Source: CONNECTICUT AGRICULTURAL EXPERIMENT STATION submitted to
MOLECULAR BIOLOGICAL CHARACTERIZATION OF THE PAENIBACILLUS POPILLIAE GENOME
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
TERMINATED
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0208806
Grant No.
(N/A)
Project No.
CONH00247
Proposal No.
(N/A)
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Program Code
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Oct 1, 2006
Project End Date
Sep 30, 2009
Grant Year
(N/A)
Project Director
Dingman, D. W.
Recipient Organization
CONNECTICUT AGRICULTURAL EXPERIMENT STATION
PO BOX 1106
NEW HAVEN,CT 06504
Performing Department
BIOCHEMISTRY & GENETICS
Non Technical Summary
New and effective biological insecticides are needed to replace synthetic pesticides for controlling insect pests. Understanding molecular biological properties of bacteria that cause disease in insects is necessary for the development of efficient bioinsecticides. This project intends to obtain specific information about the genome of Paenibacillus popilliae and to use that information to decipher the mechanism used to cause disease in insects. Understanding this mechaism will help in the development of this bacterium into an efficient bioinsecticide.
Animal Health Component
(N/A)
Research Effort Categories
Basic
100%
Applied
(N/A)
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
2154010104075%
2154010110015%
2154010116010%
Goals / Objectives
Annually, insects cause extensive damage and loss to agricultural and horticultural products. Thus, massive quantities and numerous varieties, of insecticides are used privately and commercially to control insect pests. Due to the development of insect resistance to pesticides, the discovery of new insecticides is in constant demand. Although synthetic pesticides are effective at controlling insects, the development and use of biological insecticides is needed as a means to expand the number and variety of weapons used to combat insects. Additionally, public concern with the use of synthetic insecticides has increased the need for the development of alternative insecticides. For white grubs, the larval stage of scarab beetles (order Coleoptera, family Scarabaeidae), yearly damage to turfgrass in the U. S. has been estimated to be one-quarter of a billion dollars. At present, the only effective control for white grubs is the use of synthetic insecticides. Beneficial nematodes and Bacillus thuringiensis, two biologicals that have undergone extensive research, have not been overly effective against white grubs. Paenibacillus popilliae, a bacterium causing milky disease in white grubs, was effectively used in the past as a biocontrol. However, more recent work on efficacy of commercially produced milky disease insecticide did not demonstrate the product to be effective. Still, milky diseased grubs are routinely found in field surveys of lawns. This lack of efficacy in the biocontrols is primarily due to a general lack of knowledge on basic characteristics and molecular biology of these organisms. This investigation will help develop P. popilliae as a biological insecticide by providing more information on the properties of this organism. Also, by providing new information for disease-causing bacteria in a non-human host, comparative studies will have fundamental benefits on knowledge about molecular diversity and evolution of disease mechanisms. Before it can be effectively used as a biological control agent,a detailed characterization of the P. popilliae genome is needed. The objective of this investigation is to provide information to direct future investigations on the pathogenic machinery in P. popilliae. The specific objectives are as follows: A) To enhance the crude physical map of the bacterial