Source: NORTHEASTERN UNIVERSITY submitted to
COMPREHENSIVE ASSAY FOR CARCINOGENS IN FOOD
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
TERMINATED
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1006693
Grant No.
2015-67030-23755
Project No.
MASW-2014-09023
Proposal No.
2014-09023
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Program Code
A1801
Project Start Date
Jul 15, 2015
Project End Date
Jul 14, 2017
Grant Year
2015
Project Director
Giese, R. W.
Recipient Organization
NORTHEASTERN UNIVERSITY
360 HUNTINGTON AVE
BOSTON,MA 02115
Performing Department
Pharmaceutical Sciences
Non Technical Summary
Currently, many different tests are required to test for carcinogens in foods since there are many kinds of such carcinogens and each test only measures one kind. Another shortcoming of current tests is their limited ability to discover or identify unknown food carcinogens. We propose to overcome both of these problems by setting up a "super test" with broad detection, discovery and specificity capability. In this new test, a food extract is exposed to a bait molecule functioning as a target for carcinogens. Once the carcinogens "take the bait" they become much more detectable. If successful, this project will help to reduce the incidence of cancer from dietary carcinogens. The diet is considered to be a major source of the carcinogens to which humans are exposed.
Animal Health Component
0%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
50%
Applied
25%
Developmental
25%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
71150101150100%
Goals / Objectives
The long term goal of this project is to set up a novel, practical, omic-type assay for food carcinogens that becomes widely employed. By "omic-type assay" we mean that this assay detects a diversity of carcinogens, both known and unknown, in a single procedure. In this assay, a bait molecule is employed to trap food carcinogens, in order to make them very detectable by mass spectrometry. The Supporting Objectives for ths project are as follows. Objective 1.Prepare an easily-harvested, response-normalizing, highly-sensitive, modified DNA nucleobase to function as a bait for carcinogens. Objective 2. Set up a sample preparation procedure permitting the detection of a model, spiked, pre-adducted nucleobase bait in overcooked meat. Objective 3. Apply the method to overcooked meat and detect multiple carcinogens.
Project Methods
Methods and Feasibility. To achieve Objective 1: A guanine-bait compound will be synthesized. Purification of the intermediate compounds and final product will be accomplished by crystallization, precipitation, or chromatography (TLC, flash, or preparative HPLC). Structures will be confirmed by mass spectrometry or NMR. The conditions for the synthesis will be adopted from those used in the literature to convert guanine to N2-acylguanine products. We will take advantage of our experience in progressively replacing the bromo groups on α,α´-dibromo-o-xylene with triethylamine and a nucleomonomer. Feasibility goal for Objective 1: The quanine-bait compound is synthesized and readily detected (< fmol level) by MALDI-TOF-MS.To achieve Objective 2, we will form a pre-adducted guanine bait by reacting our guanine-bait compound with methyl iodide-d3 to methylate the guanine moiety (no doubt mostly on the N7 and N9 positions). A hamburger will be fried in canola oil until well done (noting the time and heat setting), cut into pieces, transferred to a blender with a buffer that is compatible with S9, spiked with the pre-adducted guanine-bait, and placed on a shaker. This will be followed by addition of magnetic streptavidin beads (from Thermo-Pierce) and further shaking. The streptavidin beads will be harvested with a magnet, washed with buffer (initial buffer may contain Tween to reduce nonspecific binding) and then water. After drying, the pre-adducted guanine-bait will be eluted from the beads with warm aqueous acetonitrile. An aliquot will be combined with CCA matrix for detection by MALDI-TOF/TOF-MS. Feasibility goal for Objective 2: the pre-adducted guanine-bait is readily detected (< pmol level) after spiking into a homogenized, cooked hamburger.To achieve Objective 3, we will take advantage of the conditions that emerge from our work on Objective 2. The same kind of assay will be performed, including the addition of the above pre-adducted guanine-bait as one internal standard, and the proximate carcinogen benzo[a]pyrene-d12 as model carcinogen. Guanine-bait will be added as well, along with human liver S9 microsomes (obtained from Life Technologies). Feasibility goal for Objective 3: Multiple (n > 5) carcinogens (defined here as genotoxic chemicals) are detected in cooked hamburger in a single procedure.

