Source: AUBURN UNIV., ALABAMA COOPERATIVE EXTENSION SYSTEM submitted to
DEVELOPING ON-LINE AQUACULTURE CURRICULA
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
TERMINATED
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0218002
Grant No.
2009-38414-19692
Project No.
ALAE-2009-00476
Proposal No.
2009-00476
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Program Code
OW
Project Start Date
Jul 1, 2009
Project End Date
Jun 30, 2012
Grant Year
2009
Project Director
Cline, D. J.
Recipient Organization
AUBURN UNIV., ALABAMA COOPERATIVE EXTENSION SYSTEM
(N/A)
AUBURN UNIVERSITY,AL 36849
Performing Department
Alabama Cooperative Extension System
Non Technical Summary
United States school children have been falling further and further behind other nations in the areas of science and mathematics. Secondary school educators have found that using aquaculture to teach principles of math, science and business improves student interest and motivation and has the potential to positively affect chances for post-secondary success. However, teachers feel inadequately trained to teach many aquaculture related subjects and indicate a lack of readily available, easily understandable, and ready to integrate curriculum materials. The focus of this project is to understand teachers' aquaculture subject matter and training priorities by conducting a needs assessment; develop 12 video-podcasts and provide supplemental materials- readings, worksheets, activities, etc. related to the teachers' priorities and make them available on-line through www.alearn.info ; conduct teacher in-service training 2, 5-day and 5, 1-day to improve aquaculture teaching capacity and demonstrate how to infuse the video-podcasts into existing math, science, business and aquaculture curriculum. The impacts of the project include improved involvement of teachers in the development process of aquaculture curriculum; an increased awareness of relevant curricular materials; and an increased understanding and teaching capacity of teacher prioritized aquaculture subject matter. The on-line nature of the project ensures that teachers and students have access to this information regardless of the size or geographic locations of the schools.
Animal Health Component
100%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
100%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
90360993020100%
Goals / Objectives
Objective 1 - By September 2009 we will conduct a needs assessment of at least 100 teachers to determine the 12 aquaculturrally related subject matter areas with the greatest perceived teaching priority, need for curricular development and deficit in teacher knowledge. Objective 2 - By June 2011 we will use the results of objective 1 to increase the number and quality of easily accessible, research based, aquaculture teaching resources by producing 12 video lessons and curricular activities that are directly correlated to content standards within the math, science, and aquaculture course of study. Objective 3 - Throughout the project and culminating in June 2011 we will provide in-service training to improve secondary educators' aquaculture teaching capacity by improving their general aquaculture knowledge and knowledge of how to infuse aquaculture into existing curriculum using materials developed in objective 2. This project will utilize videos and podcasts to make experts available to teachers and students in grade 9-12 aquaculture programs regardless of the size of their programs. This also ensures that all students have access to this information regardless of the financial resources or geographic locations of the schools. Each video will provide content that immediately translates to the aquaculture program leaving the teacher more time to teach students rather than search for content in journal articles, text books, and other teaching resources. Expected products from this project include a list of teachers' perceived priorities of aquaculture topics, 12 video-podcast presentations-lessons, complete with downloadable supplemental readings, worksheets, and activities, based on the priority topics identified by teachers, and a series of in-service training workshops to demonstrate the lessons and improve aquaculture teaching competencies
Project Methods
Objective 1:PIs will develop a needs assessment of teachers with or interested in aquaculture programs using a Likert scale rating of teachers perceived teaching abilities, the relative importance, and availability of teaching materials in aquaculture areas. Open ended questions will allow suggested content areas. Survey analysis will provide the basis for video-podcasts and curricula. Objective 2:Using the needs assessment results a series of video-podcast presentations will be prepared. The PIs have significant aquaculture knowledge and access to AU's Department of Fisheries and Allied Aquacultures for content expertise. The PIs will seek expertise from other universities engaged in aquaculture education if necessary. The curricula will be developed around the Adobe Connect platform and include streaming video, power point presentations with voiceover, and interactive elements. Supplemental materials worksheets, suggested readings, handouts, correlated to national content standards etc. will complement the on-line presentation. The video-podcasts will be made available to a select group of secondary teachers for review and comment prior to going live on www.alearn.info. Presentation DVDs will also be made available to teachers at workshops and upon request. Objective 3:The PIs and collaborators will conduct in-service training opportunities: one 5 day residential workshop each year of the project on the GSCC campus and 5, 1-day workshops at schools around the state and region to introduce teachers to the lessons and how they can integrate the material into their classes. The PIs have conducted workshops for more than 10 years training over 200 teachers to use recirculating aquaculture systems to teach principles of math and science. Evaluation:Area I Enhancing agricultural education through curriculum improvements Objective 1:Evaluation criteria for needs assessment is the number of survey respondents. The target is 100 teachers. A second criterion is development of the top 12 teacher perceived priorities for aquaculture subject matter. Objective 2:We track the number of video-podcasts views and curriculum downloads with Web Trends site analysis software. This represents the distribution of the materials. From a sample of consumers, we will conduct surveys to see if-how materials were used. Objective 3:We will test participants' change in awareness of availability-quality of aquaculture curricula material through pre-post tests at workshops. Evaluation:Area 2 Increasing faculty teaching competencies Objective 1:This will be measured by our ability to identify the needs for teacher training and will be achieved by comparing teachers' current knowledge of aquaculture content with their perceived importance. Objective 2:Integrated interactive quizzes within the videos will ensure teachers comprehend the information. 70 percent accuracy will be required to move forward. Using Adobe Connect we will track incorrect answers to identify any weaknesses in the material. Objective 3:Pre-post testing at the workshops will measure change in knowledge. The post test will also allow self reporting any changes in teaching capacity.