genome by PCR amplification of other genes. Southern hybridization to genomic restriction fragments will be used for placement of these genes onto the crude map. B) To use Tn916 insertional mutagenesis of the bacterium for production of an insertional mutant library. The library will be available for isolating bacterial mutants in genes of interest. C) To shotgun isolate genes involved in pathogenicity via PCR amplification and degenerate oligonucleotides designed for genes known to be involved in bacterial pathogenicity. Isolated genes that have potential pathogenicity characteristics will be investigated in greater detail.
Project Methods
To enhance a genomic physical map of P. popilliae, PCR amplification using random primers will be done. Amplified DNA will be sequenced and analyzed via BLAST analysis. PFGE of I-CeuI, and Pme I digested genomic DNA will be done and the separated DNA will be transferred onto filter membranes for Southern hybridization analysis. Hybridization banding patterns resulting from use of hybridization probes to the new genes will identify the restriction fragment(s)on which a specific gene marker is located and place the marker onto the chromosomal map. Mapping will be performed for approximately 30-40 new genes. P. popilliae strains Tc1001 (tetracycline resistant) and Em1001 (erythromycin resistant) will be filter-mated and isolates resistant to tetracycline and erythromycin will be selected. 2000 P. popilliae isolates will be individually transferred into preservation medium and stored at -80 C to create a mutagenesis library. Library isolates will be screened for the loss of superoxide dismutase (SOD) activity and vancomycin resistance. SOD loss will be tested via spot inoculation onto filter paper overlaying MYPGP agar and, following growth and cell lysis, positive-staining for SOD activity. To identify mutants susceptible to vancomycin, each library isolate will be spotted onto MYPGP agar plates containing vancomycin. Isolates failing to grow will be tested in broth culture containing vancomycin to confirm sensitivity to the antibiotic. P. popilliae is able to grow using the carbohydrate trehalose. The library will be screened for mutants unable to utilize this carbohydrate. Many bacteria contain the enzyme chitinase. P. popilliae will be first tested for the presence of chitinases via an agar plate clarification procedure. Should chitinase activity be present, then the library will be screened for mutants lacking chitinase activity. Inverse PCR amplification will be performed on all potential library isolate mutants to verify that the gene of interest is the one mutated. Following demonstration that the library is suitable for gene mutagenesis/isolation, the library will be extended to include 10,000 mutants. A type-IV secretory system gene (sec) has been isolated from P. popilliae. Type-IV secretory systems may have involvement in pathogenicity. Inverse PCR will be performed on genomic DNA, using the sec sequence, to extend DNA sequence information in both directions. Results of this extension will demonstrate if sec is contained within a pathogenicity island. Paenibacillus larvae, a honey bee pathogen, has been found to contain 3 proteins that are potentially involved in the disease process. Degenerate oligonucleotide primers designed to these 3 proteins will be constructed to probe P. popilliae for similar proteins. Also, degenerate primers based on pathogenicity genes present in other invasive bacteria will be tested. DNA bands appearing following PCR amplification and agarose gel electrophoresis will be purified, sequenced, and BLAST analyzed to determine identity. The DNA region around amplified DNA having pathogenicity genes will be explored for other genes involved in pathogenicity.