Progress 07/15/15 to 07/14/17

Outputs
Target Audience: The primary stakeholders are the testing laboratories for the quality and safety of foods. Changes/Problems: None. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?The postdoctoral student, Pushkar Kulkarni, underwent training and professional development. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?By this publication: Shao, G., Agar, J., Giese, R. W. (2017) Cold-Induced Aqueous Acetonitrile Phase Separation: A Salt Free Way to Begin QuEChERS, J. Chromatogr. A 1506, 128-133. doi.org/10.1016/j.chroma.2017.05.045 What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?The phase 1 project has been completed.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? A1. Non-Technical Summary We were funded by the NIFA Exploratory Research Program for the project, "Comprehensive Assay for Carcinogens in Food". The basic idea of the project was to detect carcinogenic chemicals (carcinogens) universally in foods in a single procedure. There are three steps in the proposed method: (1) extract carcinogens from the food; (2) activate the procarcinogens metabolically to their corresponding genotoxic (DNA-reactive) products (ultimate carcinogens) in the presence of a Bait reagent that traps these latter products covalently; and (3) detect the resulting carcinogen-Bait conjugates by mass spectrometry. Two types of Bait reagents have been studied. The first type comprises a mass tag to make carcinogen-Bait conjugates very sensitive in the mass spectrometer, along with a nucleophilic moiety to react with genotoxic chemicals (essentially all organic genotoxic chemicals are electrophilic). We selected a cationic xylyl (Cmass tag for the first type of Bait, since it can provide detection at the amol level; it is an anchimeric-assisted neutral loss cationic tag. The second Bait is DNA. Following is the progress that we have made. We will first discuss the type 1 category of Baits (CAX-Baits, of which there are four), and then the type 2 Bait (DNA) A2. Progress Details A2a. Strategy for Developing a CAX-Bait Reagent We chose to compare the performance of four types of CAX-Bait reagents in order to select an optimum one for our assay of carcinogens in foods. The four criteria for selection of the best CAX-Bait were: (1) ease of synthesis; (2) efficiency of reaction with model genotoxic chemicals; (3) ability of the Bait to capture a diversity of electrophilic chemicals; and (4) stability of the Bait-carcinogen conjugates. A2b. Bait I: N2-CAX-G The guanine (G) nucleobase of DNA is a prominent target for electrophilic chemicals in general, so we selected two CAX-guanine Baits for study. In the first one ( Bait I) the CAX mass tag is attached to the N2 position of guanine, leaving the other nitrogen atoms along with the O6 and C8 atoms of guanine available for reaction with an electrophilic chemical. We prepared Bait I and tested it by reaction with benzyl bromide as a model genotoxic chemical. The reaction was efficient and yielded a stable product with a strong response in the mass spectrometer. The actual site of attachment of the benzyl moiety to the Bait is unknown; the site shown is arbitrary. Shortcomings of Bait I: its synthesis is tedious, and it lacks an ability to capture aldehyde carcinogens efficiently or at all. A2c. Bait II: C8-CAX-G In this Bait reagent, the CAX mass tag is attached to the C8 position of guanine. Also, a biotin moiety is incorporated to facilitate the isolation of a corresponding CAX-guanine-carcinogen product. While Bait II can capture aldehydes, reaction of the resulting Schiff bases with sodium borohydride would be necessary to stabilize the products by reduction. Otherwise Bait II basically has the same advantages and disadvantages as Bait I. A2d. Bait III: CAX-Hydrazide This bait (CAX-Hydrazide, abbreviated CAX-H) comprises a CAX mass tag attached to the C4-position of phenylhydrazide. It is easy to prepare, and reacts efficiently with benzyl bromide to give a stable product with a strong response in the mass spectrometer. This encouraged us to evaluate Bait III further by reacting it with a mixture of model carcinogens including benzyl bromide. Some representative, model carcinogens are detected simultaneously in this way: acetaldehyde; chloroacetaldehyde; benzoquinone; benzaldehyde, and styrene oxide. We then applied Bait III to an extract of cooked hamburger, and several aldehydes were detected. We were particularly pleased with the performance of the Bait III, although the hydrazone products of aldehydes would need to be processed under nonacidic conditions. A2e. Bait IV: CAX-Aniline This Bait comprises a CAX mass tag attached to the C4-position of aniline. While this Bait is easy to prepare, its reaction with benzyl bromide is slower than that of Bait III. Nevertheless it forms stable products after reduction with sodium cyanoborohydride that give a strong response in the mass spectrometer Bait IV provides an option for detecting aldehyde carcinogens in a way that should be more rugged, as needed, than Bait III, due to stability of the reduced products with Bait IV under both acidic and basic conditions A2f: New Kind of QuEChERS. The QuEChERS (quick, easy, cheap, effective, rugged, safe) procedure is widely employed for extraction of pesticides and other contaminants in foods, as has been reviewed (Rejczak and Tuzimski, 2015; Han, et al., 2016). We set up a modified QuEChERS procedure in which the initial phase separation is accomplished by a cold-induced phase separation rather than by adding salt, potentially making it easier to subject the sedimented matrix to further extraction for more complete isolation of carcinogens (Shao and Giese, 2017). The method was applied to salmon and beef. A QuEChERS procedure (many variations are in practice) is a good choice for extracting carcinogens from foods for detection. A2g. Melt-Labeling Assay for DNA adducts We have set up a convenient assay for detection of DNA adducts that will meet the needs of this project for DNA as the type 2 Bait. We refer to this assay as a "melt-labeling assay". The method relies on the preferential melting (as by increasing the temperature) of local DNA structure around a structure-destabilizing adduct (many DNA adducts weaken or distort local DNA structure; nucleotide excision repair relies on this property). The melted zone, including labeling-susceptible adducts there, is preferentially labeled with a mass tag (we have used CAXto date; "cationic xylyl bromide") A2h. Detection of Benzoquinone DNA adducts by Melt-Labeling with CAX-B. Quinones are a class of food carcinogens. A benzoquinone-exposed sample of DNA (100 μg) containing a known concentration of BQ-C (referring to BQ-dCMP; about 23 adducts in 106 nucleotides) was subjected to melt-labeling with CAX-B. the previously unknown adduct, BQ-hmC (referring to BQ-hydroxymethyl-dCMP) was detected at S/N of 70. Considering that mC is 4% of C in DNA, and assuming that hydroxymethyl-deoxycytosine is 1% of methyldeoxycytosine, then the level of BQ-hmdCMP being detected at observed S/N = 70 in the lower mass spectrum corresponds to 4 BQ-hmdCMP in 109 nucleotides. Thus, CAX-B melt labeling/LC-MALDI-TOF/TOF-MS can be very sensitive. A3. References Cited 1. De Jongh, H., Berthuis, R. K., Vies, R. O., Barrett, C. B., Ord, W. O. (1962) Investigation of the factor in ground peanut meal responsible for "Turkey X disease", Biochim. Biophs. Acta 65, 548-551. Han, L., Sapozhnikova, Y., Lehotay, S. J. (2016) Method validation for 243 pesticides and environmental contaminants in meats and poultry by tandem mass spectrometry coupled to low-pressure gas chromatography and ultrahigh-performance liquid chromatography, Food Control. 66, 270-282. doi: org/10.1016/foodcont.2016.02.019 Rejczak, T., Tuzimski, T. (2015) A review of recent developments and trends in the QuEChERS sample preparation approach, Open Chem. 13, 980-1010. doi: 10.1515/chem-2015-0109 Shao, G., Agar, J., Giese, R. W. (2017) Cold-Induced aqueous acetonitrile phase separation: A salt -free way to begin quick, easy, cheap, effect, rugged, safe, J. Chromatogr. A 1506,128-133. doi:10.1016/j.chroma.2017.05.045