Progress 07/01/09 to 06/30/12

Outputs
OUTPUTS: RESOURCES DEVELOPED An online needs assessment was developed and implemented to determine the need for aquaculture related training materials. One hundred eighty seven teachers responded. Based on the results of the assessment our team created a total of 13 Video elements (over 2 hrs and 20 minutes) with associated additional readings and handouts, a series of 4 Catfish lesson plans, a coloring book describing the catfish production process and participated in the production of a 4 hour virtual aquaculture workshop covering 14 topics. Video elements created included 1)Constructing a simple recirculating aquaculture system for classroom use (in interactive Flash based presentation), 2)An overview of aquaculture production systems (Voice over power point using Adobe Connect), 3)Spawning of the American oyster by thermal shock, 4)Pond-in-a-Bucket, demonstrating pond dynamics in a bucket, 5)Counting fish using mass enumeration, 6)Counting fish using volumetric enumeration, 7)How to safely drill holes in aquaria, 8)A virtual tour of a successful high school aquaculture program and demonstration of water quality adjustment. In addition, a series of career exploration videos were created to introduce students to various careers in aquaculture, fisheries and related disciplines. Included in the career exploration series were interview with a/an a)Extension Aquaculturist, b)Fisheries Technician and Student, c)Catfish Farmer d)Freshwater Fisheries Ecologist, e)Fisheries professor and world traveler. LESSON PLANS:The series of four catfish lesson plans with handouts and readings covered topics including: 1)Farming the waters, 2)Channel catfish life history and biology, 3)Brood fish management and 4)Feeding commercial catfish ponds. DISTRIBUTION OF PRODUCTS: Links to each of these products were placed on lesson plans page http://www.aces.edu/dept/fisheries/education/lessonplans.php in the education section of the www.Alearn.info web site. In addition to the web distribution of the products developed many dvds and printed materials were distributed at workshops and professional meetings. TRAININGS CONDUCTED: During the course of the grant 4, 5-day teacher training workshops were conducted and included 72 teachers from 9 states. Based on the evaluations of the workshops teachers found them extremely valuable and enjoyable. In addition to the 5-day training held each year 4, 1-day workshops were conducted at 3 locations in Alabama. These workshops included in-service and weekend sessions and involved 120 teachers. Teachers were provided with printed materials and DVDs containing the resources developed and more than 300 publications, 75 power point presentations, hundreds of aquaculture photos and a variety of lesson plan ideas. PARTICIPANTS: In addition to the PIs several individuals and organizations provided input and assistance in creating the video and online elements. Leslie Grille of Natural Outreach Solutions provided coordination, filming and editing assistance with the career exploration series of videos. Stan Arington, Marine Biology/Aquaculture teacher at Auburn High School along with several students developed the virtual tour of their aquaculture education program. Mario Lightfoote, Producer/Director for the Alabama Cooperative Extension System Communications and Marketing Program provided video production and editing for several of the video pieces. John Dijulio, Jason Adams and Tiffany Smith of the AU Production Media Group provided creative and technical services in the development of several of the pieces. The eXtension Freshwater Community of Practice and Vanessa Weldon developed the 4 hour webinar and recruited professionals from a number of other Universities to participate TARGET AUDIENCES: The target audience for this project was K-12 teachers, K-12 students and the general public PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Not relevant to this project.

