observance quality scale. The observance scale will have quality score selections from one to five, with one being "unmarketable" and five being "fresh market acceptable".The daylilies will be harvested at one-hour intervals and the observation scale of quality will be performed on each immediately prior to the formal sensory descriptive analysis will be performed. The flowers will be observed each day following harvest to determine length of acceptable marketability. Thus, the shelf-life will be defined as the length of time the flower maintains acceptable appearance for marketability. Determination of the bioactivities (toxicity and cytotoxicity) of daylily cultivars (Hemerocallis spp) grown in northern Alabama: In this objective the biological activities (safety and toxicity) of 15 daylily cultivars will be determined. We will identify varietal differences on bioactivity in two cancer cell lines (Caco-2 and Hep 2G) and non-cancer cell line (Thle-3). We will investigate anticancer properties i.e., proliferation inhibition, apoptosis inducing and anti-inflammatory activities, modulations to antioxidants enzymes that play crucial roles in several chronic diseases such as cancer, diabetes and obesity.Cytotoxicity properties of Daylily cultivarsCytoxicity determination by LDH measurements: LDH release will be assayed using a colorimetric cytotoxicity detection kit (LDH) (Roche Diagnostics, Indianapolis, IN) according to the manufacturer's instructions. Absorbance will be recorded at 490nm and experiment will be performed in triplicates.Daylily extracts: The antiproliferative activity of lipids will be determined by the MTT (3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-2,5 diphenyltetrazolium bromide) assay Caco-2, Hep 2G and Thle-3 cells will be seeded at a density of 0.9 × 103 cells/well into a 96-well plate in final volume of 100ul of media. Anti- proliferative properties of the daylily extracts will be determined by reading the absorbance of the reduced intracellular formazan product at 550/630 nm on a synergy HT micro plate reader. Assay will be performed in triplicates.Effect of Daylily extracts on endogenous antioxidants Enzymatic and non-enzymatic assays (in vitro and in vivo experiment): CAT activity will be measured by the reaction of formaldehyde produced from methanol with Purpald to produce a chromophore according to the method of Johansson and Hakan Borg (1988). Reduced (GSH) forms (nmol/mg protein) will be measured using a spectrophotometric assay (Griffith, 1985). The experiment will be repeated three times and samples will be analyzed in triplicates.Anti-inflammatory properties of Daylily extracts.Caco-2, Hep 2G and Thle-3 cells culture supernatants from the basolateral side will be collected and pooled for analysis of inflammatory markers. Supernatants will be applied to membranes containing cytokine antibody array (Ray Biotech) for 1 h at room temperature, and detection will be performed with horseradish peroxidase-coupled secondary antibodies and chemiluminescence substrate (Ray Biotech).

Progress 02/01/16 to 12/12/17

Outputs
Target Audience: Nothing Reported Changes/Problems:The projects accomplishments and goals were not realized due to the severeillness and subsequent death of a member in the PI's family. Due to the circumstances, she left the employment of the university. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? The projects accomplishments and goals were not realized due to the severeillness and subsequent death of a member in the PI's family. Due to the circumstances, she left the employment of the university.

Publications


    Progress 02/01/16 to 09/30/16

    Outputs
    Target Audience:Non-Technical Summary This research aids in fulfilling NIFA's priority need, i.e. to train African American and minority students in the program area of global food security and hunger and the knowledge area of new and improved foods. The field of sensory science / evaluation is evolving rapidly. The need for sensory scientists will continue to increase exponentially as industry has discovered the value of this designated STEM employee. AAMU and the FAS department will remain an integral part of this highly specialized area in efforts to provide underrepresented and minority students to the sensory workforce. As educators, FAS faculty continuously work to meet the tremendous challenge of preparing students for tomorrow's scientific and technical workforce, i.e. sensory science. FAS faculty are committed to addressing national industry and research needs by working toward insuring well qualified students upon graduation to aid the STEM workforce. This commitment from FAS/AAMU faculty demonstrates continuous effort to maintain a preferred and desirable sensory program for future generations. In efforts to meet the future needs of a dynamic world and society, CALNS and FAS strive to offer diverse programs, many of which are not traditionally associated with agriculture. The department of FAS offers food chemistry, food engineering, and food microbiology and has recently added sensory science to the curriculum and specialty areas of teaching and research. With that being stated, it is important to mention that the above four mentioned areas are key requirements for a food science curriculum as indicated by the Institute of Food Technologists (IFT, 2011). The long range goal of FAS is to further develop and enhance its sensory program to the pivotal matriculation point of at least three to five sensory graduates per year that will enter the STEM workforce as sensory evaluation technicians or sensory scientists. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?What Opportunities for Training and Professional Development Has the Project Provided? Six students (three graduate and three undergraduate) have benefited from this project by having the opportunity to work on this project, provide posters for STEM day, and gain knowledge through hands-on experience in food and sensory science applications utilizing daylily (Hemerocallis, spp). How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Nothing Reported What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Provide crucial data on the sensory profiling and lexiconal descriptive language for edible daylily (Hemerocallis, spp) cultivars, thereby adding knowledge to the areas of food science, sensory evaluation, and how these plants may be used as foods or components of foods and to develop a sensory lexicon for daylily cultivars, whereby developing complete sets of descriptive attributes for the following categories: appearance, smell, flavor, basic tastes, feeling factors, texture (hand-held), texture (mouth) for select daylily cultivars. Provide needed information on the application of Hemerocallis into novel and existing foods to determine functionality, acceptability and value-added aspects. This information will add support to product development, food engineering and sensory areas within food science. And aid in determination of value-added applications for Hemerocallis by incorporating the daylily components into foods as functional agents, colorants, texturizers, flavorings, or other comprised value-added additions. Generate information on the optimum month for consumption of Hemerocallis to aid growers, the fresh market industry, and the food industry to maximize the fresh-life of Hemerocallis cultivars via environmental controlled storage studies to optimize the shelf life and the development of a sorption isotherm. Provide novel information on the bioactivity, safety and cytotoxicity of Hemerocallis. This will support cancer cell research and investigate anticancer properties, proliferation inhibition and anti-inflammatory activities to determine any roles in chronic diseases such as cancer.