Progress 10/01/06 to 09/30/09

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Paenibacillus popilliae and Paenibacillus lentimorbus cause milky spore disease in the larval stage of various scarab beetles. Development of P. popilliae and P. lentimorbus into biological control agents would provide an alternate method for managing these pests in lieu of traditional pesticides. Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification of P. popilliae genomic DNA and sequencing of the amplified DNA has isolated and characterized 25 different DNA segments of the P. popilliae genome. BLASTX analysis of these isolated P. popilliae DNA segments has helped determine identity numerous genes relative to reported protein sequences in the GenBank database. Transcription start codons have been tentatively identified and, where included, presumptive ribosome-binding sites have been located. DNA sequence and gene identification data have been disseminated via scientific publication in the DNA database, GenBank. Construction of an insertional mutant library has been discontinued. The insertional mutagen, Tn916, was not confirmed as inserting into the bacterial genome in a completely random manner despite switching the conjugative donor. Construction of a phenotypic marker and a gene insertion probe for P. popilliae was nearing completion. Fusion of the P. popilliae thymidine kinase (tdk) promoter region to green fluorescent protein (GFP) was completed and found to be functional in Escherichia coli. Insertion of the tdk-GFP fusion into Tn916 and placement this transposon construct into Enterococcus faecalis (for conjugative transfer into P. popilliae) was in progress. Partial assembly of a promoter-less GFP gene insertion marker, using frame-reading insertion, into Tn916 was underway. Dr. Dingman, in association with Dr. Richard Cowles (The Connecticut Agricultural Experiment Station) has had limited success at in vivo spore production. Production of large amounts of P. popilliae endospores was to provide a source of this pathogen for use in environmental control studies. Students and teachers were mentored through presentations of research findings. Additionally, conversations with Connecticut citizens were done to educate individuals on molecular biology principles and on current practices for pesticide treatment of scarab beetle infestations. PARTICIPANTS: Dr. Douglas W. Dingman (primary investigator) has performed all experiments and analyses associated with this project. Dr. Richard Cowles has provided scarab beetle larvae for endospore production via injection. Mrs. Cindy Musante provided technical support and assisted in setup of equipment/supplies associated with experimental design. TARGET AUDIENCES: Scientists studying bacterial genomics and scientists investigating molecular properties of bacterial entomopathogens are targets of this research. These data provide information to advance scientific investigations of genetic variability within pathogenic Paenibacilli. Via comparative analysis of gene sequences and genomic organization, scientists can use these data to better understand P. popilliae pathogenicity and disease characteristics of other insecticidal bacteria. Scientists can use the knowledge gained to produce molecular tools for altering and probing these bacteria to gain more information and to provide effective control agents against harmful insects. Future scientific research on P. popilliae, or related entomological bacteria, will have available these data for construction of a genomic profile and for use in making comparisons between bacterial genes. Target audiences include landscape managers, lawn care specialists, and homeowners, also. Through results from applied investigations, these target audiences will benefit from information that can be used to establish a biocontrol agent and protocol to combat scarab beetle larvae infestations. High school and grade school students and teachers gained exposure to scientific principles via mentoring and research presentations. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
This investigation has presented 25 new DNA fragments of the P. popilliae genome, and representative gene identifications, to the international DNA database, GenBank. These data are freely available on the World-Wide-Web for individuals to view and use. This availability will impact researchers by providing more sequence data pertaining to P. popilliae for future investigations. Also, this information will provide protein sequences (deciphered from the DNA sequences) from a different bacterium for inclusion into families of classified proteins. The randomly isolated DNA segments obtained from P. popilliae can be used in future investigations to help produce a physical map of the genome prior to, or in conjunction with, complete genomic sequencing of P. popilliae. Availability of a phenotypically marked strain of P. popilliae will help investigations to tract disease progress within the insect. Construction of the tdk-GFP protein fusion was the outcome reached in providing a marked strain. Future scientific investigations can make use of this fusion to complete the phenotypic marking of P. popilliae. The ability to probe the genomic operation of P. popilliae would provide a powerful tool to investigate pathogenic coding and function of this bacterium. Development of a promoter-less GFP and Tn916 fusion for P. popilliae gene insertion would provide that tool and significantly impact scientists ability to study and understand the pathogenic function of this bacterium. The presented data are providing a better understanding of milky disease bacteria and will help in future scientific endeavors at producing an effective biocontrol for infestations of scarab beetle larvae.

Publications

  • Dingman, D. W. 2009. Sixteen sequence submissions. Accession numbers; GU295420-GU295435. GenBank.
  • Dingman, D. W. 2009. Nine sequence submissions. Accession numbers; GU299523-GU299531. GenBank.