Impacts
This project was designed to help teachers increase their knowledge of aquaculture and to provide resources that would allow them to spend more time teaching and less time hunting for information. Teachers attending the 5-day workshops demonstrated an average 35% increase in aquaculture related knowledge based on pre/post testing. At one of the 1-day workshops teachers pre/post test scores increased by 66%. Teacher responses to the post-workshop survey question "How do you feel the information presented will benefit your students included, (a) "I have more knowledge and a better understanding of the needs of fish & plants to successfully teach my students", (b) "Makes me a more knowledgeable teacher & more effective teacher" and "Gives them [students] a chance to apply principles to real world situations". The effectiveness and impact of the electronic resources developed is measured using WebTrends web site analysis software. The products developed were placed on the website www.alearn.info which is a collaboration between the Alabama Cooperative Extensions System, the Auburn University College of Agriculture and the Auburn University Department of fisheries and allied aquacultures. This web site has been very successful at disseminating educational aquaculture related materials to the K-12 community and the general public. The entire Alearn website contains 1422 pages. The education section managed by David Cline includes 358 pages that contain valuable educational resources related to aquaculture education. During the course of this grant, pages within the education section of the web site have be viewed a total of 1,298,761 times. The lesson plans page that contains the links to the new resources viewed 5,672 times thus far in 2012 has been viewed 23,460 times during the course of the grant period. The average user stays on the lesson plans page 153 seconds before clicking a link to leave the page. In web terms this figure is impressive. The Alearn website and electronic nature of the assets produced allows for wide geographic distribution of the information. In 2012 Alearn resources were accessed from 202 different countries. The majority of users are from the United States (55%) including all 50 states and all Canadian Providences.

Publications

  • Cline, D.J. (2012)Perception of Alabama science and career technology teachers concerning the Alabama aquaculture course of study. Aquaculture America Abstracts, Feb. 28-March 2. Las Vegas, NV
  • Cline, D.J. & Adams, J., (2011) America's Amazing Catfish Farmers, The Catfish institute. http://www.aces.edu/dept/fisheries/education/documents/CatfishColorin gBook_Final_small_110103_1.pdf
  • Cline, D.J. (2011)Perception of Alabama science and career technology teachers concerning the Alabama aquaculture course of study. ProQuest, Ann Arbor. (Dissertation)