Publications

  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Accepted Year Published: 2017 Citation: Shao, G., Agar, J., Giese, R. W. (2017) Cold-Induced Aqueous Acetonitrile Phase Separation: A Salt-Free Way to Begin QuEChERS, J. Chromatogr. A 1506, 128-133. doi.org/10.1016/j.chroma.2017.05.045.


Progress 07/15/15 to 07/14/16

Outputs
Target Audience:The target audience is the Department of Agriculture, the FDA, and the food industry. Changes/Problems:None What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?A postdoctoral organic chemist was hired and he is learning the skills of an analytical chemist including the use of trace labeling, sample extraction, chromatography, and mass spectrometry. He will emerge from this project as an organic analytical chemist, increasing his professional credentials. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?This is on hold until we file a patent application. But the project has led to a grant application to DOD to discover carcinogens that contribute to breast cancer. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?We will next continue our work on Objective 2. First we will optimize the harvesting step for the bait in buffer. Next we will be testing model carcinogins in buffer using S9 to optimize this step. We will then proceed to apply our method to a meat extract. This latter extract will be formed by applying a QuERChERS type of procedure to homogenized, overcooked meat. Completion of this work will enable us to proceed to the experiment of Objective 3.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? We have accomplished Objective 1. A bait molecule having three key parts was synthesized: nucleobase part to trap carcinogens, cationic signal part for high sensitivity detection, and biotin part for harvesting on streptavidin particles. This bait was successful in detecting a model carcinogen with high sensitivity. We have not accomplished Objectives 2 and 3 so far, but we have started to work on Objective 2, by designing a sample preparation procedure including the use of S9 for carcinogen activation.

Publications