Source: PURDUE UNIVERSITY submitted to
HARDWOOD SCANNING THE ACQUISITION OF AN X-RAY CT LOG SCANNER HARDWOOD SCANNING - THE ACQUISITION OF AN X-RAY CT LOG SCANNER FOR THE HARDWOOD SCANNING CENTER
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
TERMINATED
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0214712
Grant No.
2008-34569-19267
Project No.
IND011544G1
Proposal No.
2008-03472
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Program Code
YD
Project Start Date
Jul 15, 2008
Project End Date
Jul 14, 2011
Grant Year
2008
Project Director
Gazo, R.
Recipient Organization
PURDUE UNIVERSITY
(N/A)
WEST LAFAYETTE,IN 47907
Performing Department
FORESTRY & NATURAL RESOURCES
Non Technical Summary
As furniture production continues to move to China, domestic lumber consumption has decreased. By the end of 2004, 2 billion board feet of hardwood lumber demand or about 14 percent of the domestic hardwood lumber market has disappeared compared to 1998 (Barrett 2004). Even though China imported 710 million board feet of American hardwood lumber in 2003, this import level falls far short of the 2 billion board feet domestic demand that has disappeared. Obviously, other countries have supplied China with some of the hardwood lumber used to manufacture the furniture exported to the U.S. Based on statistics from the 1997 Census of Manufactures (USDC Bureau of Census 1999) and Annual Survey of Manufacturers between 1998 and 2001 (USDC Bureau of Census 2000, 2001, 2002, 2003), for every $1 million decrease in lumber shipments, roughly 4.6 jobs were lost in the sawmill industry. A loss of 2 billion board feet in domestic lumber demand is conservatively estimated to be worth $1 billion and would translate into 4,600 lost jobs. To regain some of these lost jobs, American producers must capture a larger share of the Chinese market which requires that American sawmills employ advanced technology to produce a better quality product at a lower cost. Yet, American sawmills are no different from their major competitors in Canada, Europe, China and even Southeast Asia. In softwood sawmills, currently, a log profile scanner acquires data on the external shape of the log and computer software determines the sawing solution that maximizes the volume, rather than the value, of lumber produced. In hardwood sawmills, currently, logs are still cut manually by sawyers based on their past experience. Consequently, these sawmills capture only a portion of the value that could be realized from sawing the log. However, with the availability of an X-ray CT log scanner, the situation mentioned above could change both dramatically and quickly. Coupling the images acquired from log scanning with the TOPSAW (Chang and Guddanti 1993, 1995, Guddanti and Chang 1998, Chang and Pasala 2003) sawing optimization software already developed at the Advanced Sawing Technology Laboratory at Louisiana State University Agricultural Center it would then be possible to saw around the internal defects such as knots, decays, splits, and wormholes to maximize the value of lumber recovered and increase the profit at the mill level. For the sawmill industry the proposed project will strengthen the global competitiveness of the sawmill industry. For the consumers, they get better quality lumber and finally, for the nation as a whole, improved lumber recovery would enhance the conservation of the forest resource.
Animal Health Component
20%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
20%
Developmental
80%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
1230620202034%
1230621202033%
1230622202033%
Goals / Objectives
The overall goal of the Hardwood Scanning Center is to increase the global competitiveness of the United States hardwood industry and conserve the hardwood resource through increased conversion efficiency. We aim to accomplish this goal through development of technologies which will enable hardwood industry to see inside a tree and use this information to make better sawing decisions. The specific objective of this proposal is to acquire the log scanner from MiCROTEC GmbH with funding from federal, state, and industrial sources. As such, the proposed project will provide the enabling technology to greatly increase the value of the logs cut and enhance the global competitiveness of the hardwood sawmill industry in the United States For the hardwood sawmill industry, this increase could add roughly $2.4 billion in value per year to harvested hardwood logs.
Project Methods
An X-ray CT log scanner must be fast, acquiring multiple scanning images per second, strong, capable of handling logs of over 2000 pounds, durable, lasting for years, powerful, able to penetrate logs of 25-30 inches in diameter, and cost effective. The proposed X-ray CT log scanner will be purchased from MiCROTEC GmbH of Italy. The preliminary cost estimate is around $1.5 million. Once the log scanner is verified to meet the performance requirements envisioned, further negotiations will be conducted to fit within the funding available. The basic specifications for the log scanner are as follows: Bore opening: 90 cm Field of view: 75cm X-ray energy level: up to 385 kV Image resolution: 1024 x 1024 Scanning speed: at least 2 images per second Once acquired, the scanner will be installed in a mobile scanning unit. Further research will focus on integrating the scanner with software and hardware to make it viable for an industrial application in sawmills, veneer mills, concentration yards, etc.