Progress 07/01/09 to 06/30/10

Outputs
The project is moving forward and we are receiving favorable feedback from teachers. Eighty Eight teachers have responded to the needs assessment survey and 61 people have filled out the Government/University/Extension survey. The team conducted a 5-day teacher workshop in Gadsden, AL on June 7-11, 2010 and a 1-day workshop in Florala, AL on July 29th, 2010. The workshops trained more than 20 teachers and teachers showed great enthusiasm and interest in the topics. We are planning to have several more one day workshops around the state and perhaps one online. Several video resources have been developed with supplemental handouts, worksheets and quizzes. The video presentations include, 1) an interactive flash presentation on how to build a small and inexpensive recirculating aquaculture system for the classroom, 2) Spawning of American oysters by thermal shock and 3) an overview of aquaculture production systems. There are 4 additional online video resources nearing completion: Pond in a bucket, Fish enumeration and volumetric displacement, How to drill and plumb a glass aquarium, and Aquaculture: What is it, Is it important, and why should I care. The products and results of the project are being distributed via several web sites and we are planning to work with an international aquaculture supply company to distribute the information with their educational products. A grant work page has bee set up to foster communication between authors, reviewers and potential participants at: http://www.aces.edu/dept/fisheries/education/DevelopingOnlineAquacult ureCurricula.php PRODUCTS: Eighty-eight teachers have responded to the needs assessment and informational survey though the National Aquaculture Educators Network developed by David Cline. Here is a link to the survey results. The products of this effort to date include several online video resources with supplemental handouts, worksheets and quizzes. The video presentations include, 1) an interactive flash presentation on how to build a small and inexpensive recirculating aquaculture system for the classroom, 2) Spawning of American oysters by thermal shock and 3) an overview of aquaculture production systems. The project has also resulted in the development of a laboratory exercise about how farmers can count thousands of fish using volumetric displacement, weight averaging and sampling. The team conducted a 5-day teacher workshop in Gadsden, AL on June 7-11, 2010 and a 1-day workshop in Florala, AL on July 29th, 2010. The workshops trained more than 20 teachers and teachers showed great enthusiasm and interest in the topics. Teachers that attended the training workshops were supplied with resource notebooks and a two resource dvds that contain over 300 aquaculture publications, 75 power point presentations, hundreds of aquaculture photos and a variety of lesson plan ideas. OUTCOMES: Teachers of the 5-day workshop demonstrated a 33% change in aquaculture related knowledge as determined by pre- and post-testing. At the one day workshop the teachers pre/post-testing scores increased by 66%. Teacher responses to the post-workshop survey question "How do you feel the information presented will benefit your students included, (a) "I have more knowledge and a better understanding of the needs of fish & plants to successfully teach my students", (b) "Makes me a more knowledgeable teacher & more effective teacher" and "Gives them [students] a chance to apply principles to real world situations". DISSEMINATION ACTIVITIES: The various video and lesson plan products are posted on www.alearn.info , which is a cooperative effort between the Alabama Cooperative Extension System, Auburn University Fisheries and Allied Aquacultures Department, and the AU College of Agriculture and the Mississippi/Alabama Sea Grant Consortium web site. The videos and activities were demonstrated at the two teacher workshops. The interactive flash video presentation was presented to the Southern Regional Aquaculture Center publications committee, at the International Tilapia and Aquaponics Workshop, and plans are under way to make the videos available to educators through one of the largest international aquaculture suppliers. Information related to the grant was also reported at the 2010 Aquaculture America meeting in San Diego, CA and will be distributed to the National Aquaculture Educator Network and Aquacontacts email lists. FUTURE INITIATIVES: Future plans include the completion of 5 more online video/animation projects, 1, 5- teacher training workshop and 4, 1-day teacher training workshops. The five presentations will include aspects of water quality, genetics, and the nitrogen cycle. Once all portions of the online teaching materials are available we plan to create a specific section on the www.alearn.info web site (linked to other major aquaculture information hubs) and build an interactive dvd that contains all of the materials and make it available to teachers across the country.

Impacts
The teacher survey indicates a high interest in electronic, interactive and hands on teaching resources and providing high quality resources will enable them to spend more time teaching and less time searching for materials. Comments from the teacher training workshops indicate that our efforts are increasing instructor knowledge and teaching capacity in aquaculture. Studies show that using aquaculture as a tool to teach biology, math, and science increases student engagement and helps them see the practicality of their studies by providing real world opportunities the apply the academic principals. Increased engagement, understanding and aquaculture knowledge may inspire students to pursue careers in these fields or at a minimum create a more informed seafood consumer.

Publications

  • Cline, D.J. (2010) Aquaculture as a tool to teach math & science to K-12 students: Barriers and Opportunities. Aquaculture America abstracts, March 1-5, 2010. San Diego, CA
  • Waters, P.J. (2009) Hatchery spawning by thermal shock of the American oyster Crassostrea virginica, Mississippi Alabama Sea Grant Program. Publication Number MASGP 09-026