Progress 01/01/08 to 12/31/08

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Paenibacillus popilliae, and the closely related Paenibacillus lentimorbus, cause milky disease in larvae of certain scarab beetles. Use of P. popilliae and P. lentimorbus as biological control agents would help lower use of traditional pesticides and provide an alternate method for managing these pests. Scarab beetle larvae and adults cause extensive horticultural and agricultural damage and traditional pesticides are the only effective means for management. Investigations are being conducted to provide a broad-based understanding of the molecular biological, physiological, and environmental adaptation properties of milky disease bacteria. Information gained will help future research by providing a foundational understanding of these bacteria. Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification of P. popilliae genomic DNA and sequencing of the amplified DNA has identified five new genes (a serine/threonine protein phosphatase, a spore-germination protein, a transposase, a collagenase, and a erythromycin esterase). The collagenase is being explored further as a potential virulence factor. The finding of an erythromycin esterase is unusual in that P. popilliae is not known to be resistant to erythromycin. The transposase has been grouped into the IS21 family of transposons and an insertion site and sequence has been found. The start codon for the transposase was identified. Chromosome walking via PCR amplification of flanking sequences has extended the sequences of two previously identified genes. The DNA sequence containing the heat-shock protein has been extended 487 bp and has resulted in identification of the protein start codon. The DNA sequence containing the virB11-like gene (a type-IV secretory protein) has been extended 529 bp. No new genes or gene features have been identified in this extension. These five newly isolated genes will be mapped onto the crude physical map of P. popilliae in conjunction with other mapped genes. Gene sequence information will be disseminated via scientific publication in the DNA database, GenBank. Dr. Dingman, in association with Dr. Richard Cowles (The Connecticut Agricultural Experiment Station) and Dr. Jerry Silbert (The Watershed Partnership, Inc.), is initializing experiments to use regionalized isolates of milky disease bacteria for testing a correlation between environmental adaptation and virulence. In vivo spore production experiments are in progress. High school students and teachers were mentored through presentations of research findings in informal discussions. In addition, telephone conversations with Connecticut citizens were conducted to explain molecular biology principles and current practices for pesticide treatment of scarab beetle infestations. PARTICIPANTS: Dr. Douglas W. Dingman (primary investigator) has performed all experiments and analyses associated with this project. Dr. Richard Cowles has collaborated on endospore production efforts for efficacy tests and has provided scarab beetle larvae for injection. Mrs. Cindy Musante provided technical support and assisted in setup of equipment/supplies associated with experimental design. TARGET AUDIENCES: Scientists studying bacterial genomics will find these results useful. These data provide information to advance scientific investigations of bacterial genetic organization and pathogenicity via comparative analysis of genomic content. This scientific advancement is on fundamental and applied frontiers. Scientists, to alter these bacteria and provide a product that is effective for use as a control agent, can use the knowledge gained. Secondary target audiences include landscape managers, lawn care specialists, and homeowners who, through results from applied investigations, will possibly gain a biocontrol agent effective against scarab beetle larvae. This can lower the use of traditional pesticides on these insect pests and lower environmental accumulation. The Watershed Partnership (involved with lowering pollutant runoff into Long Island Sound) have received regular updates on milky disease efficacy testing experiments. High school and grade school students and teachers gained exposure to scientific principles via mentoring and research presentations on several occasions. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
This investigation has identified new genes in P. popilliae and has provided a better understanding on the molecular properties of the genome. The randomly isolated genes from P. popilliae are being used to produce a physical map of the genome. This map will significantly help in the assembly of a complete genomic sequence of this bacterium. Complete genomic sequences are the foundation for understanding molecular properties and characteristics in a bacterium. This amplification has added a third gene (i.e., collagenase) to the list of genes potentially involved in the pathogenic properties of milky disease organisms. Work to extend DNA sequences and possibly isolate other pathogenicity genes via linkage to pathogenicity islands using the lysM domain-containing gene and virB11-like gene can now continue with the collagenase gene. The presence of a naturally occurring transposon that is part of a large family of transposons adds insight into the genomic commonality and evolutionary properties of this bacterium. This transposase may present another tool for molecular manipulations of P. popilliae. The collected data are providing a better understanding of how milky disease cause disease and will help in future molecular manipulations to produce an effective biocontrol. The DNA sequence data obtained for milky disease bacteria will be submitted to GenBank.

Publications

  • Dingman, D. W. 2008. DNA fingerprinting of Paenibacillus popilliae and Paenibacillus lentimorbus using PCR-amplified 16S-23S rDNA intergenic transcribed spacer (ITS) regions. J. Invertebr. Pathol. doi:10.1016/j.jip.2008.09.006