Progress 07/15/08 to 07/14/11

Outputs
OUTPUTS: ******Confidential****** Please treat this report confidential due to ongoing negotiations with the scanner manufacturer and possible comercialization partners. The overall goal of this project is to develop and demnostrate an industrial grade hardwood log CT scanner. The development of the scanner is partially funded by following grants: IN 06-DG-11244225-242 IN 09-DG-11420004-024 2006 CSREES IND011544G 2008 CSREES IND011544G1 In addition, State of Indiana, Indiana Hardwood Lumbermen's Association, several Indiana hardwood mills and Purdue University contributed funds to this project. Each source of funds is used for a specific objective to support the overall goal. The funds from this grant were used to: 1. Partially fund the development of LogView software (faculty and graduate student salaries, travel, S&E) 2. Partially fund the development of the CT scanner (subcontract) PARTICIPANTS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period. TARGET AUDIENCES: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
******Confidential****** Please treat this report confidential due to ongoing negotiations with the scanner manufacturer and possible comercialization partners. 1. The LogView software, developed by the PI's to visualize and analyze scan data and to optimize the rotation of the log before it is cut into flitches in a veneer slicing operation has been disclosed to the Purdue Research Foundation. This was done in order to established a legal framework for intellectual property protection, and to form a credible partner from whom the prospective scanner manufacturer can license the CT log viewing software. 2. Development of the CT scanner. Our cooperating company and its industrial partners have spent an estimated $5 million up to this point on development of the CT scanner. Purdue University Hardwood Scanning Center is contributing an additional US$ 1,000,000 to this effort. In contrast to the medical and security CT scanners that work in a relatively clean, dust-free, vibration-free and climate controlled environment, the hardwood log CT scanners of industrial grade are expected to encounter dust, vibrations, temperature and humidity factors during their operation. CT scanners consist of a static frame and a rotating gantry that holds the power source, x-ray tube and the sensors. Power and data transfer from the rotating to static parts of the system are achieved through what is called a "slip ring" - a physical electrical contacts between stationary and rotating parts of the machine. This is fine for medical and security scanners, but a truly industrial grade CT scanner for hardwood logs needs more reliable solution. This grant specifically contributed US$ 233,929 towards the development of a contactless data transmission between the rotating gantry and the static frame in order to avoid rotary joints data transmission.

Publications

  • Chang, J. and R. Gazo. 2009. Hardwood Log CT scanning: Proof of Concept. In Proceedings of ISCHP 09 2nd International Scientific Conference on Hardwood Processing. FCBA Paris, France.
  • Gazo, R. and J. Chang. 2010. Hardwood Log CT scanning: Proof of Concept. In Proceedings of Joint UNECE Timber Committee Session and Society of Wood Science and Technology International Convention: Innovative Wood Products are the Future. United Nations, Geneva, Switzerland. CD ROM, 5 pages.


Progress 07/15/09 to 07/14/10

Outputs
OUTPUTS: The developed viable scanner configuration was tested and software to visualize and analyze the data and recommend optimum log rotation for veneer slicing was developed. The scanning system (hardware and software) was introduced at two national industry trade shows. At the same time, presentations were made to owners and managers of top US hardwood veneer and sawmill operations. The feedback we received was positive, but due to the current state of the economy no one is ready to make a sizable investment in this technology at this time. We continue our efforts to find someone ready to invest, because we need to find 2-3 buyers before the scanner manufacturer will initiate the production of the scanner. PARTICIPANTS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period. TARGET AUDIENCES: US hardwood lumber industry PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Not relevant to this project.

Impacts
none at this time.

Publications

  • Chang, J. and R. Gazo. 2009. Measuring the effect of internal log defect scanning on the value of lumber produced. Forest Products Journal. 59(11/12):56-59.


Progress 07/15/08 to 07/14/09

Outputs
OUTPUTS: In accordance with the proposal narrative, the funds from this grant are to be used for the acquisition of a CT scanner. We have now determined the viable configuratuion of the scanner and found a company to develop and build it. Commercialization efforts are under way. Contact Dr. Gazo if more information is needed. PARTICIPANTS: Dr. Rado Gazo, Purdue University Dr. Sun J. Chang, Louisiana State University TARGET AUDIENCES: Not relevant to this project. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Change of vendor for the acquisition of the CT scanner.

Impacts
None at this time.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period