Source: AUBURN UNIVERSITY submitted to
A VISUAL APPROACH TO THE ASSESSMENT OF BRAND PERSONALITY AND ITS RELATIONSHIP TO BRAND EQUITY FOR APPAREL AND HOME FURNISHINGS PRODUCTS
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
TERMINATED
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0204599
Grant No.
(N/A)
Project No.
ALA07-019
Proposal No.
(N/A)
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Program Code
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Sep 30, 2005
Project End Date
Oct 1, 2010
Grant Year
(N/A)
Project Director
Solomon, M. R.
Recipient Organization
AUBURN UNIVERSITY
108 M. WHITE SMITH HALL
AUBURN,AL 36849
Performing Department
CONSUMER AFFAIRS
Non Technical Summary
Despite the importance of fabric properties or the fit of a garment, in reality many items of apparel are purchased (or not) because of the meaning the brand conveys to a customer. This project will develop a better understanding of how this "brand personality" can affect brand equity - the net value-added of a product that differentiates it from similar garments in the marketplace.
Animal Health Component
(N/A)
Research Effort Categories
Basic
40%
Applied
60%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
60451103100100%
Knowledge Area
604 - Marketing and Distribution Practices;

Subject Of Investigation
5110 - Clothing/apparel;

Field Of Science
3100 - Management;
Goals / Objectives
A primary objective is to systematically and empirically construct a visual lexicon of brand personality that can link the meanings evoked by a standardized set of images with apparel brands. The project will focus upon a set of relevant apparel product categories for which branding decisions are pivotal. This lexicon will enable development of a visual meaning map for the resulting set of apparel brands, which will also permit triangulation with more traditional verbal dimensions. Analyses of these meaning maps will be used to gauge the consistency of meanings among consumers, and will be related to financial and market measures of brand performance. This approach to mapping brand meaning visually can also inform brand managers how best to visually depict the intended meanings of their brands.
Project Methods
This first part of the work will also include development of the theoretical framework that integrates and captures the different personality meaning dimensions for the apparel brands that will be used in the research. The second step is to define these meaning dimensions visually so that we can identify commonalities of interpretation across a large number of respondents.14 In other words, meaning structures will be empirically derived by assessing the degree of convergence among respondents. The third step will be to empirically examine the differential brand personality and meaning associations that consumers have for domestic and foreign brands that differ in level of prominence (as defined by A.C. Neilson NetRatings) to assess the reliability of the methodology, to determine the underlying structure of the measures and to refine the measures through interpretation of the scaling work. This will be accomplished by administering a series of online surveys that will include a large number of visual images depicting a set of metaphorical meaning dimensions (e.g., in pilot work we have found that respondents tend to equate pictures of fire with masculinity and pictures of flowers with femininity). Subjects will be led through a set of measures that will involve the matching of images with brands. These associations will be aggregated among the entire set of respondents to identify consensual meanings. This work will also include comparisons of consumers who are high versus low in involvement in the product categories being tested as well as those exhibiting strong versus weak brand loyalty. Approximately 200 adult U.S. consumers will be recruited from an Internet panel maintained by Survey Sampling, Inc. Finally, the work will include studies that assess such variables as foreign versus domestic brands, financially successful brands versus financially struggling brands, and strong versus weak brands (defined using existing brand strength measurement tools such as the Y&R AssetValuator or Equitrend brand quality data) in order to identify relationships between type and clarity of visual brand associations and market performance.

Progress 09/30/05 to 10/01/10

Outputs
Despite the importance of fabric properties or the fit of a garment, in reality many items of apparel are purchased (or not) because of the meaning the brand conveys to a customer. This project develops a better understanding of how this "brand personality" can affect brand equity - the net value-added of a product that differentiates it from similar garments in the marketplace. We employ a web-based visual system to assess how consumers cognitively process a set of apparel brands.

Impacts
In the apparel industry the linkage of brand personalities with visual images is pervasive (ranging from depictions of social types like the American cowboy to scenes like cityscapes) yet at the same time ad hoc and often left to the discretion of individual art directors. Our research program will enable us to systematically and empirically construct a visual lexicon of brand personality that can link the meanings evoked by a standardized set of images with apparel brands. The method we are developing will allow us to generate a visual meaning map for each apparel brand we study. We will analyze these meaning maps to gauge the consistency of meanings among consumers and relate them to financial and market measures of brand performance. Visual meaning maps can also inform brand managers how best to visually depict the intended meanings of their brands.