    Impacts
    What was accomplished under these goals? What was Accomplished Under These Goals: Selection and Growing of daylily cultivars: In efforts to acquire as many cultivars of daylilies as possible, fifty letters of request for daylily plants for research use were sent to daylily growers across the country. Of those, two positive responses were received, in which the daylily growers donated fourteen to twenty plants. Efforts are under way to increase the quantity of these cultivars by dividing the mature plants. In addition, two cultivars with fifteen plants each of daylilies Elegant Explosion and Barbara Mitchell, were purchased from a local nursery. The plants were mature and large and were separated at roots and replanted within two weeks after acquiring the cultivars. This provided over thirty plants for sensory purposes. Quantitative Descriptive Analysis of Daylily (Hemerocallis spp.) Cultivars: A trained sensory panel was used to establish terminology for describing the sensory attributes of the daylily cultivars Elegant Explosion and Barbara Mitchell. Quantitative descriptive analysis was applied to evaluate the samples in terms of the aroma, texture (mouth and hand-felt), flavor, and taste attributes. Seventy-four attributes were identified for Elegant Explosion and eighty-five for Barbara Mitchell daylily cultivar. There are "complex" and "fuzzy" terms found within both of these sets of attributes, of which further work will be applied to define and investigate these areas. The findings indicate that the main differences were in aroma, flavor and hand-held textural properties. The Barbara Mitchell daylily cultivar was more "spicy" with sensorily "complex" and "fuzzy" flavor terms. Hand-held textural attributes were different between the two cultivars. The daylily cultivar, Barbara Mitchell, demonstrated promise for usage in prepared salads due to the firm texture of the tepals and sepals. Sensory acceptance and product development of beverages containing Hemerocallis powder: Each daylily cultivar was evaluated for use in beverage applications. Research began with the leaf portion, which was freeze-dried, pulverized and incorporated into strawberry smoothie beverages. The target was a "green" strawberry smoothie; with "green" being due to the vivid green color of the dried, pulverized leaves. There was not an observed sensory difference between the two daylily cultivars, as deemed by the paired comparison sensory method of attribute difference testing procedures. Also, no one sample was preferred. Determination of the bioactivities (safety and potential cytotoxicity) of daylily cultivars (Hemerocallis spp) grown in northern Alabama: Toxicological evaluation antioxidant capacity and bioactive properties of herbal product (daylily flower-Hemerocallis, spp.) Daylily (Hemerocallis, spp) is a perennial herbaceous flowering plant used medicinally in many regions in Asia. In 1930 American Hemerocallis Society began hybridizing daylily to improve their characteristics. The two cultivars evaluated toxicologically were cultivars referred to as Barbara Mitchell and Elegant Explosion. Barbara Mitchell was registered in the daylily database in 1975 and Elegant Explosion was registered in 2004. Research suggests edible flowers are receiving renewed interest as a rich source polyphenol compounds and antioxidant potential. The objective of this study was to determine the polyphenol content and antioxidant activity. Both cultivars were harvested every day at eight in the morning and stored in -20°C to preserve. Samples were weighed and blended with 80% ethanol (v/v) and placed in rotary evaporator to concentration the sample. Then the samples were lyophilized before beginning the antioxidant and polyphenol assay. Total phenolic (TPC), total flavonoids (TFC), ferric reducing antioxidant potential (FRAP), and Trolox equivalent antioxidant capacity (TEAC) were conducted on the two daylily cultivars. Graduate Student Training: One graduate student was supported by this project.

    Publications