Progress 01/01/07 to 12/31/07

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Paenibacillus popilliae and Paenibacillus lentimorbus are very closely related bacteria that naturally occur in the soil and cause disease (i.e., milky disease) in larvae of certain scarab beetles. Scarab beetle larvae and adult beetles cause extensive horticultural and agricultural damage costing hundreds of millions of dollars annually. Use of traditional pesticides is currently the only effective means for managing these insect pests. However, public concerns regarding health and environmental impacts associated with pesticide use have necessitated exploration of alternate methods for managing these important pests. Use of P. popilliae and P. lentimorbus, as biological controls, fit this niche. In order to establish these bacteria as control agents, a broad-based understanding (e.g., characterization of molecular biological, physiological, and environmental adaptation properties) is needed. Therefore, investigations were conducted to provide information that will be helpful for future molecular investigations or to gain an understanding of bacterial/environmental interactions. Construction of an insertional mutant library of P. popilliae using random insertion of the transposon Tn916 was started. Although initial isolates failed to demonstrate randomness of insertion via Southern hybridization testing, I am continuing insertional mutagenesis using a different conjugative donor. The new donor presents a better possibility for randomization of insertions. An unfinished library of approximately 2000 isolates is being tested via Southern hybridization for randomness of Tn916 insertion. Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification of genomic DNA has identified 2 new genes (a lysM domain-containing protein and a heat-shock ATPase) from P. popilliae. Inverse PCR amplification of isolates obtained from the unfinished Tn916 insertional mutant library has identified 4 new genes (a ribosome associated GTPase, a hypothetical cytosolic protein, a haloacid dehalogenase-superfamily hydrolase, and dimethyladenosine transferase). These 6 newly isolated genes are currently being mapped onto the crude physical map of P. popilliae in conjunction with 13 currently mapped genes. When physical mapping of the genome is completed, this information will be disseminated via scientific publication in a peer-reviewed scientific journal. Dr. Dingman, in association with Dr. Steven Alm (University of Rhode Island), mentored Ms. Andrea Bixby (graduate student, University of Rhode Island) on research involving molecular identification and the use of natural milky disease isolates to control scarab beetle infestations. High school students were mentored through participation on the Science Research Review Panel for the CT High Scholl Innovation Expo and grade school students were instructed via participation in the CPTV science exposition. PARTICIPANTS: The primary investigator on this project, Dr. Douglas W. Dingman, performed all experiments associated with this project. Dr. Neil Schultz assisted with Southern hybridization experiments to test for randomness of Tn916 insertion into the P. popilliae genome. Mrs. Cindy Musante provided technical support and assisted in setup of equipment/supplies associated with experimental design. TARGET AUDIENCES: These findings target other scientists working on milky disease bacteria for fundamental or applied purposes. These data have provided information that scientists can use to advance investigations of milky disease bacteria on fundamental and applied frontiers. This knowledge will be used to direct changes on how these bacteria are manipulated or utilized by scientists to provide a product that is effective for use as a control agent. The effectiveness of commercially available milky spore powder using the current stock strain was discussed with Richard Vento (Director Laboratory Operations) and Dr. F. Obenchain (consultant), representatives of Reuter-St. Gabriel Laboratories. Dr. T. Michaildes (Univ. California) was contacted involving a growing problem with misidentification of P. lentimorbus in environmental samples. Secondary targets include landscape managers, lawn care specialists, and homeowners who, through results from applied investigations, will benefit from the use of these biocontrols against scarab beetle larvae. The long-term benefits of improved biocontrol applications will minimize the use of traditional pesticides against these insect pests. High school and grade school students were mentored on several occasions.

Impacts
This investigation about the P. popilliae genome has provided necessary information with which to advance research into disease-causing properties of this microorganism. It has resulted in the random isolation of genes from P. popilliae, using non-specific PCR, for production of a genomic map. This random amplification precedes use of degenerate PCR to amplify and isolate genes associated with pathogenicity that may be present in milky disease organisms. The lysM domain-containing gene is potentially associated with pathogenicity via receptor recognition properties. Isolation of this gene, and use of the previously identified virB11-like gene, is directing work to extend the DNA sequences and possibly isolate other pathogenicity genes via linkage to pathogenicity islands. All collected data have built upon current knowledge of these microorganisms. This is helping us better understand how to use and manipulate milky disease for biocontrol. The molecular biological data obtained from this research have increased the understanding of environmental distribution and microbial evolution of milky disease organisms. This will help prevent, or bypass, problems associated with development and use of milky disease bacteria for biocontrol. The finding that milky disease bacteria are geographically distributed based on phylogeny is being used to test a new approach for increasing the efficiency of regionalized isolates to cause disease. DNA sequence data for 20 16S rDNA accessions of milky disease bacterial were submitted to GenBank.

Publications

  • Dingman, D. W. 2007. Geographical distribution of milky disease bacteria in the eastern United States based on phylogeny. J. Invertebr. Pathol. doi:10.1016/j.jip.207.09.002