Publications

  • Fournier, Susan G., Michael R. Solomon, and Basil G. Englis, Brand Resonance, in ed. Bernd Schmitt, Handbook on Brand and Experience Management, Elgar Publishing, 2007, in press.


Progress 01/01/06 to 10/01/06

Outputs
We have completed a small pilot study and we have written a theoretical paper outlining our approach to brand meaning that has been accepted for publication in a forthcoming book on branding strategy (Fournier, Solomon, and Englis 2007). We have also had a related paper accepted for presentation at The Thought Leaders International Conference on Brand Management to be held in the U.K. in Spring 2007. Our pilot study explored whether respondents could readily and consistently associate visual imagery with specific conveyed meanings and identify the meanings associated with those images. We focused upon the meanings associated with three brands of jeans with distinct market positions (Diesel, Levis and Wrangler). As a point of comparison we also examined sets of non-textile brands with distinctive positions (Microsoft/Apple; Coke/Pepsi/ Jones Soda, BMW/Ford/Hummer; Nike/Reebok). We selected the following meaning dimensions for this pilot study: Gender (masculine, feminine); Social Class (lower, middle, upper); Values (belonging, excitement, all-American, warm relationships, self-fulfillment, luxurious, respected by others, fun, cool, security, self-respect, accomplishment, sexy); Historic Period (1940s or earlier, 1950s, 1960s, 1970s, 1980s, 1990s, Today, Future); Age (Childhood, Adolescence, Young Adult, Middle Age, Elderly); Ethnicity (Anglo/Caucasian, Hispanic, African-American, Asian). We selected visual stimuli from a large online database of stock photography (Corbis), using its search engine to fit images to a subset of the brand meaning dimensions we have developed (cf. Fournier, Solomon and Englis 2007). We selected 45 photographs to represent all of the meaning dimensions and their sub-categories - as designated by the Corbis search engine. These designations thus possess external validity because these are the semantic categories art directors and other professionals specify when they search for corresponding advertising depictions. The study was conducted in a group setting. The 45 images were sequentially projected onto a large screen via a computer projection system; respondents were given 45 seconds to look at each picture. The photographs were pictures of a variety of everyday items, such as people, buildings, social settings, and landscapes. Respondents checked any and all meaning associations the image elicited and also indicated which brands they associated with each of the images they viewed.

Impacts
In the apparel industry the linkage of brand personalities with visual images is pervasive (ranging from depictions of social types like the American cowboy to scenes like cityscapes) yet at the same time ad hoc and often left to the discretion of individual art directors. Our research program will enable us to systematically and empirically construct a visual lexicon of brand personality that can link the meanings evoked by a standardized set of images with apparel brands. The method we are developing will allow us to generate a visual meaning map for each apparel brand we study. We will analyze these meaning maps to gauge the consistency of meanings among consumers and relate them to financial and market measures of brand performance. Visual meaning maps can also inform brand managers how best to visually depict the intended meanings of their brands.

Publications

  • Fournier, Susan G., Michael R. Solomon, and Basil G. Englis, Brand Resonance, in ed. Bernd Schmitt, Handbook on Brand and Experience Management, Elgar Publishing, 2007, in press.


Progress 01/01/05 to 12/31/05

Outputs
The first objective is to identify apparel brands that will be used in the research. This task is underway; we are constructing a set of brands to be used as stimuli in the data collection task. We are also continuing to develop the theoretical framework that integrates and captures the different personality meaning dimensions for the apparel brands that will be used in the research. Pilot testing of brand meanings is scheduled to commence in January/February 2006.

Impacts
This project contributes to the AAES mandate to enhance the market competitiveness of Alabama cotton-based products through the development of better understanding of consumer/ brand relationships within the apparel and home furnishings sectors. The apparel industry in particular has increasingly become a commodity market; this puts U.S. manufacturers at a distinct disadvantage owing to their higher cost structure. As opposed to competing with foreign manufacturers on price, a key to successful market differentiation for U.S. firms is the value-added of a branded garment that is provided by marketing efforts to develop a clear and desirable brand personality. The apparel industry needs a set of metrics that will measure consumers associations with brands and that will let it assess the potential market impact of linking specific imagery with branding development strategies. This project will develop such a set of metrics. And, this methodology will provide a model for application to other Alabama-based products such as home textiles and foods.

Publications

  • Michael R. Solomon, Transfer of Power: The Hunter Gets Captured by the Game, Marketing Research, Spring 2005: 26-31.